"Idol" Producer Slams Rosie, Defends Show

Nigel Lythgoe, executive producer of "American Idol," has just released a statement in response to criticism made against the show by "View" host Rosie O'Donnell. It reads:

"Without wishing to add to the obvious self-promotion of Ms. O'Donnell, I feel as though I must refute her absurd and ridiculous claims that 'American Idol' is racist and/or weightist.

"Ms. O'Donnell has, once again, spoken without thought or knowledge. Viewers need only look at the show tonight to realize that 'American Idol' constantly confirms to America that talent has nothing to do with weight or color."

It was Rosie's comments on Tuesday's episode of "The View" that drew "Idol's" ire. Rosie called the show "weightist and racist" over the way it has handled the Antonella Barba photo scandal this season, as opposed to when it booted contestant Frenchie Davis for the same thing. Although an "Idol" spy tells us that the difference is that Frenchie was paid for her pre-Idol porn, while Antonella's photos were private, and published without her knowledge or permission.

Idol's On Vacation: Click to launch photos"Idol" has also banned "The View" from using clips from the show.



Tags: american idol, AmericanIdol, rosie o'donnell, RosieO'donnell, the view, TheView

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 14 of 14) Previous 15 Comments

196. To those who wish to know. Davis's photos were straight-out porn for a price. Barba (who should go because she CAN'T SING) had pics that were not nude (breasts covered), and she was not in the porno material they "claimed" she was. Am I the only one who sees the difference here??? To be honest, I don't know why everyone is so up-in-arms about this, if all goes as it should, she won't be there after tonight anyway, so what's the big deal??!!

Posted at 4:24PM on Mar 8th 2007 by mystisol

197. HOW CAN ABC PUT UP WITH THIS RUDE, CRUDE, OBNOXIUS, INHUMAN PERSON.?
DOES SHE THINK SHE CAN TELL PEOPLE WHAT TO DO? DOES SHE THINK THAT
SHE KNOWS EVERYTHING? HOW CAN SHE BE SO MEAN TO PEOPLE? HAS SHE
TAKEN OVER THE PLACE OF THE LAST QUEEN OF MEAN?
HER BEING DEPRESSED OVER COLUMBINE HIGH SCHOOL ESPISODE. I KNOW
PEOPLE THAT HAD CHILDREN IN THAT SCHOOL AND THEY ARE NOT MEAN AND
SPITEFUL LIKE SHE IS.

Posted at 5:55PM on Mar 8th 2007 by EILEEN L CURNOW

198. HOW CAN ABC PUT UP WITH THIS RUDE, CRUDE, OBNOXIUS, INHUMAN PERSON.?
DOES SHE THINK SHE CAN TELL PEOPLE WHAT TO DO? DOES SHE THINK THAT
SHE KNOWS EVERYTHING? HOW CAN SHE BE SO MEAN TO PEOPLE? HAS SHE
TAKEN OVER THE PLACE OF THE LAST QUEEN OF MEAN?
HER BEING DEPRESSED OVER COLUMBINE HIGH SCHOOL ESPISODE. I KNOW
PEOPLE THAT HAD CHILDREN IN THAT SCHOOL AND THEY ARE NOT MEAN AND
SPITEFUL LIKE SHE IS.

Posted at 5:54PM on Mar 8th 2007 by EILEEN L CURNOW

199. it's about time rosie kept her mouth shut,I used to like her but now all she is ,is a trouble maker, maybe for ratings? I don't know

Posted at 6:32PM on Mar 8th 2007 by s higgs

200. Not withstanding all the bigoted comments on here (homophobia & weightism seems to run rampant on this astonishingly nasty website), Rosie is wrong on this one.

The cases are not identical.

Frenchie posed nude for a website and made money off of it.

Antonella posed scantily clad with her friends for fun, and those so-called friends then turned around and sold those photos the moment she was in the public eye.

The key issue here is the form the contestants have to fill out and sign when they become contestants.
One of the questions is if they've appeared in the nude in public or posed nude or semi-nude for any publication, including internet.

Frenchie answered NO to that question, which was a lie.

I don't know how Antonella answered, but even if she said NO, she would not have been lying, as those photos were basically the equivalent of a friend having a point-n-click camera when you're partying.

Bottom line: Frenchie lied on her application, and thus got kicked off, justly.

I don't care for Antonella, I think she's a very weak performer and I think she needs to go.

But the fact remains: Idol did not favor one over the other, nor did they act inconsistently.
Rosie however did. She consistently speaks faster than she thinks. Sometimes she's right on the money, sometimes she's colossally wrong, like now.

Posted at 8:51PM on Mar 8th 2007 by Jack Frost

201. What the hell is "weightest"? It's not a real word. How stupid can you get?

Posted at 9:23PM on Mar 8th 2007 by Jane

202. I am continually amazed at the crap that comes out of O'Donnell's mouth, but it makes sense since her only talent seems to be modicom of acting ability and being a loudmouth on the View. Does she not even know that many front runners have been ethnic and overwieght?? I don't think that Barba is white, at least not 100% Only a moron couldn't see that the two best singers in this seasons competition are black, and one being on the heavy side. All I can say is, when is Walters going to fire O'Donnell and get someone with talent to host the show. I say right on to American Idol and the judges.

Michael www.michaelhacker.com

Posted at 1:57AM on Mar 9th 2007 by Michael Hacker

203. Rosie's airs of moral superiority are nothing but a smokescreen inadequately concealing her jealousy. Having never apologized for her "ching-chong" incident a few months back, Rosie has a hell of a lot of nerve to accuse anybody of racism, and I'm tired of her sticking her nose in America's bedrooms and making unsolicited moral judgments, all the while demanding that she be treated with the respect that she denies those with whom she disagrees. I had never paid a moment's attention to Antonella Barba before Rosie's rant, but now I'm a fan of Ms. Barba's. I really wish that Donald Trump would follow through with his lawsuit, and that Rosie would act on her self-professed depression by killing herself.

Posted at 1:29AM on Mar 25th 2007 by Brendan

Previous 15 Comments