Celebrity Justice
Vanessa to Lawyer: You Can't Sue Me, I Was Just a Kid!

"High School Musical" cutie Vanessa Hudgens is seeking dismissal of a lawsuit filed in September, alleging she owes her attorney $150,000. Hudgens says she was only 16 when she signed the deal, so it doesn't hold up!

In his suit, attorney Brian Schall claims he helped Hudgens earn more than $5 million by advancing her funds for her songwriting and recording career. The suit says that Vanessa "has paid some, but not all, of the money owed ..."

Court papers filed Monday by Hudgens' lawyer, Evan N. Spiegel, say California's Family Code "provides that the contract of a minor is voidable and may be disaffirmed before (age 18) or within a reasonable time afterward" -- essentially, Vanessa was too young to sign the deal. The contract in question was initially signed in October of 2005, and Hudgens officially disaffirmed the contract on October 9, according to court documents. A copy of a two-paragraph letter from Hudgens to Schall nullifying their agreement is attached to her court papers, as is a copy of her birth certificate, which states that she was born December 14, 1988.

The court papers also say the agreement was with the law offices of Schall, not with Schall himself.

Related

Links

Documents

Vanessa's Request

Tags: vanessa hudgens, VanessaHudgens

Reader Comments

(Page 5 of 5) Previous 15 Comments

61. Man, what an ungrateful biatch. She shouldn't burn her bridges this early into her career, it might comeback and bite her. Where does Disney find em?????????

Posted at 1:59AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by beachdiva

62. Darren--You're an idiot. Everyone knows about her being only 16 when she signed it and she actually has no legal obligation to pay him. He doesn't care about her being a celebrity and is not doing anything odd. He just wants his stinking money. He didn't run to the media--he did what attorneys do -- he filed a lawsuit. If someone helped make me worth 5 million dollars I wouldn't care if the agreement was binding or not--I'd pay him. That 150k is nothing to her. Shes a selfish little bitch who is unthankful to a man who helped her when she was a nothing and, without him she could very well be a nothing now. That's what it's about--thanking someone for helping you--that simple. Save your stupid bloated lectures and judgements for your dog because I doubt anyone here wants to hear a loser like you give a class on law! Although she doesn't have to, because he helped her she should be more than happy to pay. You know, Darren, as soon as people read your "better--than-thou attitude" first sentence 95% of the people probably quit reading your wonderful page of crap!

Posted at 3:35AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by Get your braincells on Ebay

63. SHE DOESN'T HAVE TO PAY BUT SHE SHOULD. THAT'S THAT $10 WOULD BE TO ME.
HE SHOULDNT HAVE SIGNED A 16 YR OLD KID THOU WITHOUT BINDING A PARENT TOO. HIS BAD BUT SHE SHOULD STILL DO THE RIGHT THING.

Posted at 3:41AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by I SAW WHAT YOU DID

64. So a law firm handled this contract?? Wouldn't they have known that a contract signed by an underage person wouldn't be legal?? Maybe they knew the contract was so unfair that Vanessa's parents would never have let her sign it. Either that, or Vanessa is turning into a greedy starlet. It all depends on the fairness of the contract, which none of us really know for sure.

Posted at 8:36AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by pattijen

65. She does look like a monchichi! If she was old enough to send nude photos of herself to Drake Bell at 16-she is certainly old enough to sign and honor a contract...this girl is on a downward spiral here...she needs to watch out or her career is going to pass her by...my daughter LOVES HSM and it broke her heart when the kids at school told her "Gabriella" had naked pictures on line...this girl needs to grow up and take responsibility...she was "young" when she took those pictures...she was "young" when she signed this contract...can this girl ever take responsibilty for her actions?

Posted at 8:34AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by Kathy

66. You guys got know the details before you judge. There are so many slime ball lawyers trying to get kids into contracts, giving them a crappy contracts cause these kids don't know better. Plus she got her recording contract by being on High school musical, which i seriously doubt he helped with. We also don't know what she paid already to the lawyer.

I'm just saying that there are a lot of predatory lawyers especially in hollywood that try to make a buck from these kids by promising the the world to the kid yet giving a pittance, and by the off chance that the girl hits it big they rake in the money.

Posted at 9:58AM on Nov 2nd 2007 by chamber

67. What a bitch. I wonder if she also thought she was "a kid" when she exposed her nasty bush to the camera lens. She should pay up what a bitch!

Posted at 1:44PM on Nov 2nd 2007 by TMZ BITCH

68. she's just a kid but her acts like a slut

Posted at 3:03PM on Nov 2nd 2007 by sexy actor

69. Now lsten here she is no slut got it!!!!! none of you have the right to call that to some one you havent even met yet !!!!!!!! so she took photos when she was 15 an yes she was 15 at the time because she has a red strick through her hair and she had that in thunder birds (15 at the time) i bet you or your kids have done worse so back off !!! leave the poor girl alone !!!

Posted at 5:50AM on Jan 17th 2008 by VANESSA HUDGENS FAN

Previous 15 Comments