Celebrity Justice
Lawsuit Over "Pirates of the Caribbean"

Pirates of the CaribbeanA Hollywood screenwriter is suing pretty much everyone involved with "Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl," the first installment of the now record-breaking "Pirates" series.

Royce Mathew claims in the 80s and 90s, he "created and wrote a number of original works including drawings, screenplays, outlines, blueprints, storyboards and other original materials...which he generally entitled "SNPM," standing for 'Super Natural Pirate Movie.'"

According to the lawsuit, obtained by TMZ and filed in United States District Court, Central District of California, Royce alleges he created "various drawings depicting his pirate ship, which he named the Black Pearl, and an original design for a 'medallion,' both of which are are central elements of his screenplay." Royce says he registered the drawings and his screenplay with the U.S. Copyright Office.

Royce says the screenplay contained a blacksmith/swordsman named Will Turner, an eccentric pirate captain and a unique cursed crew whose curse was revealed only in the moonlight. Royce claims the daughter of a British governor named Elizabeth falls in love with Will Turner. In "Pirates of the Caribbean," Orlando Bloom plays Will Turner and Keira Knightley plays Elizabeth Swann, who falls in love with Will Turner.



In the lawsuit, Royce says he shopped his materials between 1991 through 1995 to various defendants, both directly and through the William Morris Agency and Creative Artist Agency. Royce claims his materials were rejected and then the first "Pirates of the Caribbean" was created, allegedly using his work as a blueprint.

The first "Pirates" movie raked in $655 million worldwide.

Royce is suing, among others, The Walt Disney Company, Buena Vista Home Entertainment, Touchstone Home Video, Jerry Bruckheimer, Inc., and Walt Disney Parks and Resorts, Inc. He is asking for unspecified damages and an injunction prohibiting the defendants from publicly displaying the movie.

Royce is also asking that all copies of "Pirates" that the defendants control be impounded.

Although the lawsuit does not mention the two "Pirates" sequels, it does ask the judge to issue an injunction against the first "Pirates" and "other infringing works."

A Disney spokewoman says the suit "has no merit."

Click here to see the documents.

Tags: johnny depp, JohnnyDepp, keira knightley, KeiraKnightley, orlando bloom, OrlandoBloom, pirates of the caribbean, PiratesOfTheCaribbean

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 3) Previous 15 Comments

31. If you read the lawsuit then you'll see that it says that after he saw the movie then he went searching for his original works and only then did he send it in to have the copyright registered. He's going to have to prove that he actually created them before that date or Disney has won. As for the name Pirates of the Caribbean, he just called his version "Super Natural Pirate Movie" (SNPM as they refer to it in the document). But here's what the Gov. Trademark site says about the trademark for "Pirates of the Caribbean" and I think that Disney can prove that it was first used in 1967 a lot easier than he can prove that he wrote the ideas for the movie 10 years ago.

Word Mark : PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN
Goods and Services IC 041. US 100 101 107. G & S: Amusement park services.
FIRST USE: 1967-03-18.
FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 1967-03-18
Serial Number 78305615
Filing Date September 25, 2003
Disney Enterprises, Inc.

uspto.gov has patents and trademarks if you care to look it up. That's the US Patent and Trademark Office site.

Only time and the courts will tell. But I'm sure Disney and Bruckheimer have lawyers that can beat his lawyer up any day. They've got more $$ to pay them than this guy will ever have. It may come down to that in the end sadly enough for the writers out there cheering him on.

Me, I'm torn, I love the movies and don't want an injunction on them, but on the other hand it'd be awesome if he could actually beat out Disney, especially if he's in the right. Maybe he's just hoping they'll go for an out of court settlement to shut him up and he'll get lots of $$.

Posted at 1:51AM on Jul 15th 2006 by RAT

32. yeah disney do good stuff sometimes and kids love them
but its sad to see how many people think the disney company is almost godlike and above the law
the names of the characters Will Turner and Elizabeth and other facts are indisputable evidence that Royces idea has been nicked
it sounds like he worked hard on his idea over many years and he must have been in shock when he realised he was up against a giant
i dont think the films should be withdrawn but he can be recognised as creator and back-paid substantial royalties ... and Disney should sack a few people and give Royce an office

Posted at 10:04PM on Jul 15th 2006 by p jeynes

33. I would like pitates of the caribbean

Posted at 11:07AM on Jul 16th 2006 by conor boswell

34. Yeah Right !! That guy just wants some $ for himself!!!!! WHAT A JERK !!!

Posted at 11:53PM on Aug 6th 2006 by Cutedlc

35. don't you think if disney really stole this guy's idea they might have changed a few of the details to try to avoid this kind of thing...?

Posted at 1:32PM on Aug 13th 2006 by kristina

Previous 15 Comments