Celebrity Justice
Birkhead Wins Legal Skirmish with Opri

Larry Birkhead and Debra Opri will go before a jury in their bitter fee dispute.

TMZ has obtained a ruling from a Los Angeles County Superior Court judge, in which Opri's argument that the dispute be heard privately by an arbitrator was shut down.

Opri was banking on the judge accepting a provision in her fee agreement, which called for arbitration. But the judge noted that "Birkhead's declaration contains great detail about the facts surrounding his introduction to Opri. ... He states that he was introduced to Opri through a reporter with MSNBC [Rita Cosby], and Opri told him that he would not be charged any fees 'because the publicity from her representation of me would greatly benefit her legal career.'"

The judge was not impressed that Opri never dealt with Birkhead's allegations of fraud, duress and waylaying hundreds of thousands of dollars he earned. The judge said, "where a party provides weaker evidence when it could have provided stronger evidence, the (judge) may distrust the weaker evidence." In other words, Opri should have addressed Birkhead's allegations rather than just saying he signed an agreement.

Birkhead's lawyer Michael Trope said, "I'm happy with the result." See ya in court!



Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 7) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. LARRY BIRKGIVESHEAD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lol. That's great.

Posted at 6:32PM on Sep 6th 2007 by El Steve

17. TMZ's headlines are so misleading... Larry won nothing except to go in front of a jury where he will lose.

Mr. BirkGivesHead, did you sign this fee agreement with Ms Opri?

BirkGivesHead: I am not sure, let me ask Coward...

LOL - the drama continues!

Posted at 4:25PM on Sep 6th 2007 by LegalSteve

18. BeerSlave, Whack mole and Grace,.......... must be on Opes team , as why would anyone have such hatred for someone, unless they have a personal connection. It just doesn't make sense to me for them to have such fervor over someone else's personal battles.

They are way too passionate about this stuff, to not be in Opies court....no pun intended.

Posted at 4:28PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Pampster

19. RITA'S BOOK IS FACT NOT FICTION .. get used to it .. I agree Opri's fee was ridiculous but nobody else wanted to take the gay guy's case .. he was on his own without her help and Rita's. So play the blame game all you want .. it is Larry who I liked once and don't now that I know him .. sort of like how Anna liked him once and couldn't stand him and left town to be away from him later. I don't want to know him either .. He's a user ..that he was gay was ok with Anna, So while Opri was priced wrong.. it doesn't make Rita wrong .. she is a stellar journatist with credentials. He is nothing .. but now he is rich and enjoying the perks. None of which Larry deserves. READ RITA'S BOOK .. ALL TRUE

Posted at 4:33PM on Sep 6th 2007 by VAL

20. Cosby's book is every rumor/suspicion/innuendo Opri and O'Quinn has ever trotted out about LB and HKS and the American media and the American people are not buying it. In less than 24 hours every major interviewer in America trashed Cosby's lack of credible sources for her book.

Opri has already tried to deny she was connected with Cosby's book in a statement Tuesday night read on LKL.

Opri won't do well in front of a Jury.

Posted at 4:30PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Only swim in the Ocean

21. Opri thinks she is such a smart A_S. It serves her right that she now has to have a jury hear this. And we all know she won't want that. And if she wants to settle I hope Larry doesn't because people should be aware of all the distrustful, unethical things she has done. At least Larry has some good news to cheer him up for DL'S BD. Hope you and DL have a lot of fun at her celebration.

Posted at 4:32PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Opri is going down.

22. I hope the jury doesn't let us down. Don't give Larry a damn dime.

Posted at 4:32PM on Sep 6th 2007 by BB

23. Forgive me, but I honestly do not know the answer to the following question:

Does this common looking bisexual boy have any form of post high school education, trade or any visible means of supporting himself ? ?

A bum with an almost boyish complexion. Quelle future !

Posted at 4:44PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Harold, a private birthday party attendee

24. Anna Nicole dies..........and then ALL WE GET is Larry in our faces. Sue - happy Larry has sure found some wonderful ways to get rich off his baby. (If it is his)......they never checked anyone else but Howard did they?

I have no respect for you Larry, constantly selling the baby to magazines. What kind of person sells there own child? Besides if the books allegations aren't true........then why are you making such a big deal about it? OH YEAH THAT'S RIGHT........you want to make more money!

Larry, try getting a job damn it! Your as big of a leach as anyone else in the whole Anna Nicole Smith drama. I'm beginning to wonder if you and Howard planned to get rid of Anna and her son. Sickening the entire money grubbing STORY.

Posted at 4:35PM on Sep 6th 2007 by K.L.

25. Yeah!!! Larry!@

It's so nice to see this Lawyer is not getting special treatment from a judge... which is usually the case, since most judges used to be lawyers..

I am so proud of Larry - he deserves this one~

WOOOOOOO HOOOOO~@!

Posted at 4:38PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Nelle

26. I don't know. If I were these people I'd settle and call it a day. Really, is it worth it? To drag yourself through all of this, it really isn't worth the headache.

That was the problem with Anna/Howard. All the drama, all the suits. Seriously, she shoudl have settled with the Marshall's for a few million and called it a day. A few million in the bank, is great. Invest it and move on with your life. Versus what is going on...a big waste of time.

Posted at 4:40PM on Sep 6th 2007 by JD

27. You go Larry!
Next on the list is Rita Cosby.
No need of the way these women tried to use you!
They were in it together from day one.

Posted at 8:20PM on Sep 6th 2007 by fecesflusterer

28. Larry is the biggest con man alive.

Posted at 4:49PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Sue happy Larry

29. Of course Larry will win. Only a handful of people believe Rita and almost everyone even the media still backs Larry and believes him. Everyone knows what Virgie's true interests are and now everyone knows that Rita, Opri, Virgie Shelly, Nanny, and of course O'Gin are all connected and behind this book to purposely slander Howard and Larry so they can control the money. Of course this is about the unethical fee's she tried to charge. I can't wait for the bar ass. which Larry has filed complaints with to take this on and hear all the facts that she has done. Pay back is a bit_h.

Posted at 4:43PM on Sep 6th 2007 by Opri is going down.

30. INQUEST

INQUEST

INQUEST

INQUEST

INQUEST

INQUEST

INQUEST

Posted at 4:45PM on Sep 6th 2007 by INQUEST

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments