Academy says "Listen" : Beyonce Can't Win Oscar

The Academy of Motion Pictures confirmed that the song "Listen," which has been heralded as the unofficial theme of the critically acclaimed "Dreamgirls," will be submitted to Academy members for Oscar consideration without Beyonce's name attached as a writer.

beyonce knowlesOriginal Broadway scorer Henry Krieger, as well as songwriters Anne Preven, Scott Cutler and Beyonce are credited on the soundtrack as the writers of the song and were submitted as such to the Academy.

As it states in the Academy's guidelines, it is customary for up to two people to be credited as writers of any given song, but under special circumstances, if it is found that the there were more than two equal contributors, an exception could be made. The Academy made the exception for Preven and Cutler, but not for our girl B.

No word as to why Beyonce didn't make the cut.

Nominations will be announced on the January 23.



Tags: Beyonce, Dreamgirls

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 3) | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. Just waiting for JZ to kick this clown act to the curb . Dickhead . She is worse Diva than Diana Ross ever was and has 1/5 the talent . Overdubbed and filtered -- her natural voice is nothing special . Her Cardboard acting should win an award -- from the Dead clowns Society . Dickhead .

Posted at 7:53PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Trans fer Gear

2. Just waiting on JZ to kick this dumb Diva to the curb .Or at least tell her to wait out in the car -- forever ! Dickhead . She is a worse Diva demander than Diana Ross ever was . Oh yeah she will win an award --- from the Cardboard Clowns on Crack film group . Dickhead .

Posted at 7:57PM on Jan 12th 2007 by nASTY bOIL

3. Perhaps because she doesnt "write" anything? All her songs are ripoff remakes and I doubt she "wrote" anything for her Dreamgirls performance either. Let the REAL writers get the credit.

Posted at 8:27PM on Jan 12th 2007 by John Jackstone

4. My teens are a fan of Beyonce. I guess I'm too old at 40 to appreciate her sound. Too much screaming, and yelling on the songs. Now that Jennifer can "sang"!

Posted at 8:31PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Trina

5.
TMZ didn't you run this story a couple of weeks ago when it was first announced that she wouldn't be listed?????

Must be a slow news day.

Posted at 8:36PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Shiloh

6. I recently saw "Dreamgirl's" and Jennifer Hudson can flat out sign! She steals the show. Go see this movie!

Posted at 8:48PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Shawn Corey Carter, that's what my passport says!

7. Gosh her dad is going to be pissed! His plan to get his baby an Oscar is further foiled by the Academy. Daddy Knowles should have realized when he made the deal for this movie that the star was going to be whoever had the Effie role. No matter how much weight B gained she could never ever have played Effie, no matter what she said. I have no doubt that she is somewhere screaming at her dad and JZ right this moment. I mean afterall, the academy has spoken!
The Golden Globes are gonna be so much fun!

Posted at 8:52PM on Jan 12th 2007 by lizzy

8. I just went to mediatakeout.com and beyonce just stated from a concert she did ,that she wrote irreplacable for the ladies ,but on the same video; Neyo said he wrote ALL the WORDS to the song and beyonce just added some hemmmm. Beyonce... LIAR LIAR WEAVE ON FIRE......

Posted at 8:56PM on Jan 12th 2007 by barbara hill

9. YEAH, it was already reported in its entirety earlier last week. Damn you guys must be having trouble obtaining new news . . . what happened?

Posted at 9:09PM on Jan 12th 2007 by kd

10. I just went to mediatakeout.com and Beyonce stated while she was in a concert " that she wrote Irreplaceable for the ladies" (straight from her mouth on a video) but on the same video Neyo said he wrote ALL the LYRIC to Irreplacealbe. Beyonce LIAR LIAR ALL OF YOUR WEAVES ON FIRE...... And I'm sure she didn't write Listen; if she had some imput in writing Listen, I'm sure it was no more than 5%....

Posted at 9:16PM on Jan 12th 2007 by ashley stitt

11. I just went to mediatakeout.com and Beyonce stated while she was in a concert " that she wrote Irreplaceable for the ladies" (straight from her mouth on a video) but on the same video Neyo said he wrote ALL the LYRIC to Irreplacealbe. Beyonce LIAR LIAR ALL OF YOUR WEAVES ON FIRE...... And I'm sure she didn't write Listen; if she had some imput in writing Listen, I'm sure it was no more than 5%....

Posted at 9:14PM on Jan 12th 2007 by ashley stitt

12. well them there are da rules

Posted at 9:56PM on Jan 12th 2007 by puff the magic dragon

13. That jennifer hudson girl can sing.b she my girl and all but jennifer got her. AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU AND YOU ANDYOU GONNA LUV MEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE.

Posted at 10:02PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Sade

14. It is unfortunate that Beyonce's name will not be attached to the credits for the song "Listen" where the Oscar's are concerned. I think she did an incredible job in "Dreamgirls." Jennifer Hudson was amazing as well, but Beyonce has more of what is required to make it in that industry - looks, voice, personality! Best wishes to both women!

Posted at 10:26PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Anne

15. hmmh..It seems there's some fishy plots to sabotage Beyonce's career. First they gave her a blockbuster movie role to expose her tatentless acting, then they drop her name from the Academy nominations...ANYONE?

Posted at 10:40PM on Jan 12th 2007 by Mathiew Knowles

| 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments