"Survivor" Fairplay and "Model" Michelle: Baby Reality

Wrestler/reality villain Jon Dalton -- "Jonny Fairplay" to "Survivor" fans -- tells TMZ exclusively that he and "America's Next Top Model" contender Michelle Deighton are expecting a little bundle of reality joy -- their first, and it's already 17 weeks along!
Jonny Fairplay, Michelle Deighton
And we're pretty sure he's not fibbing: "Michelle and I couldn't be more happier [sic] and I wouldn't LIE about that!" says Jonny, who's perhaps most famous for concocting what "Survivor" host Jeff Probst called "the greatest lie" in the show's history. He came third in the seventh season.

The sweethearts have been dating for two years. Where's an island when you need one?

Filed under: TV, Wacky & Weird

Reader Comments

(Page 4 of 5)Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

46. I see padded rooms and psychatrists in their future!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 8:15PM on Sep 10th 2007 by NYNY

47. I'm not sure who the girl is who went to school with Michelle but get it straight.... Her parents are happy you don't know what your talking about
If you went to school with her in 6th grade you haven't seen her or her family in years... People can say what they want i'm all about every one having their own opinion and the commets are fine but don't act like you know her or her parents if you don't.Yes I am part of her family and we are very excited.
Danielle

Posted at 10:00PM on Sep 10th 2007 by weluvchell

48. This is a waste of internet paper.

Posted at 11:32PM on Sep 10th 2007 by Justin MacIntyre

49. Contracting herpesyphiligonhoclap while escaping the womb will be this poor child's tiniest worry. Antibiotics can't remove parents.

Posted at 11:58PM on Sep 10th 2007 by Spyder Mayhem

50. So you gave up on trying to impregnate Alexis Arquette Jonny?

I'd much rather be britney's kid than have these two as parents.

Posted at 2:39AM on Sep 11th 2007 by Rockin Rod Watman

51. I think it's great that you guys are having a baby! I'm so happy for you Michelle. I miss ya and hope that you can come visit soon so we can re-know each other.

Posted at 5:36AM on Sep 11th 2007 by Sharyla

52. She's not gay, she's bisexual. Her and Jonny have been in a relationship for a while, they sleep together and with other girls but not other men and only in front of each other. They call an XM Show a lot and explained their relationship a few weeks ago. Weird!

Posted at 6:38AM on Sep 11th 2007 by Chris Brannigan

53. Wrong Michelle. Everyone is thinking of Michelle, one of the twins who had an identity crisis. The pregnant Michelle is the one that ANTM died her hair an awful blonde and she had a bout with with impetigo or something of that nature.

Posted at 11:46AM on Sep 11th 2007 by Lisa

54. I can only hope this baby is blessed with the glorious combination of its mother's sloping Down Syndrome forehead and its father's hawkish nose and ramen noodle hair.

Posted at 11:53AM on Sep 11th 2007 by NormanB

55. She was said she was bisexual on ANTM actually.

Posted at 3:02PM on Sep 11th 2007 by Crispian

56. At Dr. Al's Abortion Clinic we offer a deal where reality television stars get a 50% off discount. And since there's two reality stars in this situation we'll do it for free. Why you may ask? We have to stop this nightmare before it reaches another generation.

Posted at 3:56PM on Sep 11th 2007 by Dr. Al

57. omfg who cares woped de do ugly dad dosnt mean the baby will be ugly . and i have to say who cares if shes gay or bi. congrats she is havin a baby. she was preety

Posted at 7:30PM on Sep 11th 2007 by steph h.

58. Ummmm....isn't she a lesbian?

Posted at 9:06PM on Sep 11th 2007 by Molly

59. Congrats to you two!!! Maybe it's time for you both to cut back a LOT on drinking and partying so that you would be better role models and also lead a more healthy/proper lifestyle for your future kid. I love you, Fairplay but I care about your kid and his or her future too. I wouldn't want you both to be leading the similar lifestyle that Britney Spears is currently leading, with her heavy partying while having 2 kids back at home and all.

Regardless, much love and good luck to you both!!

Your #1 Fairplay fan - always and forever!

Posted at 12:05AM on Sep 12th 2007 by Miss Melissa

60. To me these two make a perfect couple, Johnny lied to win a MILLION DOLLARS, and all of the others fell for it , they where just way too easy. Michele goes both ways and Johnny is a real bytch of a man. Hopefully the baby isnt born androgynous.

Posted at 8:07AM on Sep 12th 2007 by PERFECT MATCH

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Hot Tips