Jennifer Hudson -- Liar, Ingrate?

Click to return to TMZ.comJennifer Hudson has been trash-talking "American Idol" and dissing on Simon Cowell. But the video evidence makes it clear -- the Dreamgirl is dreaming it all up.

"EXTRA" rolled back the tapes of Hudson on "Idol," and Simon clearly gave her props throughout the season, saying that she was a "front-runner" and calling her "great" multiple times -- high praise from the often harsh Cowell.

Why would Hudson rant about the show and the judge who moved her from obscurity to Oscar winner? Is she an ingrate? Watch the video, then vote.



Reader Comments

(Page 4 of 30) Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

46. Ungratefull fat bag of sh*t

Posted at 10:58AM on Mar 6th 2007 by independent

47. Seriously, does Jennifer think she would have gotten a toe in the door to audition for Dreamgirls if she had not been seen on AI? NO Way...she better start sounding grateful like Carrie Underwood.

People want to bring down a winner to their own low level. That is what will happen unless she follows this up with some juicy movie role. And I do think she should slim down some more.
If she doesn't get some good movie roles she will go the way of Maria Tomei. Tomei had a promising career until she won an Academy Award. Then pffft.!!
What happened? I think the winners start getting bad advice about what roles to take---they don't take good roles soon enough after they win, or they choose bad ones, thinking they can do no wrong.
Hopefully, for her sake JH will keep good people around her and get rid of the homeboys who know squat about Hollywood.

Posted at 11:11AM on Mar 6th 2007 by PJ

48. Let's not make this a race thing please. I can't stand Jennifer Hudson either but it's because she's an ungrateful bitch. Nothing to do with being black.

Posted at 11:05AM on Mar 6th 2007 by Kell

49. Hudson is an over-rated, over-exposed non-talent and screamer. She's hallucinating and thinks way too much of herself. If it weren't for her exposure on Idol, she'd still be cater-walling in the alleys of Chicago. Consider the fact that the black female finalists on this season's Idol have much more personality and real talent, compared to this wretched obnoxious teen. I'm disgusted that she won the Oscar, since what she was doing wasn't acting, but being her own low-class, low-life egomaniacal self in the movie. At least most of the other nominess in her category really knew how to act and had real roles. Go figure, Hudson and Eddie Murphy acting all outraged before and after the Oscars. Hudson you ought to get on your hands and knees and ask the good Lord for forgiveness. Hudson's so-called career is over. No one in their right mind would ever want to engage her again for anything, since once she got her way with you, she'd trash you until the next fool comes along and goes on to fresh meat.

Posted at 11:02AM on Mar 6th 2007 by TH

50. Simon is not responsible for Jennifer's loss on American Idol... America voted. If you watch this show consistenly one will see that Simon is always right about a contestant's talents and short comings....Just wish the losers would shut up and be glad they at least got that far. I don't believe Jennifer was worth of all of the awards... She won't be around very long. She also needs a professional make over....

Posted at 1:22PM on Mar 6th 2007 by Elizabeth Smith

51. She is great and I hope to see her in a lot more movies and is the only black singer and actress out there that I actually can stand to look at.

Posted at 11:01AM on Mar 6th 2007 by janet

52. #1 Naren - comments about 'thanking God'

So it wasn't just me, good to know. My thoughts ran along similar lines - I sat thinking wouldn't it be better if he pulled his finger out and cured my son's cancer than bother about Jennifer's gong.

Posted at 11:08AM on Mar 6th 2007 by confusedforeignor

53. JHud needs to sit her dumb a$$ down, she did good in Dreamgirls but let's be hnest most people wnet to see it to see Beyonce/it just happened to be a good movie too. I can't stan Jennifer, it's about time people start looking at her dumb ungrateful A$$ insttead of always trashing B who is quick to give props and is very humble.

Posted at 11:31AM on Mar 6th 2007 by Bella

54. How is fat a blessing? I am so sick of this new "woman have curves" bullsh*t and "jennifer hudson is healthy" talk. No she isn't! She's a fat ass! I am 5 feet 8 and weigh 135 pounds which is perfect. Jennifer Hudson probably weighs 200 pounds and I find it revolting.

Posted at 11:02AM on Mar 6th 2007 by Kate

55. she great get the f*** over it.

Posted at 11:03AM on Mar 6th 2007 by janet

56. DAMN. I don't like JHudson much. I hate that style its just LOUD. I don't think she deserved the OSCAR (I just don't see how that part warranted all this recognition. I mean you can count the minutes she was on screen!!!!)but she won so congrats to her BUT you people are INSANE. Its one thing not to like her but do you all really waste this much time hating someone...calling her fat, a turd etc I mean are you all in the fourth grade????

oh and the remark about her working in McD's soon HILARIOUS (how unhappy with your life do you sound?) Jealousy is a monster. You all sound so jealous like you are about to blow up with hate. Take it down a peg and get a life maybe you'll have an Oscar to put on your mantle or at least Employee of the Month at your glam job LOLOL

Posted at 9:18AM on Mar 11th 2007 by Sami

57. There's an old saying - "Don't sh*t in someones backyard until you have sh*t in your own" Clearly that is what she is doing with her "Idol Bashing".

Dreamgirls was the role of a lifetime for her, unfortunately this is the first, last and only role that she will ever have with this kind of merritt.

Her 15 minutes are up and she is done!

Posted at 11:06AM on Mar 6th 2007 by So Cal Race Girl - Tony Stewart #1

58. Mary - comment about overweight women

Funnily enough, a big woman won a Brit version of American Idol with Cowell as a judge - he loved her - Michelle McManus was the name

Posted at 11:07AM on Mar 6th 2007 by confusedforeignor

59. #47-Kate - Eat a cookie or somethin! Too skinny isn't cute either!!

Posted at 11:07AM on Mar 6th 2007 by wouldn\\\'t you want to know

60. you dont hear carrie underwood doing with this fat pig is doing. and underwood has way more talent than her
i cant stand hudson, she is one big fat ugly phony, every time she wins an award, i want to vomit, she is not sincere but pretends to be. i am so sick of seeing around.

Posted at 9:59AM on Mar 7th 2007 by audrey rose

Previous 15 Comments | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments