TMZ

Our TV Shows

Got a Tip?

Call TMZ at (888) 847-9869 or Click Here

Who'd You Rather?

10/6/2007 1:01 AM PDT BY TMZ STAFF

"American Idol" judge Simon Cowell turns 48 on Sunday, while "Idol" champ Taylor Hicks turns 31.
Simon Cowell, Taylor Hicks
The question is ...

71 COMMENTS

No Avatar
31.

godtwo8854    

31? i'm 31.. and this guy looks 49 roughly..

2539 days ago
32.

Knows    

I am 48 and Hicks looks older than me! There is no way that he is 31. It's one thing to have prematurely grey hair. But those wrinkles? How did he ever get on Idol?? Don't they check out the contestants?

2539 days ago
33.

Seriously    

ewwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww for both.
Yeah, and when are you going to put NEITHER as a choice??

2539 days ago
34.

Gr8fulheart    

I've come to the conclusion that the one's responsible for polls like this are products of the '60's"! Are there enough brain cells still functioning to focus on any positive issues? Is this an example of what our country's future is based on. Only One Major Comment: SHAME ON YOU!!!

2539 days ago
35.

Jane Pall    

Simon! He is the complete package -- sexy, deliciously arrogant and oh so gorgeous!

2539 days ago
36.

Skank You, Y'all    

Simon. You're Hot...

2539 days ago
37.

Pieta    

Oh, good God........neither.

2539 days ago
38.

NewYorkBaby    

I've seen Taylor in person. Taylor lost a lot of weight and is very good-looking. If he didn't have the gray hair he would look like a 31 year old man. So, my pick is TAYLOR.

2539 days ago
39.

writergal    

TAYLOR! have you seen him play a harmonica! whoa baby!

2539 days ago
40.

nonaurbiz    

Would rather become lez. Those guys are skank.

2539 days ago
41.

NewYorkBaby    

Libra men are man-ho's. Doubt if either one of them has been faithful to a woman.

2539 days ago
42.

Karen1229    

You can't be serious! I'd "rather" do MYSELF!

2539 days ago
43.

www.sugar-shoes.co.uk    

neither

2539 days ago
44.

rudewaitress    

in my worst nightmare...

2539 days ago
45.

ihatefollywood    

Ewwwwww.........is there a third option?
You need to put a "I'd rather die" , "I'd rather jump off a bridge", "I'd rather run barefoot through glass".......(are you catching my drift here?) button on these things.

2539 days ago
Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

Around The Web