Academy says "Listen" : Beyonce Can't Win Oscar

The Academy of Motion Pictures confirmed that the song "Listen," which has been heralded as the unofficial theme of the critically acclaimed "Dreamgirls," will be submitted to Academy members for Oscar consideration without Beyonce's name attached as a writer.

beyonce knowlesOriginal Broadway scorer Henry Krieger, as well as songwriters Anne Preven, Scott Cutler and Beyonce are credited on the soundtrack as the writers of the song and were submitted as such to the Academy.

As it states in the Academy's guidelines, it is customary for up to two people to be credited as writers of any given song, but under special circumstances, if it is found that the there were more than two equal contributors, an exception could be made. The Academy made the exception for Preven and Cutler, but not for our girl B.

No word as to why Beyonce didn't make the cut.

Nominations will be announced on the January 23.



Tags: Beyonce, Dreamgirls

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 3) Previous 15 Comments

31. ALL OF THIS HATING ON BEYONCE' IS A FREAKIN SHAME !

I AM ASHAMED OF YOU ! I'll be willing to bet MOST of you who have called this mannerable, respectful, extremely hard working, role model for young black females, are indeed a member of the Black race yourself !

THIS FREAKIN DISGUSTS ME !

How soooooo many Blacks can NEVER, I mean NEVER support one another. Not to say that everyone should like Beyonce' or her music. There are many artists I do not like. But I don't speak of them like " dogs " or " mutts " the way many of you have spoken about Beyonce. Most of you are JUST LIKE ME....DON'T KNOW BEYONCE' PERSONALLY, HAVE NEVER HAD A RELATIONSHIP LONG ENOUGH WITH HER TO JUDGE HER PERSONALLY, BUT CAN CALL THIS FEMALE " DICK HEAD ", " BITCH" , "HO", "TALENTLESS" ...Awh please, get a life and get some self respect. Because if some of you had some, you wouldn't speak of anyone who had NOT MISTREAT Y-O-U that way ! What Have Beyonce' done to any of you ???? Not a damn thing ! But yet, all you have seen of this woman is respect. Do you see her out til 5:00 am doing drugs ? Do you see or KNOW of her sleeping with other's husbands ? Boyfriends ? Do you see her speaking ugly of other actors/actresses ? Do you see her flashing her tits or privates to the camera ? NO ! You guys only see or hear good things about this female. But yet you ridicule her as if she has hurt some of you personally.

After Beyonce's sucess of attainment in this harsh, evil world, ridden with racism against Blacks, and gender bias against females, I'll be damn if she isn't a strong, Black, ....wait, a VERY strong, any color , woman.

Now I truly believe that you can NOT please people. She does things the right way. I have not seen anything else to make me think otherwise. And neigther have you guys. But, you STILL can be pleased.

I'm glad as HECK I don't have to please man to get to heaven. Because you all are a wicked, unworthy group.

Posted at 12:04AM on Jan 28th 2007 by Real Talk

32. WTF ? B jealous of jen ? for what ? enough already with this be jealous / mad of jen mess. just some rumor. i'm tired of it so i know B is dayum tired of it. thats probably why she said what she said, that she is already a star so there is no need , i know i would of said it and so is the rest of us who know what time it is.

point blank B is full of talent. beauty. poise. humility.good looks. good body.

jen can act. can sang.

ppl dishin out major haterade on B cause she got it like that. most of the rumors coming from these crazy comments. i aint neva heard B say this shit y'all sayin this shit. not be. the haters most def in the house

Posted at 11:44PM on Jan 28th 2007 by holla

33. Beyonce is on top of her game and cant be stopped. So to all of you who have something bad to say All you haters will be her motivator

Posted at 9:18PM on Jan 28th 2007 by Stacey

34. BEYONCE IS PRACTICALLY USED GOODS ,BY THE PUBLIC AND HER DADDY. SHE THOUGHT ALL IT TOOK WAS TO BE BOOTI-FULL., SHE SHOULD HAVE SHOOK HER HEAD UP AND DOWN INSTEAD OF HER BOOTY .WORK THOSE BRAIN CELLS YOU MIGHT COME BACK ! FIRE DADDY ,PUT SOME MORE CLOTHES ON AND LEARN TO SING JAZZ.

Posted at 10:30PM on Jan 28th 2007 by 1mg

35. It seems that Beyonce's parents wanted her to win an Oscar.....up against the seasoned women in best actress category..they were dreamin'.....Jennifer Hudson, without a doubt, in my opinion, was the STAR of that movie, Eddie and Jamie were very good as well, but Miss Jennifer, well, that young lady can SANG

Posted at 11:40AM on Jan 29th 2007 by Pat

36. as the resident commentator/comedian, hailing from H-TOWN tex'ass, i seen beyonce rise and shine. so what there is a nutha star twinkling out there in the heavens. Beyonce proved she got tha chops. i aint a fan of Beyonce, trust me, but tha gal got dat "shyt" that makes anyone with ears headnod. in respects of the movie Dream gulz... hmph... all i can say is this, who owns the rights, who is on that finall cuttin board, who makes the finall money talk "say-so".? "Beyounce" is talented, well groomed for that performance, alibet, sometimes a shootin star catches more attention than a rising one.

Posted at 9:31PM on Feb 11th 2007 by thrill hill

37. All of you jealous ass people can go to hell.

Posted at 9:57AM on Feb 26th 2007 by Phaedra D.Nash

38. BEYOUCE GET GONE - I'M TRIED OF YOU. http://www.racheal.johnson@morganstanley.com

Posted at 12:55PM on Mar 2nd 2007 by racheal johnson

39. the song "listen" just plain sucked! just like her latest cd

Posted at 9:15AM on Mar 8th 2007 by so what

40. NO YOU DON'T "why it happend". SO YOU LITTLE BIGOT WANT TO PUT ASIANS IN A LITTLE BOX do you, WHERE DID YOU LEARN THAT FROM. EVER HEARD OF EURASIA, ASIANS AND EUROPEANS HAVE BEEN INTERMIXING FOR MILLENIA. YOU GOT ASIANS WITH BORN WITH RED, DIRTY BLONDE, BLONDE, BROWN, WAVY, CURLY, STRAIGHT HAIR. THEY HAVE BLONDE, BROWN BODY HAIR. BLUE, GREY, GREEN, ALL SHADES OF BROWN EYES. THEY RANGE FROM VERY FAIR WHITE SKIN TO DARK BROWN. THEY ARE HAIRY LIKE A CARPET TO HAIRLESS. AS FAR AS DYING HAIR, WHITE WOMEN DYE THEIR HAIR FAR MORE THAN ANY OTHER GROUP.

Posted at 2:10AM on Mar 12th 2007 by ZIELTN

Previous 15 Comments