Home : Who'd You Rather? : Who Would You Rather?

Who Would You Rather?

Posted Oct 3rd 2007 8:15PM by TMZ Staff

Teen movie queens Rachael Leigh Cook (28) and Alicia Silverstone (31) share a birthday today.
Rachael Leigh Cook, Alicia Silverstone
The question is ...

Tags: alicia silverstone, AliciaSilverstone, rachael leigh cook, RachaelLeighCook

Comments [41]

SHARE |

Email 4ie6

Reader Comments

(Page 1 of 3) | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

1. Harvey Levin you mad genius!!

Posted at 12:04AM on Oct 4th 2007 by FlBiker

2. NEITHER

NEITHER

Posted at 12:06AM on Oct 4th 2007 by anonymous

3. Rachel all the way ! my god she is perfect !

Posted at 12:08AM on Oct 4th 2007 by Robert

4. Kissing Alicia would be like licking out an ashtray.

Thanks

Posted at 12:07AM on Oct 4th 2007 by Conky

5. Now this is a tough one! Rachel Leigh Cook may have been at her hottest in the "This is Your Brain on Drugs" PSA. On the other hand, Alicia's PETA PSA was pretty hot too.

Posted at 12:08AM on Oct 4th 2007 by I Wish I Had a Third Hand.

6. RACHEL'S HOTTTT!!!!

Posted at 12:21AM on Oct 4th 2007 by cj

7. I would do Alicia Silverstone but I would make her eat meat also.

Posted at 12:21AM on Oct 4th 2007 by I just roll like that

8. ok honestly how can people vote on this...they look the damn same just A.S is paler.....maybe she just needs meat, lol.

Posted at 12:32AM on Oct 4th 2007 by same

9. Alicia and her kind are idiots. PETA kills. Look at their adoption vs kill track records. What in the hell do they do with all those donations? Seems to me, they have more than enough dough and don't need to do any euths. Oh, and they're against no/low kill shelters too. God forbid we save a few, and make them our "slaves". Idiots.

Posted at 12:32AM on Oct 4th 2007 by C

10. I've had a woody for her since her appearances on Dawson's Creek. Great things come in small packages. (Katie is still the ultimate)

Posted at 12:53AM on Oct 4th 2007 by tromba

11. I'd shoot either one.

Posted at 12:41AM on Oct 4th 2007 by Phil Spector

12. EITHER ONE WORKS FOR US WE ARE NOT PICKY! LOL

CHEERS,
BUSTED CELEBRITY

Posted at 12:47AM on Oct 4th 2007 by Busted Celebrity

13. They could be sisters - they look so much alike, except for the coloring

Posted at 1:08AM on Oct 4th 2007 by * MISS UNIVERSE

14. let mike vick have them both and he can have them in a nude mock dog-fight with all proceeds going to PETA.

Posted at 1:34AM on Oct 4th 2007 by KROG

15. neither- because neither of them have upper lips. just sayin.