Madonna vs Michelle: Cougar Alert!

16. I don't think Madonna's a hag. I think she's holding up rather nicely. Yes, I think Michelle is prettier, but you'd all be lucky to look like Madonna at that age!

Posted at 12:07PM on Aug 16th 2007 by And Justice for All?

17. Michelle is an 8.7. If she has her teeth whitened, she'll be a 9.5

Louise (Madonna) is ugly, and has been for years.

Posted at 12:08PM on Aug 16th 2007 by PatinNJ

18. madonna is a great entertainer and has made her share of mistakes. She does best whenshe just performs and keeps her mouth shut on EVERYTHING.

Michele P. is pretty ,classy, and is inside and out.looking at her ,you cna see she has not had plastic surgery. Michele looks real.

OH BY TE WAY, Michelle adopted a child ,Claudia Rose,a littl e Black child, way back before she married David Kelley and M.P. never issued a press release, made statements ,paraded her daughter all around for pr and anything else for show. Her daughter is HER daughter and she LOVES her daughter as much as she loves her biologicla child by David Kelley.

Posted at 1:38PM on Aug 16th 2007 by Botoxy

19. Michelle Pfeiffer is a true beauty.

Mandonna, on the other hand, looks like they attached her head on the corpse of a Transsexual, then brought 'it' back to life in a laboratory through the illegal use of stem cells and lots of electricity! Paging Dr. Frankenstein!

Posted at 12:20PM on Aug 16th 2007 by ZedsDead

20. Michelle's forehead and eyebrows didn't move a fraction of an inch in "Hairspray" or on any of her recent talk show appearances which means only one thing - Botox - and plenty of it! she also looks like she had other work done on her face too. Madge, never really that pretty to begin with, may have a great gym-rat body and has likely done a touch-up or two w/the needle, but without make-up on, she kinda looks her age. of course, had either of these two lived the stressful lives of most of us women, i.e., real jobs, real cooking, real cleaning, etc., they'd both probably look like graying, wigged-out fossils!

Posted at 12:16PM on Aug 16th 2007 by cripbabe

21. Yeah, Michelle is better lookin, but who would you rather have a conversation with? I would pick Madonna any day.....she's a brilliant woman, with a fascinating life.

Posted at 12:17PM on Aug 16th 2007 by Tam

22. I never knew that Amy traded up to the '79 Chevelle.

Posted at 12:19PM on Aug 16th 2007 by ace

23. Sorry but NEITHER one ranks in my books. They've both had plastic surgery and have private nutritionists, trainers, maids, cooks..etc... Take a picture of the everyday woman who ages gracefully and beautifully, and then I'll be impressed. Hollywood is so youth obsessed that the older celebrities are starting to look like manufactured dolls (scary dolls at that). Its not natural at 50 years old to not have at least one line on their forehead. Take notes from the old Hollywood (Audry Hepburn, Katherine Hepburn, Elizabeth Taylor). These older celebs do interviews proclaiming they love their age, they are so confident, so happy, etc etc but then turn around and get so much work done, they don't look like themselves. Really sad.

Posted at 12:21PM on Aug 16th 2007 by Kate

24. bad picture of Madonna...she's way hotter than that. She looked stunning during her last concert. I do wish she was blonder like during the 80's and early 90's. I think a lighter shade looks better on her. I loved how she looked in her "Take A Bow" video. She was stunning!

Posted at 12:26PM on Aug 16th 2007 by dttown

25. Um, Michelle has had A LOT of work done....but she does look good, even without any expressions...

Posted at 2:46PM on Aug 16th 2007 by JoeJ

26. Neither is aging well. I will say Michelle Pheiffer kept her looks for a seriously long time, but like everyone else, she's starting to "get there."

Posted at 5:08PM on Aug 16th 2007 by Lillian Gorham

27. Madonna's had work, Michelle is ALL Natural!!

Posted at 1:42PM on Aug 16th 2007 by ozzy

28. Um, let's try not to compare Michelle to a scarecrow. Michelle is muy caliente! She is so hot she has her own fire engine!

Posted at 12:34PM on Aug 16th 2007 by Luv Michelle

29. The beautiful french actress Catherine Denueux said, there comes a time in every woman's life when she must choose between her ass and her face. It is very apparent that Madonna has chosen her ass much to the detriment of her hard looking face.

Posted at 7:56PM on Aug 16th 2007 by pushing 49

30. Michelle has class. Mad Donna has nothing. She is so over the hill Go back to Kabballa land Maddy.

Posted at 12:35PM on Aug 16th 2007 by mangey