Celebrity Justice
Exclusive: Prosecutor in Gibson Case Removed

TMZ has learned the prosecutor who filed DUI charges against Mel Gibson has been removed from the case.

Ralph Shapiro, the Deputy in Charge at the Malibu branch of the D.A.'s office, has been taken off the case. The new deputy D.A. is Gina Satriano, who is currently handling the case against Rodney Alcala, accused of mass murder. In the past, Satriano prosecuted Courtney Love for assault.

We're told the switch occurred late last week. TMZ contacted D.A. Spokesperson Sandi Gibbons, who said the switch "was not the least bit unusual." Gibbons added that supervisors routinely file cases and then are replaced by trial deputies.

TMZ noted four cases to Gibbons in which the Deputy in Charge personally handled a high-profile case -- Shapiro's predecessor in Malibu, Lonnie Peterson, handled cases against Nick Nolte, Nicole Richie. Deputies in Charge also handled cases against Zsa Zsa Gabor and the accused killer of model Linda Sobek. Gibbons responded by saying those were "four cases out of tens of thousands of cases," repeating that it is typical to give cases to "experienced trial lawyers."

Shapiro, who is Jewish, could not be reached for comment. As TMZ first reported, Gibson hurled several anti-semitic comments at the arresting deputy, though the comments are not the basis of the prosecution's case.


Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 7) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

31. HarveyHarveyHarvey...So is this worth it---deliberately stirring up animosity on both sides for the sake of ratings and your new-found fame? TV contracts anyone? You are so myopic that you will never truly grasp the far-reaching consequences of your actions and for that I grieve for you, me and the rest of humanity.

Hmmm.... I wonder who in this entire sordid affair is the most despicable: the drunken fool or the wily weasel who exploits people's weaknesses for personal gain.

Posted at 6:09AM on Aug 8th 2006 by nina

32. Let Mel heal in peace already,

On the news:
Stop Attacking Mel Gibson, Put up or Shut up, link:
http://blog.americasnewstoday.com/2006/08/02/stop-attacking-mel-gibson-put-up-or-shut-up.aspx

Posted at 6:10AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Larry The Cable Guy

33. LOL at the idiots who act as though Mel Gibson spoke to the U.N. or at a public rally, or even an interview.

Newsflash: it was 2:30AM, he spoke to a (jewish) cop, DRUNK off his mind. This story IS being blown out of proportion. Maybe, just maybe, you can argue that it isn't IF he was speaking publicly (not privately to a cop while drunk) and/or he didn't apologize (which he did). But that isn't the case here, MOVE ON. ridiculous shit like this really dimishes real claims of serious antisemitism. And it makes you all seem too sensitive, unforgiving, vindicative and hypocritical.

I am Asian American and i have the media, films, tv, AND people, celebrities and noncelebrities, say offensive things about my people all the time. IF Mel had said "Asians" to an Asian cop and went off drunk on a HIGHWAY AND then apologized, i KNOW that my community would not be this petty. Additionally, the media would not have covered it this extensively.

I am still waiting for MY apology when Sarah Silverman, a JEWISH comic, called my people "chinks" on the Conan O'Brien show and then REFUSED to apologize, even slandering an activist who demanded one.

beating this story to death and blowing it out of proportion only makes you look hypocritical. i hope one day you people who hate will be judged NOT by how you lived for 50 years but by a single drunken moment. hypocrites.

Posted at 6:24AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Vicky

34. the so-called jewish conspiracy you complain about is not the issue at hand. We have the facts: that mel gibson said derogatory drunken remarks about jews. The media outet and its intentions with the story is not the point. The remarks were said and therefore they reflect on mel gibson's character. be childish and see his movies out of spite. (they all suck anyway) but if any slight remark about christians was made, the source of the news would not even be an issue. people would be angry at the CONTENT of the remarks whether or not it was heresay.

Posted at 6:30AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Mitch

35. And onther issue I need to raise is Rob Schneider. Dont get me wrong I think he is a hillarious actor. the first date my hubby ever took me on we saw Deuce Bigalo and laughed the whole night! HOWEVER< for him to put a huge ad in a paper stating he would NEVER work with Mel gibson because of his comment is just outta control. I mean come on people whens the last movie you saw them working together anyways? Let me think...NONE!!! If he had actually done movies with him the ad still would have been stupid but at least he would have made an opinion. The fact he's NEVER worked with him to star with just made the ad just ridiculous!
Brenda

Posted at 6:49AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Brenda

36. 13. l wonder what mel would think if l were intoxicated and said mels religion has people in it that molest young children in his church and ruin some of thier lives.

Posted at 12:00AM on Aug 8th 2006 by scott levy

It;s said all the time - especially in papers like the NY Times. A paper that also defended manure smeared pictures of Christian images as art. But wasn't so tolerant when an artist depicted art that made light of the Holocaust.
What he said wasn't right but last time I checked we still had freedom of spech. As long as he doesn't advocate the killing of folks, believe it or not, he doesn't have to like Jews, homosexuals, or any other group. The CRIME is the DWI.

Posted at 7:07AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Chirraighe

37. Maybe Mel's trail will be like his last movie, in a forgein obscure language. Isn't his lastest movie the same way. I know I'm not impressed by all these subtitled movies, but I'll not pay $ 10.00 to see a subtitled movie again. If he not happy with america and americanactors he can go join Russel Crowe. But to get back to the present.. He screwed up and now has to eat dirt. Go into rehab and fake it like the rest. You'll be forgiven. Like Aways.

Posted at 7:19AM on Aug 8th 2006 by rosemary

38. It must be nice to be so perfect. For all the people criticizing Mel Gibson, look in your own backyard first. Can you honestly say that you have never made a mistake, or said something that you wished you hadn't?? It amazes me, that all these self-righteous loud mouths have nothing better to do then to slam someone for making a mistake. Is your life that boring or empty that you have the time to criticize others?? All I can say is keep your nose out of other people's business and the world would be so much better for it.

Posted at 7:22AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Coryjaygreg

39. What's so tragic about all this hoopla is that Mr. Harvey Levin has succeeded in reenforcing the stereotypical Jew- selfish,self-righteous, vindictive and ready to make a quick buck at the expense of the gentiles and his fellow Jews.

Posted at 8:10AM on Aug 8th 2006 by anne

40. it sounds like this has become a bashing ground for people
who have a problem with jews.
its starting to sound like a romper room in here
all this story is attracting are the immoral, simple minded cretins
who are morally bankrupt and ethically inept

Posted at 8:12AM on Aug 8th 2006 by doug

41. Barbara Walters and Rob Schneider are the only people I can think of that would enjoy the updates on Mel Gibson. Barbara the witch from the View said she would never see another Mel Gibson movie. Rob says he will never work with Mel (I'm sure Mel is heart broken about this). There is such a thing as a code of honor. Don't kick someone when they're down. We all make mistakes. I would always look forward to her special on Oscar night. I am only one person but I will never see her specials again. How can she put herself on a pedestal.

Posted at 8:49AM on Aug 8th 2006 by gwen1

42. My gosh people...Leave the man alone already. Who hasn't said some dumb crazy s*** when they are drunk? I know I have. Judge not lest ye be judged. He has apologized and apologized! But that isn't enough for everyone. I never hear anyone apoligizing for blasting the catholic church. No one is perfect not you, not me and not Mel. Forgive and love one another. Can't we all just get along?

Posted at 8:50AM on Aug 8th 2006 by emartinez88

43. DIDN'T MEL DO WHAT ALL ETHNICITIES DO IN PRIVATE...BASH OTHER RACES FOR THEIR PRETTY MUCH ACCURATE GENERAL BAD BEHAVIOR. BECAUSE WE SPEAK THINGS LIKE THIS ABOUT EACH OHTER,,,,WE ARE ALL BIGOTS! I I HAVEN'T MET A RACE THAT DID NOT BASH OTHERS...SO BACK OFF AND GO HOME AND DO THE SAME THING BEHIND YOUR GLASS HOUSE!

Posted at 8:54AM on Aug 8th 2006 by betty damials

44. What you people do not realize is that Mel Gibson attacked ALL of the officers that night on a personal level. The press is making such a big deal about his "anti-Semitic remarks". Well, he had ALOT of nasty things to say, not just the Jewish things. LEAVE HIM ALONE!!! He had a VERY bad night. What's important to remember is that he never went around acting this way in his personal life. Is he a bigot? Honestly, it doesn't matter, as long as he treats people respectfully, which by all indication, he always has. Besides that, he long-time Jewish friends are sticking up for him. This is a witch hunt!

Posted at 8:56AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Kris

45. Let he who is without sin in thought word or dead cast the first stone. Everyone of us sins every day and its a good thing that our words and choices aren't plastered all over the news. Mel made a bad decision and not only he but his whole family will suffer the consequences of it. To place judgement on others we need to first look in the mirror and realize that we have ALL made bigotted comments in some way shape or form and must be grateful that most of the time our words and deads only affect a few and our embarrasment is minimal. What gives anyone of us a right to judge another mans heart? Only God can see the soul of a man and only He has the right to judge.

Posted at 9:15AM on Aug 8th 2006 by Vicki

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments