Who'd you rather?
Ty vs. Chris

"Extreme Makeover: Home Edition" hottie Ty Pennington turns 43 on Friday, while "SNL" alum Chris Kattan is 37.
Who'd You Rather?
The question is ...



Reader Comments

(Page 3 of 3) Previous 15 Comments

31. The tale of two yucks.

Posted at 12:31PM on Oct 19th 2007 by Janine

32. Totally Ty. Chris may be younger but Ty looks better. Ty has heart and knows how to get things done. Chris would probably just tell knock knock jokes in the corner.

Posted at 12:39PM on Oct 19th 2007 by Ashley

33. I choose neither!!! This is the first time that I have ever said neither!!! If someone paid me 10 billion dollars to be with one of them, then I would choose Chris.

Posted at 1:58PM on Oct 19th 2007 by blackandwhitegirl

34. Right now the vote is at 23% for Chris and these 23% of people should just be killed. YOu have to be a sick puppy to want to sleep with that gnome. HE is so ugly, short , untalented and has a terrible ego (for what I have no idea). I love how he thought he was going to be so famous after SNL and all his costars now are but not him-haha!

Posted at 3:06PM on Oct 19th 2007 by Kim

35. I think Ty is handsome but he needs to lose the spiked hair and jewelry. He could clean up to look good though I think.

Posted at 3:06PM on Oct 19th 2007 by Kim

36. Why can't you give us a third choice for "neither"?

Posted at 3:49PM on Oct 19th 2007 by No way

37. please you have to add a neither answer it cant just be yes or no when i looked at these 2 i think i puked a little in my mouth so please add a neither button:)

Posted at 3:48PM on Oct 19th 2007 by scaarlett07

38. chris is cool. being from southern cal I just don't get that ty guy. He's just like every other loser that looks like him from this araa. He was a horrible carpenter/woodworker on that other show. I'm pretty sure he had next to no training, and no education. Probably road around on a skateboard and drank and smoked pot. Give him props for getting to the audition for that other show (trading spaces? or while you were out?). It's really easy to go to those auditions but somehow he got the part. For some reason older lower class and middle-lower class women think he's 'hot'. I have no idea how he scored that extreme makeover gig. no talent, no skill, no peronalilty. nothing. My girlfriend and I cringe and change the channel anytime that show comes on.

Posted at 3:52PM on Oct 19th 2007 by white lady

39. TMZ......ISN'T THERE A PLACE TO CHECK NEITHER ONE?????

Posted at 4:05PM on Oct 19th 2007 by sunshine

40. TMZ, you really should give us two other options:
"Neither" and "Death".
At least give us the "Neither" option.........

Posted at 4:48PM on Oct 19th 2007 by T S

41. I have been waiting on a split screen of Harvey Levine and Chris Kattan forever. They look just alike!

Posted at 7:24PM on Oct 19th 2007 by missjonz

42. Ty is on crack - speed - redbull - ritilain and a crap load of other drugs....I can't imagine being in the same room with that spinning top!

Posted at 10:59PM on Oct 19th 2007 by Just saying

43. I love Mango! No, you can not have me!

Posted at 7:56AM on Oct 21st 2007 by Kat

44. I can't stand Ty, who ever made this loser famous should be shot

Posted at 1:36PM on Oct 21st 2007 by Joyce

45. Oh just out of curiosity I'd have to pick Ty. I mean, he's such a freak...just think...he might use the University of Nebraska marching band to serenade you before hand.

And, if he'd build me a free house, no question about it. I'd do Ty in a second for one of those Extreme Home Makeover houses!

Posted at 1:11AM on Oct 29th 2007 by personmakingcomment

Previous 15 Comments