Who'd you rather?
Who Would You Rather?

One of these two birthday blondes will probably stick her tongue out at cameras and scream something about being "punk rock" -- after she blows out her birthday candles: Gwyneth Paltrow (35) or Avril Lavigne (23).
Gwyneth Paltrow, Avrile Lavigne
The question is ...



Tags: avril lavigne, AvrilLavigne, gwyneth paltrow, GwynethPaltrow

Relevant Posts

Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 4) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

31. Happy birthday Ms Paltrow.

Posted at 8:25AM on Sep 27th 2007 by ilovewifey

32. WELL, TMZ.COM, YOU'VE FINALLY, ACTUALLY GIVEN US A CHOICE THIS TIME. BUT, NO THANKS. THEY'RE BOTH MARRIED.DOH! NO SCRUPLES, TMZ.COM?

Posted at 8:25AM on Sep 27th 2007 by ME

33. Ok, what's up with this "would you rather" BS lately? Since when did this site stoop to such low depths? I guess I am just stupid, but I thought you were a little better than that. I think it's ridiculous. If there's no news to report - wait until there is rather than load your site up with this sophomoric crap. It reminds me of those stupid jr high newspaper "favorites" columns. Who gives a rat's ass?

Posted at 8:39AM on Sep 27th 2007 by LB

34. More Greasy Bear please!!

Posted at 8:44AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Sami

35. both of these women make me want to puke ... Gwyneth because she seems like such a pretenious bitch, and Avril is just a rude, dirty-mouthed little tart ....

Posted at 8:49AM on Sep 27th 2007 by TWIST420

36. They are both beautiful women, Gwyneth is an amazing actress and Avril has an amazing singing voice. Why Gwyneth wins it, cause Avril can behave like such an idiot. Have you seen the video of her at her birthday sticking her leg out the door and making faces at the paparazzi - if she hates them taking her picture - why encourage it? I think she loves all the attention and just acts like she hates it to add to her "bad girl" image, which is probably all the fake. I wish she'd just stick to singing cause whenever she speaks it just sounds ridiculous.

Posted at 9:00AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Jedison

37. gwneth is ugly people only think shes hot cuz shes famous and rich when u get famous n rich everyone becomes hot they r both ugly pancake face n big nose

Posted at 9:08AM on Sep 27th 2007 by shubb

38. Avril

Posted at 12:04PM on Sep 27th 2007 by www.sugar-shoes.co.uk

39. Neither.

Paltrow is so full of herself, Id bet she is one lazy girl in bed. (what can you do FOR me?)

As for April, this girl does nothing for me.

Posted at 10:08AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Robert

40. Is it just me, or does Avril look an awful lot like Jodie Foster in that pic?

Posted at 10:14AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Trish

41. NEITHER!!!

Posted at 10:32AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Linda

42. could you stop with the who-would-you-rathers?
so boring.

Posted at 10:20AM on Sep 27th 2007 by sonjamills

43. Keen sense of the obvious?

Posted at 10:32AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Christina Ricci and Geiko Gecko Separated at birth?

44. How about neither? One has the frame of a boy and the other is old and too skinny.

Posted at 11:07AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Jon

45. I much prefer Gweneth! At least she has some integrity. Up until her last album, I thought that Avril was okay. At the beginning of her career, Avril was a breath of fresh air. She vowed that she would never use sex to sell records like Britney and Madonna have been known to do. Then Avril disappeared for awhile, and when she came back, she looked like a slut and all she talked about was how sexy she is. What a sell-out! It pisses me off to see performers sell their souls for a few bucks. A truly classy star - like Bruce Springsteen - would never stoop to that level.

Posted at 10:40AM on Sep 27th 2007 by Booboo

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments