16. this is exactly what i said last week during her performance! it looks good, but very familiar.

Posted at 4:20PM on Mar 19th 2007 by darrlene

17. I liek Haleys hair! Shes a hot babe. Oh Haley!!

Katharine also has some of the best looking hair Ive ever seen!

Posted at 4:41PM on Mar 19th 2007 by bluesfan

18. I am a guy, so I don't really know... I am just wondering why women these days use hair extensions so much rather than actual hair? Are they "follcally challenged?

Posted at 6:10PM on Mar 19th 2007 by John C jackson

19. Ewww.....same dress too!

Posted at 6:45PM on Mar 19th 2007 by Vigilante Justice

20. Haley looks more like Laci Peterson than Katherine McPhee!

Posted at 10:34PM on Mar 19th 2007 by Isabella

21. Yeah, Kat is the hottest looking AI contestant who can really sing! Pathetic wannabe's can use her hand-me-downs including her undies and they wont even come close to her talent and beauty! And to those jealous haters, not only I'm gonna shove her extension down ur throat, but i'm also gonna shove Justin Guarini's CD up ur ass!

Posted at 11:32PM on Mar 19th 2007 by Kat Rap

22. I'd use Kat's hair. If I were Haley, I'd hope it'd bring me some luck.

Posted at 9:52AM on Mar 20th 2007 by Maurine

23. To John C. Jackson, it's not that women can't grow hair, it's just that they want long hair NOW! It's a way to change one's look. I think they're pretty expensive and painful and time consuming to install, so I'll pass.

Posted at 10:19AM on Mar 20th 2007 by Maurine

24. I thought that the hair looked familiar! I immediately thought that she was trying to look like Katharine!

Posted at 12:55PM on Mar 20th 2007 by rhonda

25. anna said, "mcphee sucks." I think she must be confusing her with Ms Antonella.

On the hair: The fact of the matter is natural human hair extensions are expensive. Katharine didn't want to buy them and not enough stalker types knew about the eBay auction to get the minimum bid ... so they end up on the head of one of next years contestants. I thought Haley's hair looked good and, ultimately, that is why you wear them. The singing could use a bit of work though.

Posted at 1:48PM on Mar 22nd 2007 by Charles

26. There is only One Katharine MCPhee, others can try to be like her, but its never going to happen. Kat is a one of a kind super sweet girl. And her voice is far above this one.

Posted at 8:55PM on Mar 22nd 2007 by Rose

27. I REMEMBER SCARNATO'S GRANDHAG SAYING SCARNATO WAS GOING TO PUT SAN ANTONIO ON THE MAP. WHAT?? OBVIOUSLY, NEITHER HAG MUST KNOW THAT JOAN CRAWFORD AND CAROL BURNET WERE BOTH BORN IN SAN ANTONIO, NOT TO MENTION ALL THE OTHER "TRUE" STARS THAT HAVE LIVED HERE. POLA NEGRI FOR ONE. BESIDES, OLD HAGS, YOU MUST HAVE FORGOTTEN "THE CRADE OF LIBERTY, THE ALAMO". BELIEVE ME, YOU DAMB FLUCKS, NO ONE WHO CAN BARELY TWEEDLE IS SOMEONE TO BE PROUD OF.

Posted at 7:53PM on Mar 23rd 2007 by Tricia

28. The truth is, Haley doesn't really "suck". It's just that her voice is too much like everyone elses. It's not distinct and that's what makes her forgettable (which is EXACTLY what Simon has been saying). She is a good singer, but not nearly good enough to be the next Idol. She could be a good hotel singer though.

And no one can lay a finger on Kat when it comes to talent or beauty.

Posted at 12:27PM on Mar 29th 2007 by afsoccerchica12

29. Haley needs to go, she can't sing that great. Her clothes are getting sluttier, just like Katherine Mcphee. She is acting like a tramp.

Posted at 12:42AM on Mar 30th 2007 by tammi_sutton2003

30. And, just what, exactly, has Ms. McFeever been doing beside losing weight, showing up at fashion week and getting a makeover....she's not exactly top ten on any music list. Pretty - $5,000 Talent - $1,000 - To be taken seriously and record something - PRICELESS!

Posted at 11:02AM on Mar 30th 2007 by GYPZYGAL