Celebrity Justice
Casting Secrets of Convicted Felons

When you look at Meg Ryan do you immediately think, "She would be convicing as a statuatory rapist?" When you think of Farrah Fawcett, do you think, "sex symbol" or "child murderer?" True crime author Gregg Olsen decided to ask the actual rapist and murderer what they thought!

Penelope Ann Miller, Mary Kay Letourneau, Meg Ryan
Olsen's first thriller, "A Wicked Snow," just came out in paperback. But over the years, he's interviewed some of the most notorious female criminals ever, including hundreds of interviews with teacher/convicted rapist Mary Kay Letourneau. The Seattle schoolteacher, who had a sexual relationship with her underage student Vili Fualaau (whom she later married), wanted Meg Ryan to play her in the TV movie "All American Girl." Instead, it was Penelope Ann Miller -- whom Letourneau never heard of.

"I don't get it at all," she said. "Penelope was good, but I think she played me like I was crazy. Maybe Meg would have been a better choice."

Diane Downs/Farrah Fawcett
Diane Downs was in prison for killing a daughter, injuring another and paralyzing her son. She was the subject of

the Farrah Fawcett mini-series "Small Sacrifices." Most people would say Farrah is as sexy as it gets, but not Downs. "I know that you'll probably think I'm egotistical or something, but I don't think Farrah looked like me at all," Downs told Olsen. "I think I'm prettier and have much nicer eyes. All I can say is that her hair looked good."

Helen Hunt, Pam Smart, Nicole Kidman
Pam Smart has been in prison for two decades for the murder of her husband, insurance salesman Craig Smart. She was a teacher's aide/weathergirl wannabe who seduced her lover into killing Craig. Her story was told in the TV movie "Murder in New Hampshire," starring Helen Hunt, and was the inspiration for the Nicole Kidman movie "To Die For."

"I'm famous here," she says of being the subject of books and two films. "Everyone wants to take a potshot at me; the guards, the other offenders. It isn't easy being me. Both actresses got it wrong because I didn't do what they said. I'm innocent. Those movies were fiction."

Tags: diane downs, DianeDowns, farrah fawcett, FarrahFawcett, helen hunt, HelenHunt, Mary Kay Letourneau, MaryKayLetourneau, Meg Ryan, MegRyan, nicole kidman, NicoleKidman, pam smart, PamSmart, Penelope Ann Miller, PenelopeAnnMiller

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 3) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 |

16. Post Number 13.... Darlie Routier is on Death Row in Texas. She may be getting a new trial. Darlie is guilty, I think, but she didn't kill her sons for a man. Diane Downs shot her kids because she thought her ex-lover would take her back if they were out of the way.

Posted at 7:26PM on Mar 4th 2007 by april

17. I think Jay Mohr would play a great Larry Birkhead.

Posted at 7:57PM on Mar 4th 2007 by rye

18. It's GREG SMART, not Craig Smart.....and neither Nicole Kidman nor Helen Hunt captured the ice cold killer personality of Pam Smart. That poor man was brutally murdered in a hideous scheme concocted by his sicko psycho wife who will rot in jail for the rest of her life!!!! Praise the justice system!

Posted at 8:07PM on Mar 4th 2007 by Sue C

19. I thought the casting for Mary Kay was right on. Mary Kay is nuts.
As for Diane Downs, we need someone who was much butchier to
play her.

Posted at 9:02PM on Mar 4th 2007 by anne

20. Regarding Mary Kaye, yeah, that was horrible what she did; but how will she explain what she did to her two daughters? They are the innocent victims in all of this? What will they think of their mom? Food for thought. I thought Farrah did an excellent job of portraying Diane Downs. There is a book written about Diane by Ann Rule called Small Sacrifices. Excellent book I highly recommend it. gotta go. bye

Posted at 9:43PM on Mar 4th 2007 by Jaye

21. I agree with No. 15 Why isn't Jay named The Sexiest man of the Year. Enough of George Clooney and Brad Pitt...

Posted at 9:44PM on Mar 4th 2007 by Jaye

22. LOL, Rye! I thought of Jay Mohr also when I wondered who would play Birkhead in the Anna Nicole Lifetime movie. Perfect casting. I wonder who would make a good Howard K. Stern? Or Virgie?

Posted at 10:03PM on Mar 4th 2007 by Gregg Olsen

23. I was the ghost writer who worked with "Dianbo" (my wife's name for her), and spent literally hundreds of hours with her in preparation of a book she ultimately published under her own name, though she didn't write it. It's called "Best Kept Secrets" and it's hard to find .. her father formed a publishing company, bought the rights from me and published maybe 50,000 copies, nearly all of which sold. It purports to be Diane's version of the whole thing from the shootings through the trial and her escape. The photo you posted here of her knocked me out of my chair. It was taken at the rear of the Oregon State Police Department, where they brought her after her escape and capture. She's looking at.... me. I was standing there with my wife taking photos when she was taken out of the car, and I was the only familiar face who wasn't a cop or a reporter, and there were scores of them there.... as for who is better looking? I've seen Diane in jail blues with no makeup and her hair just brushed, and seen her dressed to the nines, total makeup in a photo shoot for Oregon Magazine which serialized her book.... and there's no question that Farrah Fawcett is ten times more gorgeous. Diane's comments here are classic Diane. Thanks for the blast from the past!

Posted at 12:36AM on Mar 5th 2007 by Richard

24. Thanks post # 14. Yes, Darlie Routier was her name. Now I remember. What was the reason she killed her son's, and why is she getting a new trial? On all the interviews I saw of her, she never even acted like she was sad.

Posted at 1:58AM on Mar 5th 2007 by jan

25. Farrah was amazing in Small Scarifices.

Posted at 10:38AM on Mar 5th 2007 by justin

26. Someone commented that who are we to judge love in the MKL case??? would you say that about Michael Jackson?? Or any other pedophile? A lot of grown men say they love little boys. Just because she is a petite woman doesn't make her any less of a sicko.

Posted at 11:20PM on Mar 5th 2007 by Belinda

27. #23- You may view Mary Kay as a "sweet soul" ,but she is also a child molestor and quite frankly, mentally ill!

As for Diane Downs and Pamela Smart, in their interviews they come across as cold-blooded killers.

Posted at 2:48PM on Mar 5th 2007 by JV

28. #22...DARLENE MURDERED TWO OF HER CHILDREN...THE YOUNGEST ONE WAS UPSTAIRS WITH HER HUSBAND...SHE KILLED THEM, BECAUSE THE ONLY THING SHE WAS INTRESTED IN WAS THE PERFECT HOUSE, THE PERFECT LOOKS, MONEY MONEY MONEY, AND THE KIDS WERE JUST COSTING TO MUCH AND RUINING HER PERFECT HOUSE....ON THE ONE SONS BIRTHDAY (WHICH WAS AFTER HE DIED, LIKE RIGHT AFTER) SHE HAD A BIRTHDAY PARTY AT THE GRAVE SITE WITH SILLY STRING AND LAUGHING AND HAVING A GOOD TIME

Posted at 5:27PM on Mar 5th 2007 by TAMMY

29. Someone previously said what do her daughters think of her? Well they love her. They don't look down on their mom at all. I am friends with them and they love and support her life. She actually has a very close relationship to her children (both from her first and second husband). She visits her 19 year old daughter every chance she gets. They have family dinners and outings all the time. The children she had with Vili are also very close to her children she had with Stephen.

Posted at 5:07PM on Mar 6th 2007 by liz

30. Love is love. While Mary Kay may have "done" a 13 year old, he had to get it up first. It isn't rape when the party is willing. And, he must have loved her to have waited for her and then married her. Get a grip folks, this is old news. Now their lives are NONE of our business.

Posted at 2:53PM on Mar 8th 2007 by Jane

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 |