Tim vs. John

John is amazing...happy birthday John, you are my hero!

John is hot and talented..and has a new rolex for his birthday Happy Birthday Johnny! Love ya!

Is there a third choice?

Poor Tim didn't have a chance

TMZ, you pick some odd combinations for your "who would you rather" section. Spice it up a little more and try a choice between Pamela Anderson and Donald (Duck) Trump. I'd rather do neither, but the replies would probably be worth it. LOL

I think I'd pick OJ!

I LOVE John Mayer! Tim is cool, but hell yeah "I'd rather" John Mayer!!!

ah a John Mayer gay moment!!!

http://www.spymac.com/details/?2280695

John screwed that tramp Simpson, he's damaged goods now

"C", none of the above.

"C", none of the above.

John is quite gorgeous but . . . Tim is the MAN! ;)

I still think Tim is pretty hot, but I think John is hotter!

TMZ is trying to figure out who their core viewers are. They use these thinly veiled "who would you do" polls.

John, fire your make up artist Your neck and your face are total different colors. You still look hot though.