Celebrity Feuds
Cousteau Family Clash Over Croc Hunter

A very public clash of opinions has broken out between Jean-Michel Cousteau and his nephew Philippe over the late naturalist Steve Irwin -- and it's just the latest face-off in the continuing conflict amongst the scions of the life aquatic's first family.

One source who knows the family tells TMZ that Jean-Michel's remarks yesterday, when he slammed the beloved Irwin for his "very misleading" methods on the same day of his public memorial service, may have been an attempt on the part of Jean-Michel to steal PR thunder from his nephew and is not out of character for Jean-Michel. (Philippe was Irwin's partner on the fateful sea voyage that cost him his life.) Other sources say that the seemingly insensitive remarks are the result of "cultural differences" and that Jean-Michel may not have realized how inflammatory his words might be.

Jean-Michel, who is the eldest son of sea-explorer legend Jacques Cousteau, told reporters that he thought Irwin, in his "Crocodile Hunter" shows and beyond, would "interfere with nature, jump on animals, grab them...It appeals to a lot of people, but I think it's very misleading. You don't touch nature, you just look at it. And that's why I'm still alive." (Jean-Michel also said that he found the death "unfortunate" and said he had "a lot of respect" for Irwin.)


But not a fortnight ago, Philippe paid sincere homage to his producing partner and friend on "Larry King Live," saying he was amazed at "how dedicated Steve was and how much he really loved being out there...and also how much the people around him cared for him." Reps for Jean-Michel, Philippe, the Irwin family, and Discovery Channel did not comment on the spat, but this latest disagreement certainly isn't the first time various factions in the Cousteau family have sparred.

In 2001, Francine Cousteau, Jacques' second (and much younger) wife, took legal action to block Philippe, his sister Alexandra, and his mother Jan from using the name Cousteau Foundation, which was named after Philippe's father, also named Philippe, because it might confuse people who thought it was the Cousteau Society, which she administered. (The elder Philippe died in a seaplane crash in 1979.)

Philippe's relationship with his grandfather wasn't exactly the stuff of Hallmark cards, either. He told a scuba diving publication in 2003 that he saw Jacques, who died in 1997, only a few times a year, and added, "Unfortunately, he was not really a father figure to me." Jean-Michel, for his part, battled with his own father over a resort in Fiji that bore the Cousteau name; Jacques spent his later years trying to prevent his son from exploiting the Cousteau name for tourist profit.

Tags: Jean Michel Cousteau, JeanMichelCousteau, Philippe Cousteau, PhilippeCousteau, Steve Irwin, SteveIrwin

Reader Comments

(Page 5 of 5) Previous 15 Comments

61. Gosh, I hope people don't go to circuses. Wouldn't you say that those animals are being abused and caged. I know I don't go. Also, is anybody perfect. Lay off Steve Irwin, he did a great thing bringing wildlife into our homes so ammatures don't go out and try this and really do some harm to these animmals. I know I would love to get up close and personal but know that it can be harmful and dangerous. God did put these animals here for us, and I myself being a great animal lover, I am glad there are professionals out there to educate me on them.

Posted at 10:38AM on Sep 23rd 2006 by terry

62. I don't think it's a French thing, Jean-Michel is just an asshole. To speak ill of the dead is unforgivable. Why didn't he say something while Steve was alive and could have defended himself if Jean-Michel felt that strongly about it. Sure, Steve took chances, but that's what he wanted to do. He brought nature to a lot of people who may have otherwise not given a second look. He never hurt the animals. Shame on you Jean-Michel and the other idiots who apparently seem to agree with him!

Posted at 1:43PM on Sep 27th 2006 by ladybug

63. I was taught to respect wildlife. Not taunt, tease, and humiliate it. Steve Irwin built his empire on this very concept and in the end - what goes around comes around. A sting ray was defending itself because he was getting too close so he got stung and died, plain and simple.

The bottom line is that if he hadn't died by sting ray, he would have died by some other close encounter. Furthermore, the fact that he donated some of his profits from these horrible encounters to conservation doesn't fix the fact that he did these horrible things to the animals. It is blood money so it doesn't right the wrong.

In closing, I think that his name says it all when it comes to how he treated animals - "The Crocadile Hunter". The name implies that he went out and killed Crocs. This doesn't strike me as a man who loves nature and the creatures in it. He abused the animals he encountered and he tried to dominate them (instead of understand their normal behavior).

The fact that a family man dies is tragic however, the way he treated animals was tragic as well. This is something that all of the Cousteau family members should be able to agree upon.

PS. I really loved Jaques Cousteau growing up.

Posted at 2:15PM on Sep 27th 2006 by Joe Blancher

64. QUOTE =

What else would you expect from a french family. The 'French' , in general , don't like the rest of the world. And it's apparent, from this public family spat, that they French don't even like themselves.



That was fucking lame.
And if i recall correctly we're not the world haters, not the one to blame for creating civil war, hating between people, suspicions n other sympathetic things.
We're not self-absorbed and wont voice stupid comments as you apparently.
SO if you are french, you're a chauvinistic pig,stupid dumbass n whatever?
Man, grow up!
I take it you're an american so you eat mcdo everyday n are a big fatto with a cowboy hat in a trailer park.??!.. no i didnt think so either.

I advice you to go buy a new brain ,buddy.


I'm a french woman, damn proud of it & mostly of the fact we're stereotyped by people like you but manage to stay calm n tolerant


Posted at 1:27PM on Sep 28th 2006 by Pauline

65. s for # 4 what props do the french use to get other people to fight there wars. Just like a frenchman to play computer Rambo.#


If you talk about ww2 lets not forget the interst usa finded in it.
HOw about being the first nation, the first power,the first economic nation?
Let's not forget we helped you back when you were not even a country if we are there to count who did what for who.

I find it pretty ridiculous to see comments like that dissing my country for absolutely nothing besides a picture a man reflected of himself through medias.He may have done great things, be a great husband n father im not saying he wasnt.

But come on, all of this insulting comments for someone you didnt even know, for a sentence ONE SINGLE fucking FRENCh man said.

HELLO

ONE SINGLE MAN..

Should he represents a country?

come on im sure you're better than that ppl !

Posted at 1:26PM on Sep 28th 2006 by Pauline

66. I just want to know what the hell is wrong with his teeth.

Posted at 2:30PM on Sep 28th 2006 by Mrs. Smith

67. This excerpt is in response to those who have made such negative comparisons on Steve Irwin to Jacques Cousteau. Mr. Cousteau made some great contributions to conservation and oceanography but he also had some great faults. I remember this event, the unnecessary death of a baby sperm whale caused by Cousteau and his team.

Jacques Cousteau's "The Silent World" | 1, 2, 3

Later, the Calypso crew sights a school of 27 sperm whales and follows them. Tragically, a 20-foot whale calf is sucked under the ship and heavily lacerated by one of its propellers. A tide of blood discolors the ocean. Cousteau observes that there is no way it can survive so they pull the whale alongside the ship and shoot it to put it out of its misery.

The blood attracts a swarm of sharks. "Then comes the first bite," Cousteau comments. "It is the signal for the orgy to begin." The sharks strip the whale of flesh chunk by chunk, biting and gnashing away. The crewmen, Cousteau explains, are enraged at what he calls the "mortal enemies" of divers, and they "grab anything they can to avenge the whale." What follows is also an orgy of violence. The crew hauls shark after shark up onto the deck and brutally hacks at their heads with axes, tuna hooks and crowbars.

This vengeful wrath over the shark attack may seem an admirable display of emotion, but it struck me as at least partly disingenuous. The whale is already dead. Its death was an accident but the crew of Calypso is responsible, not the sharks. The sharks are merely following their instincts, after all. Nothing is gained by killing them except some dramatic footage.

There are other indications that at this early stage Cousteau and his crew were not the best custodians of the life they sought to capture on film. At one point they dynamite a remote coral reef. While Cousteau condemns dynamiting as a fishing method, he justifies it for science as the only way to take an accurate census of the marine life in an area. He never tells us why it is important to take a census and what the results are. Instead, he just shows us hundreds of fish lying dead on the sea floor and a puffer fish deflating as it dies. It is a "tragic scene," he admits, but he doesn't linger on the fact that he created it.

It's uncomfortable to watch such things now, almost 50 years after they were filmed, because our sensibilities have changed. Today we know that ocean life is in danger, that reefs are dying and that sharks play an important role in the marine ecosystem. It's unlikely, of course, that Cousteau's actions were malicious. For all his knowledge of marine biology, he was simply naïve.

As time progressed, Cousteau became a prominent spokesman for protecting the oceans. In 1960 he galvanized public support to prevent nuclear waste from being dumped in the Mediterranean. In 1974 he founded the Cousteau Society in the United States to advocate environmental protection. And in 1977 he spent five months collecting samples from the Mediterranean and produced a television documentary that educated viewers about the devastating impact of pollution on the ecosystem. Whereas the waters off Marseille teemed with life in the short films Cousteau made soon after World War II, 30 years later the same area was virtually barren.

But our greatest debt to Jacques Cousteau is for the lifetime of oceanic exploration that he captured on film, an odyssey he began with "The Silent World." Cousteau's motto aboard Calypso was "Il faut aller voir" ("We must go and see"). He insisted that people needed to venture into the seas to understand and appreciate their marvels. When he and his men descended to depths previously unplumbed, they brought millions with them.


salon.com

- - - - - - - - - - - -

About the writer
Greg Rubinson is a writer in Los Angeles.

Posted at 12:30PM on Oct 5th 2006 by Beth Bryson

68. "Jean-Michel? Never heard of him. Maybe because he is a big NOTHING. Steve Irwin has changed the world and what our children are going to think of wildlife in the future"
Taunting animals indeed! Do any of you folks know what you're talking about? I hope you're not advocating the American approach of doping the creatures, raising them for their body parts(you knw that "sustainable use" crap), or simply allowing them to die as a testament to "natural selection".
Bottom line; that's pure BS! And as an American, I should Know!

Posted at 8:40PM on Nov 28th 2006 by Jerilyn Bridges

69. And while I am at it, let me state that I find Jean Michel's treatment of animals more sadistic. It smacks of the patronizing behavior that Wealthy White Southern Americans feel that they can display torward anything not white!
We should get him together with his American counterpart: Trent Lott.

Posted at 9:03PM on Nov 28th 2006 by Jerilyn Bridges

Previous 15 Comments