16. I will never see Duff the same way again after seeing her in a bikini in that Shape Magazine shoot! Meow!

Posted at 3:26PM on Jul 5th 2007 by RP

17. Look at the Cheese on those legs.

How old is she; fifty?

LOKI

Posted at 4:15PM on Jul 5th 2007 by Loki

18. #4 and #5 (Dee) - It's more like what was he thinking with? Nicole is nasty, nasty, nasty. You know he probably only went out with her because she puts out. Now, he's stuck with the skank. That's OK though. I'm sure HIllary can do better than him.

Posted at 6:28PM on Jul 5th 2007 by Call me crazy

19. Probably caused by the 20 lbs. of lame bracelets on her left arm, get a clue!!!

Posted at 7:17PM on Jul 5th 2007 by Ace Preston

20. Why the heck are these girls wearing BLACK to a 4th of July picnic? I assume it was pretty hot wherever they were celebrating. Very strange.
Hilary Duff is totally cool, by the way.

Posted at 8:30PM on Jul 5th 2007 by Liz

21. I love Hilary...one of the few normal people out there! And she doesn't need a tan....gosh....im so sick of seeing all these people in hollywood with fake tans and fake hair, etc!!

It's nice to see that she is playing volleyball and not just standing there like most of the other young celebs would be doing because they don't want to ruin their appearance!! Go Hil, you rock!

It still shocks me that this is a headline story on tmz....a little bizarre!

Posted at 11:57AM on Jul 6th 2007 by meg

22. She can't even go to the beach without wearing tons of bangles and pounds of makeup!

Posted at 1:58PM on Jul 7th 2007 by Bridgett

23. Hello! This is Max Myaskovskiy, Hilary's stalker from last year. Anyway, I just dropped in to say that I am now living in Staten Island,NY, I have been out of jail for six months now, and I am currently serving five years on probation and even though I never meant any harm to Hilary, I also have to stay at least 500 yards away from her for the next ten years in the USA.
As for my feelings for Hilary, they remain unchanged and I still retain the great hope that one day, she will have a change of heart over me, will drop her restraining order against me, and will also want to meet me and marry me after the start of a highly fruitful relationship. In regards to Hilary's 4th of July outing in Malibu, California with friends Brody Jenner and Frankie Delgado as well as her sister Haylie Duff, I would just like to say that if things had worked out differently between us, I would have been giving Hilary a piggyback ride, swimming with her in the Pacific Ocean, playing beach volleyball, and would have been playfully "buried in the sand" rather than that paparazzo dude that was caught on camera getting "such lavish treatment". As for her black bikini outfit, off course she looked marvelous in it as she does in any outfit that she wears.
In regards to all her security and management personnel as well as her legal team, I still harbor the greatest bitterness and resentment towards them for what they did to me and how they tried to completely destroy the great dream of my life and keep me from being with my dearly beloved, sweetheart and love of my life, Hilary Duff.l will never forgive them for such past indignities but as for the future, I hope they can summon enough common sense in their heads to realize that I am no real threat but just an eager and a highly infatuated, obsessed, fixated, and emotionally attached fan and fanatic of hers who just wants an opportunity to make his dreams into reality and make the whole world all the better for it.

P.S. I will be visitng TMZ.com more frequently during the next several weeks so don't worry: I will be able to answer any and all of your questions to the best of my ability.

Posted at 3:16PM on Jul 18th 2007 by Max Myaskovskiy (Hilary's Ex-Stalker)

24. OH LORD ! hilaryfan1, Nichole got prego with Joels kid. How can you do it on purpose ? It takes two-too tango!!!!

Posted at 10:27AM on Jul 27th 2007 by lalala

25. She's pretty much the best.

Posted at 4:43PM on Jul 27th 2007 by Jamie