46. who can be the skinniest? these woman are nuts! NUTS!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 3:56PM on Jul 20th 2007 by annab

47. Just remember....all of you mean spirited younger people are getting older too! Madonna looks great! This is just a bad photo/angle. Madonna takes care of herself physically, emotionally and spiritually! She's a successful business woman and an icon in the industry. Her age will never overshadow her accomplishments. Too bad you won't have any of these characteristics when you're her age....Yep; you all will be hitting the sidewalks from above and filling the mental institutions. I'm sure there will be no shortage of mean spirited younger people laughing and making fun of YOU. "time keeps on ticking, ticking, ticking...into the future"

Posted at 4:06PM on Jul 20th 2007 by ticktock

48. Sorry, wrong article

Posted at 4:10PM on Jul 20th 2007 by LuvTMZ

49. I guess the black baby is no longer stylish. Not too many pics with him anymore huh? Phony

Posted at 4:15PM on Jul 20th 2007 by WooHa23

50. STEROIDS !!!!

juicing seemed to start with SWEPT AWAY

Posted at 4:18PM on Jul 20th 2007 by dogandponybot

51. Damn she is showing some serious boneage there in her arms. I guess you can exercise too much. Yikes. Her face isn't as gaunt as the rest of her body, hmmmm.

Posted at 4:19PM on Jul 20th 2007 by Cheryl

52. You kids on here are harsh!! Let's see photographs of your arms carrying something heavy. Your arm would have the same bulge. It's natural. She's a thin, fit woman of 48. You should look so good at 48! Stop being so superficial!

Posted at 4:20PM on Jul 20th 2007 by baffledindc

53. No excuse for arms that look like that except "too much skin and not enough fat." Frankly, I'm happy to see her go to the boneyard.

She was a good entertainer who kept pushing the boundaries. She made millions on her albums, tours etc. And my kids paid to hear her. Then she has kids and becomes as pure as the driven snow and doesn't even allow her children to watch TV.

This tells me that she is a selfish bitch who rose to the top and was rewarded handsomely...and all by walking over the generation who put her there.

And we are supposed to be impressed that she won't allow her own children to watch the very things that she promoted to our kids? Hmmmm....

Posted at 5:02PM on Jul 20th 2007 by Rocky

54. If that was a black&white photo I might mistake her for an Auchwitz victim.

Posted at 5:43PM on Jul 20th 2007 by the truth

55. I am wondering if she is vegetarian?? Seems like I've heard she is. I think she looks like someone who doesn't get ANY fat in their diet!! A person needs to eat some fat so they don't look like a walking skeleton!!

Posted at 5:55PM on Jul 20th 2007 by mia

56. Sandra B as in Bullock??? Really???

Posted at 5:58PM on Jul 20th 2007 by mia

57. LOL........her arms look AWFUL !

She needs to ingest massive amounts of protien to fill out those GAPS, sags and indentations in her arms.

This is not a HEALTHY look for her. It's one thing to be lean and defined ....it's quite another to look malnururished. For someone who can afford a personal trainer she sure doesn't look like she has one.

Posted at 7:10PM on Jul 20th 2007 by The Wise Old Owl

58. Jay, #30, you asked who started this fad.

It was Calista Flockhart, Miss Ally McBeal. She was so skinny at an awards show that everyone started talking & all the stars were jealous of her.

Then Jennifer Anniston was at an awards show, and she said, "Wow, these girls make me look fat."

Right after that she & the other female stars of Friends went on starvation diets & lost all their body fat. And it just snowballed from there.

Posted at 7:12PM on Jul 20th 2007 by Swizzle Stick

59. Please eat Madonna, you are much to talented to waste away to nothing. Your fans love you!

Posted at 7:13PM on Jul 20th 2007 by Barbara LA California

60. This poor lady is turning into a senior citizen before our very eyes. She ages 5 years from one month to the next month. It's sad in a way. You'd think with all that money she would look a whole lot healthier.

Posted at 7:22PM on Jul 20th 2007 by Taller than I used to be