Paige-ing Kat McPhee!

16. damn! that's a star on the rise! do any other idols even get this?

she's gorgeous.

Posted at 8:32PM on Dec 14th 2007 by aaron

17. Re: my comment @ #12 --- should read "FOR those who give a crap..."

Anyway, to #14, those "same comments" are the same for a reason: they're from a single nitwit troll who's been leaving his "mark" on these McPhee forums for months--he's a psycho-obsessed, certifiable nut job who needs to be locked up in a padded room. You should see the crap he pukes out on her IMDB forum.

Posted at 8:51PM on Dec 14th 2007 by EM745

18. Katharine is a flop. Taylor is the one who is a success story. Number one touring musician of 2007. He's the next Elvis. Katharine is already forgotten.

Posted at 9:19PM on Dec 14th 2007 by Cake

19. I love her! Shes so gorgeous and talented.

Posted at 3:11AM on Dec 15th 2007 by Jake

20. You guys seriously need to grow up. Katharine McPhee's album one did not flop, and two she is not a slut/whore/whatever. How can you say such cruel things when in the video shes being completely nice when she could have just given TMZ the bird. Celebrities should look up to her and model her behavior.

Posted at 9:41PM on Dec 14th 2007 by katphan07

21. Hi Kat! This woman is beautiful and amazingly kind and giving. I'm just sorry to see how TMZ invades her privacy and then writes a negative comment like "we're over it", especially since she was very nice to them...I don't get it...she deserves better!

Posted at 9:57PM on Dec 14th 2007 by a3boymom

22. Ohhhh, now I see. All the mean comments are being made by Talor's fans because TMZ compared Katharine to him! Wow, why can't you just support Taylor and pour all your energy into that instead of following Kat around on the internet behaving like immature pubescent kids?!

Posted at 9:58PM on Dec 14th 2007 by dani

23. TINY RING -- NOTHING TO SEE. DESPITE THAT, SHE SEEMS TO BE PROMINENTLY DISPLAYING HER LEFT HAND. NO ONE HAS EVER HEARD OF THAT MIDDLE AGED NOBODY SHE'S ENGAGED TO.

Posted at 10:06PM on Dec 14th 2007 by just the facts

24. Don't blame the Soul Patrol for these comments. I haven't heard any of them say anything bad about Katharine.

Posted at 10:30PM on Dec 14th 2007 by Not So

25. She's pretty, hot and adorable. But is she lonely? I seem to see her profile on a celebrity dating site
RichLoving.com She has a great profile with attractive photos there. What is she looking for there? Date, love, or friends...? omg, can't believe it.

Posted at 10:20PM on Dec 14th 2007 by velar

26. the soul patrol? oh please....i'm a card carrying member of the soul patrol and and we don't dis kat. she's a pretty girl and if you like her great. who said these are taylor fans?

http://celebrity-do-gooders.blogspot.com/

Posted at 10:45PM on Dec 14th 2007 by writergal

27. I love this girls' voice and she's a really nice girl from what I've heard. The negative crap is either from the Soul Patrol or a bunch of 15 year olds that can't get a date on Friday night.. They need a lot more attention from their mommy. Taylor's a nice guy, but his fan base is the most obnoxious bunch of old battleaxes I've seen in my life. They should be ashamed of themselves, grown women acting the way they do..

Posted at 12:26PM on Dec 15th 2007 by Brentwood

28. I AM A Taylor Fan and the Soul Patrol would not say those horrid things about Kat. I believe these goofballs are just spreading their hatered from Taylor to Kat is all..
Kat is a beautiful young woman and is very talented, You trolls should really find your own home and keep yourself company...

Posted at 11:59PM on Dec 14th 2007 by Getreal

29. now come on Brentwood, we are not old battleaxes. We are dedicated to our IDOL just like the fans of the other idols are. WE are all ages and all sex's and we do not like the constant insults to Taylor just like you would not like them against your favorite. Give me a break already. The only Fan Group that would say these things is the group that no other fan group will have. Think about it, who would want these rude disgusting trolls in the same fan group with them?

Posted at 11:59PM on Dec 14th 2007 by Getreal

30. I think that she is pretty and talented. You people are so mean. Best of luck to you Kat.

Posted at 12:15AM on Dec 15th 2007 by Will