Carrie UnderWeight?

Former American Idol champ, Carrie Underwood, made her triumphant return to the show last night, looking like some weight had been taken off her shoulders ... and her arms ... and her face, since her big, pressure-packed moment on the Season 4 finale. What do you think?


Tags: carrie underwood, CarrieUnderwood

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 6 of 10) Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

76. she is a anice looking girl fair singer just got luckey . think casting couch .

Posted at 10:45PM on Mar 9th 2007 by ginagatewood

77. Well I think shes gorgeous either way- but I would prefer her to maintain a healthy weight- but Im sure that it is difficult to eat well balanced meals when you are flying all over the country- not to mention the fact that she has many stressors that Im sure those of us who are not celebrity's or performers could possibly understand. She does need to take care of herself and make sure she eats healthy to keep up the pace and not crash and burn from exhaustion like so many other stars.

Posted at 10:08PM on Mar 9th 2007 by tara

78. I just have one thing to say I think she is a pretty lady and a good singer but she looks like to is trying to be just like all the rest of the people out in there . when she was on america idol she look good and she was sweet, but it seem like she is changing i think when a singer is as talented as she is she not have to change her image or the way she looks.

Posted at 10:25PM on Mar 9th 2007 by jennifer

79. She looked great last night. The picture makes her look even thinner than she really is.

Posted at 1:48AM on Mar 10th 2007 by Anonymous

80. She looks great!!!! Don't be a hater.

Go Girl! Best Wishes.

Posted at 11:26PM on Mar 9th 2007 by ann

81. I think Carrrie looked much better with a few more pounds. She is much too thin and has totally lost that "Southern belle" appearance so much of us remember and loved about her. She doesn't look very healthy and I really hope that she gets the help she needs to return to a much healthier weight. To her, I say, Good luck on all your success but your health should be first and foremost.

Posted at 11:43PM on Mar 9th 2007 by Rosalyn

82. I guess all the overweight people (FAT) just do not have anything good to say about someone that looks as nice as Carrie does. Just because she is smaller than she was doesn't mean that she has a problem. Maybe a few of you people need to lay OFF the fries!! And good luck on ever looking as good as her. TATA!

Posted at 11:53PM on Mar 9th 2007 by stupidville

83. TMZ: Just the fact that you're referring to Carrie's older photo as being "plump" is the reason so many women starve themselves. That is not my idea of "plump." Thanks for contributing to what is an epidemic problem in this country.

Posted at 12:14AM on Mar 10th 2007 by JackieTX

84. carrie is beautiful! I commented on that when I saw her and also how is she coping with such extreme fames so fast. I think she is handling it very well. But only she knows.

Posted at 12:38AM on Mar 10th 2007 by P

85. She looks great. She is not to skinny. I guess in hollywood you are either fat or anorexic... there seems to be no in between with you people.

Posted at 9:26PM on Mar 10th 2007 by Melissa

86. She looks great and so far she is saying that gave up sweets and other unhealthy food.

Posted at 6:11AM on Mar 10th 2007 by Hello Kitty

87. Maybe a little thin in the arms, but she looked gorgeous. If only she had a little of Kelly Pickler's personality who I think is a riot.

Posted at 7:03AM on Mar 10th 2007 by Patty

88. I love her style, grace and confidence and the way she has been able to avoid making an ass out of herself as so many celebrities do, i.e. Spears, Lohnan, C. Love, Hilton, etc. I doubt very much that Underwood will ever put herself in any kind of compromising position to threaten herself or her career.
All that being said, yes, I do think she has gotten too thin. I had not realized how thin until I saw this picture. I hope she takes care of herself and does not go the way of Ritchie or Mary-Kate.

Posted at 9:17AM on Mar 10th 2007 by Susan

89. Eat a sandwich b*tch. You looked stiff as cardboard and sounded nervous, rushed, and forced. You look flat out anorexic - and your not good enough to have this fuss made over you anyway. Just go back to Oklahoma or Nashville and eat.

Posted at 2:41PM on Mar 29th 2007 by rene klaar

90. Carrie is awesome!! I thought she looked beautiful as usual!

I like Carrie is a beautiful soul and a talented human being, so down to
earth; more stars could learn from her and act like her. She is a class-
act. So gracious and beautiful all the time. What a whirlwind year she
has had, keeping THAT busy is enough to make anyone shed 10 pounds.
i don't think it was intentional - she has said that she just doesn't have
alot of time to sit around and eat.

Posted at 1:07PM on Mar 10th 2007 by Lili Sal

Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments