Broadway Not Aiken for Claymates Musical

An "American Idol"-themed musical inspired by Clay Aiken and his army of obsessive fans has gone up in smoke just one day after it went up in lights on a Broadway marquee. Did we mention it was about Clay Aiken obsessives?
Clay Aiken
"Idol: The Musical," billed as a satirical look at a troupe of Clay-mates from Ohio, opened two days ago at the 45th Street Theater, and promptly flopped like Clay's clammy hand on Kelly Ripa's mouth just a day later. The show's producer, Todd Ellis, said that he was shutting down the show because of a "lack of advance ticket sales, a lack of positive feedback from audience members and critics and a lack of sustainable financial resources." The rough English translation? It sucked real bad.

Backstage magazine called "Idol" "interminable, amateurish, headache-inducing," and that was just in the first paragraph of its review. Just for the record, neither Aiken nor "American Idol" the show were involved in the production.

Tags: American Idol, AmericanIdol, Clay Aiken, ClayAiken

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 4) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

31. Kelly Ripa and Regis are established friends and know each other very well, so I am sure Regis did not object to her putting her hand over his mouth. On the other hand Clay was a guest on the show and Kelly probably barely knew the man, so he had no right to be so presumptious as to put his hand over her mouth on her show and to think that it is ok. I saw that show and I thought he was gross and arrogant. Anyone else who think that just because Kelly did it to Regis, then it's ok for Clay to do that to Kelly, is sadly mistaken. Let some barely known person put thier hand over your mouth and see how you like it.

Posted at 12:47AM on Aug 16th 2007 by SAMI

32. Ok "Integrity"

I get it, you are a religious conservative who is also homophobic.

You have a poor taste in music and you are scared (lol) for Brit, Paris and Lindsay.

You talk about how horrible it is to degrade others and to treat others the way you would want to be treated, and than you call our president a loser and a liar. Hmmm sounds pretty degrading. You make judgemental statements about Ellen and Rosie (who is a fat pig), again, hmmmm

So in essence you are a pius hypocritical judgemental individual who knows how to post non sensical ramblings.

Judge not, least ye be judge, oh and one more thing....

BITE ME< BITCH!!

Posted at 12:47AM on Aug 16th 2007 by aLL aMERICAn gURL

33. I happen to like Clays voice, his looks don't matter to me when I'm in my car or using my IPod.
As for being gay, who cares about that either, it's NONYA

And what station plays the music you've recorded? Yeah, that's what I thought............LOL

Posted at 2:19AM on Aug 16th 2007 by Loves tunes

34. Clay come out of the closet !!!! Ur a fake!!! Love ur sexuality!!!Ur a cute g*y boy!

Posted at 2:27AM on Aug 16th 2007 by tell us the truth

35. I really don't get the whole clay aiken thing. I find it hard to imagine he is popular with anyone who doesn't live in a trailer park or a retirement home. How much money could those people have, so why is he still making money? or is he?

I get the whole giant corporation-production machine behind American Idol that takes people with little talent and manufactures them into a pop star, but how long does it really take for that to crumble apart when the hype fades and the lack of talent is revealed?

Is he really even a guy? or a she-he? Not that I care, but I really can't tell by looking at him what he is? .....besides gross.

Don't mean to be cruel, but can anyone account for why he is popular...now? or know what he is?

feedback please.....

Posted at 2:49AM on Aug 16th 2007 by tory

36. #30 Integrity

My what a dysfunctional, illiterate, ignorant rant! You only proved you're on crack! Do you really believe your salvation, much less the fate of all mankind, depends on whether or not people like Clay Aiken?

Put down the pipe and have a lie down for awhile.

Posted at 3:00AM on Aug 16th 2007 by tory

37. #41 Injun Mike

Yuck! that's just nasty. Is this for real or are you goof'in? Did you actually see any of this? How is it no video of this has surfaced since his idol "fame"?

not that there's anything wrong with that.....

Posted at 6:30AM on Aug 16th 2007 by tory

38. This musical was meant to make fun of Atkin and fans.. seems like fans stayed away in droves and won another one for The Clayman

Posted at 5:23AM on Aug 16th 2007 by BuzzedOFF

39. what is wrong with you people? you all have so much hatred towards someone who has done nothing to deserve it. all your comments are so superficial and pathetic that they make me want to puke. keep your stupid comments to yourself because no one cares what you all think. I'm not a fan of clay aiken either but damn, I'm not going to crawl to everyone's level and pretend i'm cool because I made a jab at clay aiken. so what if he's gay? straight people assume all gay men are feminine, but you'd be suprised how many are not. they're just not as afraid to show that side of them

Posted at 6:44AM on Aug 16th 2007 by websitesneedtoremovecommentsections

40. These people that bash Clay don't really hate him. They hate gays and because he isn't really gay, he is an acceptable punching bag to express their homophobic hatred. If Clay was gay it would be socially unacceptable to gay-bash him. This is also why they refuse to believe that he is straight and the tabloids print their lies. It feeds the hunger of the homophobic masses.

Posted at 6:57AM on Aug 16th 2007 by David

41. You negative people are so cruel I cannot believe it. Are you really that unhappy that you have to trash someone like Clay? At least he is out there making a living, doing multi-charity work such as UNICEF, doing wonderful things for his family, etc. Not to mention contributing his music to those who love and appreciate it. If you have nothing good to say, why don't you just say nothing???

Posted at 7:32AM on Aug 16th 2007 by Ann

42. This show should have been produced by Rosie O'Donnell...she's such a Gay Achin' fan!
And should have starred George Michael as his brother, Michael Jackson as his dad, with all the little claymates as munchkins!

Posted at 8:35AM on Aug 16th 2007 by hotterthanthat

43. Clay Aiken makes me puke!! Not because he's as gay as they come, but because he is not big enough to admit it. Shame on you little "man". It just means that you have no faith in your ability as a performer and the American public to look past such trivial things. Oh yea, never mind, you have no talent, you suck (in more ways than one) big time.

Posted at 9:31AM on Aug 16th 2007 by clayhater

44. You negative people are so cruel I cannot believe it. Are you really that unhappy that you have to trash someone like Clay? At least he is out there making a living, doing multi-charity work such as UNICEF, doing wonderful things for his family, etc. Not to mention contributing his music to those who love and appreciate it. If you have nothing good to say, why don't you just say nothing???

Hey Ann, So are a lot of us!!! (making a living donating to charity,helping our families)

Posted at 9:37AM on Aug 16th 2007 by clayhater

45. Can't stand Clay.

Posted at 10:18AM on Aug 16th 2007 by ohnoudient

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments