Who'd you rather?
Tim vs. John

Oscar winner Tim Robbins turns 49 on Tuesday, while Grammy winner John Mayer turns the big 3-0.
Tim Robbins, John Mayer
The question is ...



Reader Comments

(Page 2 of 3) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

16. you sneaky bastards...you put the names in the opposite order of the pictures and I accidentally chose TIM instead of JOHN....eeeek!

Posted at 5:14AM on Oct 16th 2007 by jastall2

17. I'll take John. Wow, he's already 30??? How old does that make me???

Posted at 11:10AM on Oct 16th 2007 by she smiled

18. Haha! I'm with you #3 - both these guys are idiots! I'd rather be alone the rest of my frickin' life.

Posted at 1:49AM on Oct 16th 2007 by KT

19. It's just not fair.Why isn't there a both alternative????

Posted at 3:38AM on Oct 16th 2007 by marisell

20. c) I'd rather Flea from the Red Hot Chili Peppers. He shares the same Bday and he' d kick both their asses! Or how about D) Angela Lansbury. She's hot!

Posted at 2:07AM on Oct 16th 2007 by Celebrity Trashcan

21. uh. who'd i rather WHAT? where's the VERB?



oh.


sex.


very funny.

Posted at 2:20AM on Oct 16th 2007 by kiki

22. Have them both washed and brought to my tent.

Posted at 2:36AM on Oct 16th 2007 by MissVee

23. I think you have to go with Tim on this one, of course

Posted at 7:05AM on Oct 16th 2007 by DevonLohan.com

24. Can you say 3way.....!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 3:19PM on Oct 17th 2007 by Just Me

25. is his real name John Wayne Mayer?...

Posted at 3:39AM on Oct 16th 2007 by da'truff

26. Come on this is not a fair match up. Its comparing apples and oranges. Happy Birthday to both lovely gentlemen. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2181126/

Posted at 6:59AM on Oct 16th 2007 by OhReally!

27. no thanks

Posted at 7:29AM on Oct 16th 2007 by o ya

28. Matt Damon

Posted at 8:54AM on Oct 16th 2007 by Matt Damon

29. I like Tim, but prefer John, even if John did have the bad taste to date Jessica Simpson at one time. We all make mistakes and should be forgiven for them.

Posted at 9:40AM on Oct 16th 2007 by Booboo

30. C'mon y'all it's just lovin...I'd rather do some lovin' on both of em.

Posted at 3:04PM on Nov 2nd 2007 by Debbie

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments