Madonna, Clay Aiken in Top 50 Worst Songs Ever

Our friends at Blender Magazine have published a terrific list of the "Worst 50 Songs Ever." (A quick hat tip to them for not writing Worst. 50. Songs. Ever.) Big names like Madonna and Clay Aiken we're right near the top.

Clay's "invisible" comes in at #11. Blender says:

"It's not just the schmaltzy play for loser pity ("If I was invisible - wait, I already am"). It's not just the ridiculously purple lyrics. And it's not just the thought of Aiken's eternally asymmetrical porcupine 'do quivering as he soars into a high note. It's the whole hey-girl-I-want-to-watch-you-while-you-think-you're-alone-in-your-bedroom thing that transforms this song from a merely mediocre ballad to a disturbing voyeur fantasy, filling your head with images of Aiken downloading porn and thinking bad things about that girl from homeroom. What lurks in the hearts of lonely geeks? Clay Aiken knows, and it's not pretty." 



Madonna didn't escape Blender's wrath either. "American Life" is at #10: 

"On which Madonna updates the "Material Girl"–era satire of commercialism and spiritual emptiness - but this time, she does it with what is hands-down the most embarrassing rap ever recorded. Nervous and choppy, she makes Debbie Harry sound as smooth as Jay-Z. The only thing worse than shouting "soy latte"? Rhyming it with "double shot-ay." The rhymes don't kick in for a full three minutes, but the song - propelled by a constipated digital beat and some bungled musings on celebrity culture - stinks the whole way through. "

Hey, Beavis they said "constipated"  - Uh huh huh huh.  Notably, Limp Bizkit comes in at #4, with "Rollin'" - my question is how did the rest of the Bizkit catalog escape the list?

Reader Comments

(Page 5 of 6) Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

61. Your opinion of Clay's song (which he didn't pick) is about like saying
Frank Sinatra should have been a ditch digger. Get some talent for your
craft and get with the program, which by the way is CLAY!!!!!! FOREVER.

Posted at 10:18PM on Jun 27th 2006 by Kathy

62. Ok... I think you are doing Clay a lot of wrong if you say the "Invisible" song is about porno. There's nothing wrong with it ; on the contrary, it is a very beautiful love song that gave me chills the first time I heard it. And when Clay sings it at concerts, there's just so much joy brought out from him that is amazing! But of course you do not understand, even if I explained it you. You know why? Because it can not be put into words, you have to feel it!

What I can explain to you and what I hope you understand, is that this song is sung by the best pop singer ever, so please don't go telling absurdities about porno stuff and doing-bad-things-to-girls.

I will not tell you to apologize for this article, because I know you won't do it, but don't you ever publish another bunch of nonsense like this.

And before I quit, let me suggest you something, okay? Go buy his CD, sit down on a sofa with a cool drink and enjoy, 'cause what you got there is REAL SINGING!

Posted at 7:20PM on Jun 29th 2006 by Doudou

63. I totally agree with Doudou's message below!

Yo, Blender, buddy, you really need some brain therapy! It's with extreme pleasure that I will lead you to the nearest asylum. Just give me a sign when you're ready!

Ok, let's make it clear between us : this list sucks!

And Clay rules!!! He will always rule! No matter what cranks like you say or do!

Posted at 7:44PM on Jun 29th 2006 by Wendy

64. I totally agree with that Doudou said!

Yo, Blender, buddy, you really need some brain therapy! It's with great pleasure that I'll lead you to the nearest asylum! Just give me a sign when you're ready, okay?

Let's make all this clear between us, buddy : your list sucks!

And Clay rules!! And he will always rule! No matter what cranks like you say or do!

Posted at 7:51PM on Jun 29th 2006 by Wendy

65. Oh... the writer is just jealous of CLAY!!!

Posted at 11:57PM on Jun 29th 2006 by -nobita-

66. heyy i love clay...well i don't listen to him. but i lvoe his new look. wow he's hot! haha guys with shags are AEWSOME!! haha

dianaa.

Posted at 9:47PM on Jul 2nd 2006 by diana

67. Clay Aiken's Voice is one of the best, if not the best in the music industrie to date. To knock him now that he made it to the top is just typical. First they lift him up and because he came in second and he should have won. Now they try to knock him down, because this always happens to the stars. As soon as they are big, lets find flaws !!!!!!!! The man is a gift to us. His voice is a gift . I just hope one day he will sing "Ave Maria" on his Christmas Album. His Jukebox Tour music was outstanding. The last singer I was this impressed with was Elvis. YOU GO CLAY !!!!!! SING !!!!!!!!!

Posted at 12:47PM on Jul 3rd 2006 by R. Hatfield

68. Madonna shouldn't have been on the list your moron. There are other songs that should, for example, the ones YOU sing!!
Give Clay credit for at least having talent . He can really sing the hell out of any song. Like him or not the dude can really sing!!!!!!!!! All these "macho" rappers don't sing, they stomp and spit their filth all over the stage. Back to Madonna, she may not be the greatest singer, but she still kicks ass.The next one could be yours. I can only hope!!

Posted at 8:17PM on Jul 7th 2006 by hilda

69. I haven't heard much of Clay, but Madonna is great. I love the entire CD, not just American Life, the single. Leave my girl alone. She's the best.

Posted at 3:56AM on Jul 9th 2006 by Enemy of the Republic

70. What!Clay DIDNT even write that song!!!!!!!!!!!The one looking up the porn is his writters!!!!!!Put them up as the blam for the bad song!!!!!!!!Anyway invisible is an awsome song!!!!!!Its about someone in LOVE!!!!!!Not some pervert!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 4:51PM on Jul 19th 2006 by Clay Aiken Fan

71. I can not believe you would write junk like that about Clay unless you are looking to be noticed. For interviews that have come out, Clays fans are the most loyal out there. I am one of those fans and I hope you go to, can not say it but you know what I mean.

Posted at 11:55AM on Jul 20th 2006 by Pat Brandenburg

72. You obviously aren't listening to the complete lyrics and message behind 'Invisible'. It's about loving someone who doesn't notice them.
And as far as stalker type songs, every time I hear " Every step you take, every move you make, I'll be watching you" is still the worst ever made, and I hear it constantly on the radio. A truly creepy and real stalker song! They should consider putting that at the top of the list!

Posted at 3:24AM on Jul 23rd 2006 by Margie Anderson

73. i think this is stupid. clay doest care what you think. you guys SUCK.

Posted at 12:05PM on Jul 26th 2006 by no name sry

74. How old are the Blender critics . they dissed not only Clay and Madonna but many outstanding artists. Where does this list generate from? Some of us grew up with this music, and looooved every minute of it, including Clay .No matter what anyone thinks of Clay that man can sing circles around many of todays artists, AND hes singing all the way to the bank....SING CLAY SING !!!!!

Posted at 9:25AM on Jul 28th 2006 by music fan

75. Oh...I would agree wholeheartedly!!! Everytime I hear that song it makes me want run and hide my ears.....of course, though we know he didn't write it.....he was just allowing his producers/and or A & R guys to run him....No balls Clay......get some GOOD writers for a change. Don't be a push-over anymore....

Posted at 1:14PM on Aug 8th 2006 by eric colver

Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments