Carrie UnderWeight?

46. I love both Carrie and Kellie!!! I think some of you LIE about supposedly having friends who know these people. I know a guy who worked on the Idols tour the summer Carrie was on it and he said she is a DOLL. This guy would not lie either. He said she was the nicest person on the tour that year.

Also, she looks much better skinny. Beyonce, J-Lo and especially Jennifer Hudson are way too fat!!! I don't even like looking at Jennifer - she looks like Miss Piggy.

Go Carrie!

Posted at 12:36PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Lauren

47. #43 frustrated: Did you actually see Carrie on AI last night? That is NOT a Photoshop'd picture.

Posted at 12:50PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Oops

48. The second I saw her last night I was in shock! I called my husband to the T.V. and said, "look how skinny she's gotten!" Her legs and arms are like little birds! She doesn't look to be exactly "too thin" yet, but let's hope she doesn't take it any further.

I would guess she's dropped a good 20 lbs and she looked beautiful before the weight loss. She isn't very tall so 20 lbs is a lot! She looked very hip in that little number last night! Very "modelesque"! It's something I would love to look great in but since I'm a chunk-ster myself I could never pull it off. Hopefully, she'll realize that she gone far enough!

Posted at 1:02PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Sandy

49. anorexic...chicken arms...and shoulder blades that look like a starving cow....she'll need hospilization soon...or "rehab"
another sick attention whore.

Posted at 12:58PM on Mar 9th 2007 by patty cake

50. Carrie said she gained weight while on AI becuase she was not eating right. Since then she is eating healthy (she has been a vegetarian since age 13) and cutting out a lot of the "junk food". She exercises when she can and feels good. Her hectic schedule has also contributed to some of the weight loss. Carrie is petite and is at a healthy weight for her stature. She feels good and that's what matters. Also, her family would be the first to let her know if they thought she was too thin! I think she looks great!!!!

Posted at 1:10PM on Mar 9th 2007 by carol

51. I'd love to be her size!! She looked great!!!

Posted at 1:16PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Skinny Carrie

52. Um, that photo is altered. Check out theskinnywebsite.com for the real pictures.

Posted at 1:29PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Rian

53. i am form her home state OK. I saw her back in Oct. when she came to concert with Brad Paisley. She looked so thin, granted she was weaing an all black outfit, but she looked scary. She is a gorgeous girl but her legs were so thin they almost looked invisible!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 1:50PM on Mar 9th 2007 by ucokaty

54. this is dumb, yes she's a bit thinner, but look at the pictures they choose to post.
Pic 1:
her face is lifted forward and at a slight angle
her arms are held away from her body

Pic 2:
her face is back, and straight on. of course on anyone it would make them look fuller
arms are tightly pressed against her body.

Posted at 5:43PM on Mar 13th 2007 by Sylvia

55. Carrie looks fine either way. It's her lackluster personality and hideous songs that need help. Sorry, but she bores me to tears with her shark eyes -- dark and devoid of emotion.

I'm glad she's doing well. I just have hard time understanding why because she's such a mediocre performer.

Posted at 2:36PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Angelique

56. Carrie Underwood is a beautiful and talented young woman. She is my favorite Idol of all.

Posted at 2:28PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Daisy

57. Carrie is gorgeous but she did look alittle too slim.

Posted at 4:07PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Newburghgal

58. Here is the proof: The TMZ foto is faked!
http://theskinnywebsite.com/site/2007/03/09/is-carrie-underwood-getting-too-thin/

Which means: TMZ manipulates fotos with Photoshop (or similar) in in order to make us believe that Carrie Underwood is too thin. This method to damage the image of someone is pretty criminal.

So, for everybody to know: Carrie ist not too thin. So you can calm down, and TMZ will pay 100,000 Dollar to the Salvation Army.

Posted at 2:55PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Michael

59. Carrie is beatiful and I would LOVE to look like her!! and she doesn't need someone to show her how to dance and for the people who said "eat a burger" no carrie is a vegatarian!! Yes,Carrie is skinner then she was on AI but isn't TO skinny!! and she was never plump people!! Carrie is THE best!! you go girl!!

Posted at 3:02PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Jenny

60. I personally love Carrie Underwood and think she is absolutely phenomenal. Her performance was my favorite moment of last nights show. Check out more of what I thought about her on my blog at http://blog.gotuit.com/index.php/2007/03/09/another-shocker-from-idol/

Are you an Avid watcher of American Idol? DO you think you could predict the order the top 12 will go home in? Do you want to win an iPod? Enter my Idol pool and if your picks are correct you could win. For more details check out my blog at http://blog.gotuit.com/index.php/2007/03/09/american-idol-pool-pick-the-order-win-an-ipod/

Posted at 2:55PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Lindsay