Jessica Takes A "Holiday"?

Madonna might be more than a little surprised when she hears the title track and first single off of Jessica Simpson's new album "A Public Affair."

The single appears to bear a striking resemblance to Madonna's 1983 hit "Holiday."  In fact, the songs sounds eerily similar.

From the synth-pop beat to the jangly guitars in the beginning, to the eight-note motifs in the verses to the choruses that begin on an A and the use of the same key (B-minor), the two songs are so similar that, in a highly unscientific poll, every person to whom TMZ played "A Public Affair" identified it as "Holiday."   Will Jellybean Benitez (who produced the original) be getting royalties for this? 

TMZ called a rep for Madonna, but as of yet our calls have not been returned. As for Jessica, her rep tells TMZ "It is a fun summer single and comparing to retro Madonna is flattering!"

But don't trust our ears: You be the judge. Listen to Jessica's "A Public Affair" and Madonna's "Holiday" to compare.



Reader Comments

(Page 4 of 34) Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

46. This comparison only proves what I already knew...that Madonna's music is timeless! You know the ol’ expression: Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Yes, there are similarities, but focus, people, F O C U S! At least Jessica Simple did not "oversing" the lyrics - as she so often does. Forget that last part. AS SHE ALWAYS DOES.

Oh, and by the way...I like your video of this song...it’s so much more watch-able than Jessica's over-emphasized facial expressions. I’m sure they’re as painful to perform as they are to watch!

Posted at 7:59PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Joanne

47. This comparison only proves what I already knew...that Madonna's music is timeless! You know the ol’ expression: Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Yes, there are similarities, but focus, people, F O C U S! At least Jessica Simple did not "oversing" the lyrics - as she so often does. Forget that last part. AS SHE ALWAYS DOES.

Oh, and by the way...I like your video of this song...it’s so much more watch-able than Jessica's over-emphasized facial expressions. I’m sure they’re as painful to perform as they are to watch!

Posted at 7:59PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Joanne

48. Head over to www.uglyonline.com to listen to two new Christina songs and the new Kelly Clarkson single!

Posted at 8:01PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Giuseppe

49. I think its time people wake up and realize that Jessica Simpson is a Soul-Less, Cold, Organic Vector. Too many unaware people are carried away by her body. Look deep into her eyes and you will see nothing but DARKNESS. She is Ruthless , Arrogant, Stupid and Programmed to Hurt and Devour the Life Essence of men. I feel very sorry for Nick Lachey who does have a Soul and Feelings, and who was deeply hurt by her Imperious, Hauty, Egotism. What she did to Nick and Madonna is only the beginning of what you can expect to see, so stay focused. Does anyone realize she couldn't even write out a check until recently?? If you're going to pick someone to idealize, at least pick someone with some Real Talent and Soul Substance!!!

Posted at 8:18PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by William

50. Oh, please!!! What's the BIG deal? Don't almost all starS steal the sound from other songs? I have heard my share of songs that sound just like other songs and no one says a d... thing! People please stop hating! I am not really a Jessica fan, and I really don't like this song, but fair is fair... EVERYONE DOES IT!

Posted at 8:21PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Nat

51. Who hasn't duplicated the same sound from an old song? There aren't any new tunes for these "Pop Singers" to sing or write about any more. Chech out some tunes from the 70's & 80's, you will be surprise to hear what was copied, notes that were barrowed and what was remixed.

Posted at 8:22PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by bam

52. OUCH.... I hope it won't be the best song on the album..Maybe after I listen to it a couple 100 times it will grow on me..sounds kind of Juevenile. I know she thinks she is young but in the music business she is old and should do song to show that she isn't going through her mid-life crisis already. Sounds like bubblegum music trying to act sultry..I am sure we won't care about the song anyways once her video comes out since her looks is the only thing that sells about her..As for ripping off Holiday, yeah same music no doubt, no originality as usual from her music.. Her biggest mistakes. 1. getting rid of a man that loved you for you, not your looks and listening to your dad way to much, it does border line on the side of sick how obsessed he is with your life. As for the song....I really really really hope the video is reveiling in order to distract us from the song.

Posted at 9:00PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Jessica gone wrong

53. Jessica totally ripped off Madonna....how unoriginal if she cant even come up with her own "vibe"....she is just trying anything because Nick's album is doing awesome and he is doing better without her....Note to Jess, your songs not so hot, and neither are you anymore....GO TEAM NICK!

Posted at 9:01PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Tintimidator3

54. The song is a complete RIP off !!! I agree with previous comments...Jessica can not come up with any material of her own. She knows that the little kids that like her music will not recognize that they are remakes. Madonna is awesome, she is always willing to change with the times. Looks like Nick will win the competition of who has the better music, and the better morals.

Posted at 9:05PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by Lisa

55. ahhhhh!! How bad was that! All she does is "re-make" everyone elses songs, and she RUINES them!!! Please go away Jessica !!!! I hate to say it but I would rather listen to a Ashly Simpson song!!

Posted at 9:18PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by amber

56. Jessica, don't listen to those jeolous clowns. Your song is great, I listened to it 10 times, and I love it. You didn't rip off anyone. Their still mad that you left Nick.People, just be honest for once. This song is good, and I can't wait to dance to it! love ya jess

Posted at 9:20PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by patty

57. love your song, not ripped off at all. everyone jeolous of you jess. their mad cause you left nick. well, i love ya jess. your great in everything you set out to do. jess is a hard worker. not easy to put an album out, and be in a movie too. you multi-task very well jess. fan forever

Posted at 9:23PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by patty

58. everything you do turns to gold. great song, will be a hit! isn't it funny how people turn on you when ya split. good fans these guys are! love the song, voice sounds great. Light, fun & sexy song for the summer, perfect choice. wanted to keep listening to it.

Posted at 9:32PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by patty

59. Wonder if one of them will claim to be 'like a virgin'

Posted at 9:39PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by doug

60. omg.just calm down people!I think it is actually a cool song.u people are just wanting to say something about her cause u have nothing else to do with ur lives,oh yea there is alot of people that have made like remakes of songs and has the same beat as other artists and I bet u wont say anything about them.so hush u people!u rock jess!

Posted at 10:13PM on Jun 23rd 2006 by nicole

Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments