Tim vs. John

31. I think Tim is hot!
Problem is I am not old enough for him, I am only 40 and I know Susan is older than me and him, :(

Posted at 10:13AM on Oct 16th 2007 by SoCalRaceGirl

32. I'd rather do Harvey Levin

Posted at 10:46AM on Oct 16th 2007 by Sick of who'd you rather

33. I've never commented or voted on the "I'd rather" columns, but this the the exception.

Although John Mayer is cute (in a puppy dog sort of way), he's a flirt, a playa, damaged goods, shallow, and kind of annoying sometimes. He thinks he's all that AND a bag of chips.

Substance over style any day.
My pick is an odd one, but Tim Robbins gets the vote. The man's got substance, and some morals, is in a happy relationship and actually stands for something. He also stands by what he believes and seems to be a very good father. He's also a very talented actor. That's why I'd rather....
two thumbs WAAAY up for Tim Robbins. The guy rocks and THAT makes him sexy.

Posted at 10:59AM on Oct 16th 2007 by Shocked...

34. Happy 30, John!

Posted at 12:06PM on Oct 16th 2007 by me

35. Happy Birthday, John and Tim! :D

Posted at 12:49PM on Oct 16th 2007 by kira

36. Neither =( yuckkkkkkkkkkkkkk!

Posted at 12:25PM on Oct 16th 2007 by Kim

37. PLEASE Tim Robbins, PLEASE stop with the botox, peels and face lifts! You're too handsome to mess with your face like this! Please! I beg you!

Posted at 1:00PM on Oct 16th 2007 by Poopoo

38. I definitely pick John! He is smokin hot!!! Happy 30th Birthday John! I love you and everything that you do. I hope you get everything you want.

Posted at 3:49PM on Oct 16th 2007 by JM's future wife

39. Bill and Tom are both talented. I've always thought Bill's baby face was adorable! His movie "Jacob's Ladder," has always haunted me, because there had to be some meaningful message behind it and for the life of me I don't know what it is! Haha Either way, it's a great movie.

John's voice is a gift that mesmerizes and is soothing to the soul, mind and heart. It brings to mind a recent promotional quote from Robin William's character in a new movie: "Music is a harmonic connection between all living beings." I love that quote! Who hasn't exprienced how animals and humans both relate to soothing great music?

Posted at 3:37PM on Oct 16th 2007 by Vix

40. tmz, I've been waiting for this day!!! I choose John- he's my favorite singer, cute, an intellectual, etc.

I LOVE HIM!!!!!

Posted at 8:23PM on Oct 16th 2007 by blackandwhitegirl

41. Gonna have to go with John Mayer on this one. He is super hot and an amazing performer. I've seen him live 3 times already, and next time he comes nearby, I'll probably see him again! It never gets old! I love his music. Happy Birthday John, hope you have a great day!

Posted at 3:16PM on Oct 18th 2007 by Bunny Honey