16. Well obviously she has made a name for herself and a good one at that. It's pathetic how people are so fast to find fault with someone. How in the world do you know what she has and doesn't have??!! I really don't know why I'm even talking to you....guess I was bored for the moment.

Posted at 3:05PM on Aug 15th 2007 by gigs

17. I SURE AS HELL WISHED THAT SHE WOULD HAVE WON AMERICAN IDOL INSTEAD OF THAT TALENTLESS, EXTREMELY ANNOYING, GRAY-HAIRED OLD MAN THAT LOOKS LIKE HE IS HAVING A SEIZURE WHEN HE DANCES.KAT IS SO EXTREMELY TALENTED. IF ONLY THE SINGERS OUT THERE TODAY COULD SING AS WELL AS HER. BY THE WAY, RAP AND ALL HIP-HOP SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 3:19PM on Aug 15th 2007 by IAMBEAUTIFUL

18. Jesus Christ people this girl is trying to make her dream come true and y'all haters are the one that have to f..k it up and end up that that trailer trash Bbriatch.

Posted at 7:27PM on Aug 15th 2007 by chismosa

19. It just looks like she borrowed that baby bump from Katie Holmes. I'm sure Hollyweird is fully stocked with fake baby bumps.

From what I could see (my opinion folks) is that K. McPhee was able to sing only one song well, Judy Garland's Over The Rainbow. Hmmmm......can't make a career out of singing one song you know?

Posted at 8:46PM on Aug 15th 2007 by K.L.

20. Her CD was given to my wife by a friend. I listened to it a few weeks ago. Wow, talk about amature crap! Acting could be her thing. Good luck to her!

Posted at 10:44PM on Aug 15th 2007 by Random

21. You Idol fans are so weird, so you didn't like her on the show. Does that really mean you need to follow her now and do nothing but hate on her.

Posted at 11:13PM on Aug 15th 2007 by batman

22. Im sorry but how much more money needs to be wasted on this girl trying to hype her up. ITS NOT WORKING shes a flop her new song love story isnt even getting hardley any spins its a joke. They probley only gave her these tiny movie roles in hope that they could get her naked in a movie next. Well at least thier plan will work because thats where this MCHO is headed ..

Posted at 11:22PM on Aug 15th 2007 by penlope

23. I'm sorry she has a career but instead of posting crap about her everytime she comes up on here maybe you could find out what the Idol loser you liked is doing and follow them.

Posted at 12:29AM on Aug 16th 2007 by chloe

24. I love Katharine McPhee. I've seen other pictures of her on set, she looks hilarious!

Posted at 1:05AM on Aug 16th 2007 by Jake

25. Lets see my idols have sold millions of albums and have won alot of awards and have not ditched thier fans at concerts to swim and makeout with thier boyfriend. have not gone around telling teenagers and others that its sexy to smoke. Have not gone around talking about thier boobs in every magazine article and on talk shows asking people to touch them. Have not gone to every magazine they could and took off as much as possible to get people to notice them. Mine to not admit to french kissing thier pets. This girl needs to grow up and learn how to be an actual idol im glad she didnt win because shes a disgrace. And I love the way you all act like everyone loves her but most of the public doesnt since only .5 percent if that bought he music and I bet its less then that because I know most of her diehard fans bought a bunch each to make her look better. So waaaaaa

Posted at 9:42AM on Aug 16th 2007 by penlope

26. I don't care about what your Idols have done. I would just like to be able to read news about this movie ( I happen to like Tyson) and not get bombarded with stupid Idol fans bashing the whole production and everyone involved because they don't like her.

Posted at 6:40PM on Aug 16th 2007 by chloe

27. Not a hater. I don't even know what her record sounds like. I've never even heard a Kat tune on the radio, and the radio sure plays alot of former idol tunes.
I just think she comes across as very annoying. She may have a pretty face and a pretty voice, but most people find her unlikable. JMHO

Posted at 8:54PM on Aug 16th 2007 by shelter

28. SHE CAN'T SING AND SHE IS SOOOO FAKE, SO YES MAY BE ABLE TO ACT.....SHE'S VERY FULL OF HERSELF..THANK GOD, CAUSE NO ONE ELSE CARES...MOVE ON!!!!

Posted at 11:41PM on Aug 17th 2007 by PROUD AMERICAN

29. The sad thing about the Katharine bashers is that they actually spend all of their time following HER career, reading HER message boards and blogs, following HER sales sfigures, wathcing HER on TV almost every night, buying HER almost weekly magazine photo shoots. This is so bizzarre, I swear they are all mentally ill. The only reason that they all showed up here is because someone on the IDF board suggested her fans might post a message of thanks here to TMZ for covering this story. And here are all the usual bashers, blabbering on about a BS TV reality show that no one really cares about. Truly Sicko/Psycho/Stalker behaviour.

Posted at 12:33AM on Aug 18th 2007 by Remur

30. This girl is AWFUL... I actually had the pleasure of working with the season 5 idols last year. While Kellie Pickler is dumb and pretty bitchy, Katherine was the worst. She let stardom go to her head waaay too fast, and refused to aknowlege anyone's presence that wasn't a superstar "idol". I want to puke when I see her acting so sweet on interviews. Really wish she would have crashed and burned. Everyone else was super nice.

Posted at 5:27PM on Oct 13th 2007 by ugh