Celebrity Justice
Cheesy Lawsuit Against O

Oprah Z SpinThis class action lawsuit against O Magazine is a cheap attempt to use Oprah to grab some publicity.

True enough, TMZ broke the story that a disgruntled subscriber has sued the mag and Hearst Publications, claiming she was double billed for her magazines and threatened to pay up -- or else her credit rating would go in the toilet. Maybe she was double billed. It happens. But frankly, it happens with lots of magazines, so why did the lawyers in this case zero in on O? Then answer lies in the O, and the P R A and H.

These lawyers got one pissed-off woman to launch a class action lawsuit. So how are they going to get other plaintiffs? Well, first you need the media to put the word out so other subscribers will follow suit. After all, the more plaintiffs, the more money the lawyers make. The media isn't going to do a story on Popular Mechanics over-billing its customers. Oprah, on the other hand, is a sure bet.




I won't deny it. TMZ dug up the lawsuit and broke the story. And that's exactly what the lawyers wanted. Should we have published it? It's hard to play judge when it comes to reporting on court cases. But Z-Spin is my chance to talk about the real deal, and the real deal is that this lawsuit is a little bit sickening.

I don't know her, but I'm guessing Oprah doesn't have much to do with sending out invoices for magazines. She's kinda pressed for time. But using Oprah's name -- that's gold. The lawyers were actually legally wrong when they repeatedly referred to the publication as Oprah Magazine. It's called O. But maybe the lawyers weren't sure if the media would figure out that O stands for Oprah. So for safe measure, they used an incorrect magazine title to ensure attention.

In the end, if this lawsuit goes anywhere, the plaintiff's will each get $10 and the lawyers will get rich. This is a case where a celebrity was totally used in an unfair way, and it kinda sucks.

Tags: O, O Magazine, OMagazine, Oprah, Oprah Winfrey, OprahWinfrey

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 4 of 5) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

46. HOPE OPRAH LOSES HER ASS. SHE IS SO PHONEY. SHE SURE DOES WANT TO BE A WHITE PERSON.

Posted at 8:46PM on Dec 1st 2006 by Debbie

47. OPRAH SUCKS

Posted at 9:24PM on Dec 1st 2006 by Kammy

48. All of you stupid fathead, sorry ass racist white crackers and you self-hating, sad ass, stupid ass, ugly ass n***** who are hatin' on Oprah need to get a life!

She has far more class, diginity and many other assets and has accomplished far more that most of you pathetic, wayward losers will ever have.

Perphas if some of you would begin to reexamine your own pathetic, sorry ass lives, you might do a whole lot better.!

Posted at 1:14AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Observer

49. Americans are really becoming cruel, ruthless bastards. There is so much hatred, racism, and ignorance spewed in these comments that it's no wonder the rest of the world thinks of us as greedy, spoiled, arrogant, fat, ugly monsters. Americans did NOT used to be like this, but the hatred is becoming very "common" and I'm shocked at how absolutely illiterate most of the commenters are in these forums.

S-C-A-R-Y

You know, this is (in many ways) what it was like before Rome fell. The United States is not immune to the fate that has befallen other nations that have become warped and overrun with hatred.

Really, if anyone wastes brain energy actually "hating" Oprah Winfrey (an enormously successful black woman and respectable American role model), there's something seriously wrong with people's heads...and with American attitudes in general. When China, India, and the entire Muslim world come to kick our asses, I hope we have more worthy defenders than the kind of trash who post here.

(You know who you are). And kudos who people here who make rational, decent, witty comments.

Posted at 11:24PM on Dec 1st 2006 by Ian

50. Well said Ian.

People from all over the world read these posts. Is this REALLY the impression we want to give them about the "UNITED" States?

Posted at 12:06AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Tina

51. 50. Well said Ian.

"People from all over the world read these posts. Is this REALLY the impression we want to give them about the "UNITED" States?"

Why assume that only people from the US made these comments? I don't agree with 99 percent of them, but why assume only US citizens made these posts? People frm all over the world comment on these posts as well.

Anyway the racist comments are stupid and why they started I don't know. But before anyone says it's a white woman is suing oprah it is a BLACK woman suing her. ( perhaps that may stop some of the racist stuff)

What is an oreo? When growing up I heard the slur but it was always directed at bi-racial children. How can oprah be a oreo? And if she were bi-racial why is it an issue. All people bleed the same PERIOD. An aside: Why is it that 50 Cent is calling her a white woman? I don't get it.

Posted at 1:36AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by More questions than answers

52. ENOUGH ALREADY! SO TIRED OF "O"

Posted at 3:00AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Katie

53. TMZ, you are sh*t. You go and post something like this with a "tsk tsk" tone and shake your heads in a "what is the world coming to?" tone. MEANWHILE, you are more than happy to post this and you get a thrill that someone is doing something to cause (no matter how insignificant) hassle to a celebrity you don't like. Very transparent.

Posted at 3:20AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Hill

54. My people have been in this country ( Carolinas)since the 17th century; my ancesters built this country while enslaved; defended this country as soldiers in the civil war, as in ALL wars; free labor for 230 years;made this country rich; was set free by Lincoln; no schools set up to educate the "free" slaves, no "40-acres & mule", ect.,ect.,So don't give me that crap about "going back to Africa.."! I am mixed with American Indian, white(yessss, white, not necessarily in an honorable way, because the "mixing" started on southern plantations), and black(not african-american, I refuse to use that term)You white folks, go back to Europe if yu don't like it here! I am proud to be an American, and belong here more than you! What have you contributed besides hatred?! Don't hate on Oprah! You would be surprised how many rich/well off black people are in America! Hatred has you blind as a bat, and is hurting YOU more than the black people YOU hate! All the adversity we face on a daily basis keeps us stronger than you who "whine" about us! Could YOU as so-called "whites"survive the same adversity? I say so-called whites, because the creator does NOT catergorize the human race as black or white; and does not care what color, only cares about whether you "know" him or not, and what's in your heart; The creator does not make mistakes, or create humans with "monstrous" attitudes(he made monsters separately). No one is born hating people, all of you people who have hatred in your hearts, YOU WERE TAUGHT hatred!! Don't hate Oprah; hate and jealousy is what you have for her, and the rest of successful black people! I am an American, and my ancestors contributed blood,swear, and tears to make this a rich country; no amount of hate can change that fact! why not appreciate that fact. Did you know that the history books in schools did not include the facts about slavery, and how much rich history blacks have, and what a major contribution blacks made to America through slave labor and inventions? and credit was NEVER given! If you actually knew the truth about black people would you really be so hateful toward Oprah's success? and other black peoples success? Think about it all you Oprah "haters".

Posted at 4:38AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by dina

55. WHAT has Oprah ever done wrong? And what about her Legends Ball for everybody that says she disses blacks? C'mon people get a grip, it sounds as if you all are angry because of her success. Her best friend is black! Her boyfriend is black! What about her school she is opening in Africa for African American girls? How closed minded can you people be? Oprah is a good person and she has the right like everybody to pick and choose who or what she wants to do with her time and money. Jealousy is a terrible thing.

Posted at 8:28AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Deborah

56. What she should have done was cancel the subscription. Maybe O Magazine was inundated with millions of subscription requests daily and didn't pay attention at customer service one day, There's no point in having this lawsuit. Either there was an error when they entered the transaction or she doesn't have to pay double for her subcription.

Posted at 9:18AM on Dec 2nd 2006 by Preston

57. Web rage is becoming a largely studied phenomenon. Basically it turns out that many people filled with rage believe they have found a way to release negative feelings about themselves by posting what are called flame messages. They use the internet and jump on basically anything where they can be negative whether they are really invested or not. They use blogs and/or discussion groups (chat rooms) where they can post anonymously. Because in day to day real life, no one would put up with such a miserable human being.

Here’s the catch. The research shows that rather than being a method to release the users rage it tends to amplify or build rage. A type of escalation of rage. As you can see on TMZ when bloggers escalate to nothing but name calling and derogatory remarks. So what you are seeing is indeed becoming more common on the internet. Abd I agree that’s very sad. This study included all web users from a variety of sources so it’s not necessarily an American phenomenon, more like the Internet in general. Granted you may have a argument that most people blogging on a site hosted my “America on Line” would be America’s but that another discussion.

Posted at 2:30PM on Dec 2nd 2006 by ratherthanthat

58. anyone wondering who that tvbegone guy is? who posts on every story with the same website? hes selling a device that supposedly turns off any tv anywhere within 69 seconds for 19.99...

Hey TMZ Harvey: I wasnt aware we could adverstise on your site?

Can I start putting my web address to sell something every time I post?

Posted at 6:55PM on Dec 2nd 2006 by tv dont be gone

59. Magazine Subscriptions are notoriously bad,but in this case i think it is justified as i have a friend that this exact thing happened to with O magazine.This lady i work with subscribed to this magazine but after issues were not delivered and she never even read the issuses she got anyways ..she cancelled her subscription after the one year she had it.The Magazine people called hr and told her she ws dishonest and a bad person for not wanting to keep her subscription.They automatically started her subscription back and and started charging her again....I will let her know about this class action lawsut..that TMZ seems to think is baseless..I get the feeling TMZ are not very good people myself hmmmmmm...Screwing the innocent and protecting the bad....

Posted at 11:07PM on Dec 5th 2006 by Stan the man

60. IT'S INTERESTING TO SEE HOW THE PUBLIC HAS RESPONDED TO THE ARTICLE. WHAT DOES OPRAH HAVE TO DO WITH ANY OF THIS?? OPRAH JUST RUNS A MAGAZINE AND PEOPLE OF ALL COLORS CHOOSE TO READ IT. THIS ONE PERSON, IN THE LAWSUIT, IS TRYING TO GET A DIME FOR HER PENNY. THE TRUTH IS OPRAH HAS AN INSIGHT INTO WHAT THE AMERICAN PEOPLE WANT TO SEE AND HEAR. SOMETIMES, I FEEL SHE COULD USE A MORE DOWN TOO EARTH FRIEND TO TELL HER HOW LIFE REALLY IS. BUT WHO CAN FAULT HER..SHE HAS MADE HERSELF AN AMERICAN QUEEN AND DESERVES EVERY BIT OF IT.

Posted at 1:50PM on Dec 8th 2006 by BIANCA

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments