"Lost" Diary -- Confirmed Dead

LostHey, it's Daniel here, back with another edition of the "Lost" Diary.

In the week since the premiere aired, I think I've had about 1,500 conversations about "Lost." I don't understand how people watch the show on DVD and just plow through episode after episode. I need the full week to digest what just happened.

For all you "Lost" Diary newbies, here's how it goes: I gather with a group of friends watching "Lost," writing what happens on the show as it happens, and throwing in my two cents along the way. Tonight I am watching the show by myself -- time constraints prevented me from watching it with the whole crew.

Let's roll:

6:01 -- With the title of this episode being "Confirmed Dead," I have a feeling this underwater camera we're looking at is looking for the survivors of the crash of Oceanic Flight 815. As Naomi said last season, everyone thinks they're dead -- and as I said, someone probably went through a lot of trouble to make that happen. This could be that story.

6:02 -- Yup, it's the plane. Wow, a major prediction of mine from last season has just been proven right. Hang on a sec while I pat myself on the back ... Okay, done.

6:03 -- Dan, the guy who parachuted onto the island at the end of last week, is crying over news that Oceanic Flight 815 was found -- and he doesn't know why. So if this is Dan's flashback, and they are just finding the wreckage, I guess the question is: Will we learn something tonight about how much time has passed off the island and if it's any different than the amount of time that has passed on it?

6:04 -- "I'm Daniel Farraday, I'm here to rescue you." -- Daniel. Yes, because it's just that simple.

6:08 -- Daniel doesn't know where the rest of his crew is, and lost his pack that has his phone. He is the worst rescuer ever. He also acts like a nervous meth addict, which is odd.

6:10 -- Locke just correctly predicted the weather -- reason #825 why he's the man.

6:11 -- Locke just told everyone that they have go see Jacob (though he didn't put it that way) and he's getting his orders from Walt. Also, Ben looked like he picked up on the fact that Hurley let it slip that he saw Jacob's cabin.

6:12 -- "Because he's a liar and he's trying to scare us. Or because the people coming here intend to do us harm." -- Juliet, talking about Ben. Like I said before, Ben is always telling the truth, except when he's lying.

6:13 -- "Rescuing you and your people ... can't really say it's our primary objective." -- Daniel. Like I said, worst rescuer ever. I wouldn't lend this guy a dollar, much less put my life in his hands. The gas masks aren't exactly a confidence builder either.

6:15 -- As a few readers theorized on the message boards last year, the gunshot went through Locke's body and didn't hit any major organs -- because he doesn't have a kidney there. And Locke thought there were no pluses to having his kidney stolen from him by his con artist dad.

6:16 -- Jack and Kate found Miles, and he's, shall we say, not exactly friendly. It boggles my mind how Jack and Kate kept following Daniel without making him clarify the "not our primary objective" thing. Idiots.

6:21 -- Into Miles' backstory now, he appears to be some sort of shyster ghostbuster.
Lost
6:23 -- Um, I actually don't know what to make of what he just did.

6:24 -- "Tell my sister I love her" was in fact, a code, and Miles seems a little broken up over Naomi's death. Perhaps he and Naomi were more than just co-workers.

6:26 -- It took Ben all of about 10 seconds to get Sawyer to want to punch him, which he did.

6:27 -- "It's only a matter of time until he gets us, Johnny. And I bet he's already figured out how he's gonna do it." -- Sawyer about Ben.

6:28 -- After a few minutes of low-pitched babbling, Miles agrees that Naomi died like Kate said she did. Also, finally, Jack is figuring out that they need to get the hell out of there. Little late there, Jack. Little late.

6:30 -- "I don't know, Miles. How stupid are you?" -- Jack. Okay, Jack -- you're forgiven.

6:33 -- We're on our third rescuer flashback, and in this one, Charlotte is a female Indiana Jones of sorts who has just discovered a polar bear skeleton ... with a Dharma collar. Okay, this raises lots and lots of "WHEN THE HELL ARE WE?!?!?!?" questions.
Lost
6:35 -- Back on the island, Charlotte is introduced to the Locke group of Losties. It will be interesting to see what they do with her.

6:36 -- "Hi yourself." -- Locke

6:37 -- Leave it to Sayid to start asking Miles and Daniel the questions Jack and Kate should have been asking from the beginning. Actually, that would make a great show -- "Leave it to Sayid." Only instead of a precocious little boy getting into mischief, a hairy Iraqi guy tortures people every week. Tell me you wouldn't watch that?

6:39 -- "See there's your problem ... we don't want to be found." Locke to Charlotte. There's something about Charlotte, I can't put my finger on it. I kind of believe that she believes she's there for a good purpose -- and not to kill everyone.

6:40 -- What are the odds Charlotte's transmitter is attached to an animal -- like Vincent?

6:41 -- Ha! Too easy.

6:46 -- Our fourth rescuer looks like a surf bum -- and he claims he was supposed to fly Oceanic Flight 815 on the day it crashed. Seems a little strange to go from airline pilot to surf bum in that amount of time -- of course, we don't know how much time has passed. But something tells me that will be the big reveal tonight.

6:48 -- "Mooooo." -- random cow.

6:49 -- "Who are we to argue with taller ghost Walt?" -- Sawyer.

6:50 -- Ben shot Charlotte, but she was wearing a bulletproof vest. You have to ask yourself: What kind of rescuer wears a bulletproof vest?

6:51 -- Surf bum rescuer is named Frank and he landed the helicopter safe and sound on the island. Why are the lovable drunk pilots in TV and movies always the best pilots?

6:56 -- Matthew Abaddon and Naomi are plotting the "mission." Obviously, Mr. Abaddon does not work for Oceanic -- and probably not for Penny, either.

6:57 -- "There were no survivors of Oceanic Flight 815." -- Abaddon. You sure about that one, Matt? But that does explain why Naomi seemed genuinely surprised to find Oceanic survivors on the island

6:58 -- "We're here for Benjamin Linus. Now where is he?" -- Miles

6:59 -- After playing "This Is Your Life" with Charlotte, Ben tells everyone he knows why the rescuers have come to the island -- they're looking for him.

7:00 -- "Because I have a man on their boat." -- Ben.
Lost
I give tonight's episode a B-. They did a solid job of setting up the rescuers, giving us a dash of mystery there at the end with Abaddon -- who is shaping up to be a legendary character after just two scenes.

The five-person flashbacks tonight gave us some interesting backstory for our rescuers. With the exception of Naomi, you have to wonder if any of the four remaining (living) ones really have the whole story as to why they're there. I believe they know most of it -- but Naomi knew more -- and now she's dead.

One of the things I like most about the start of the season is how balanced things are. Sun and Jin haven't been prevalent in the slightest (go back and watch the premiere -- Jin looks like he was edited in later for all scenes, I swear), but for the post part, everyone else is involved equally. I hate it when sometimes we don't see Locke or Sayid for two weeks in a row. The balance of the cast has been on display in these first two episodes.

So imagine for a second that you're Jack. Your entire purpose in life right now is to get off this island. And then these people show up, pointing guns at you, carrying gas masks and telling you that rescuing you isn't really their top priority.

On the other side of things, you have Ben. He has pretty much become the bane of your existence. You have said on numerous occasions that you want to kill him. Handing him over to the rescuers will (probably) improve your chances of being rescued yourself.

What do you do?

Now, I think we, the viewers, trust Ben more than Jack does, so let's try and think of this from Jack's point of view. As shady as these new rescuers appear to be, if you're him, don't you try and help them as much as you can? I am pretty sure Jack would hand them Ben's head on a stick if they asked. Has to be a no-brainer decision from his point of view, right? Right?

Over on thelostdiary.com, I do a question-and-answer column every Tuesday. I skipped it this week because I felt we needed two weeks to really get things rolling. Click here to send me a question.

Reader Comments

(Page 6 of 15) Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments

76. Charlotte Staples Lewis---Her initials are C.S Lewis....like the author....very interesting....

Posted at 12:47PM on Feb 8th 2008 by KLC

77. Anyone else notice the Charlotte Staples Lewis reference...C.S. Lewis...The Chronicles of Narnia but more important to Lost is his novella called The Great Divorce about a few residents of Hell taking a bus ride to Heaven, where they are met by people from Earth. The proposition is that they can stay (in which case they can call the place where they had come from “Purgatory”, instead of “Hell”): but many find it not to their taste.

Posted at 12:48PM on Feb 8th 2008 by mercerrm

78. C.S. Lewis also wrote "The Screwtape Letters," which is about:
The Screwtape Letters is a work of Christian fiction by C.S. Lewis first published in book form in 1942. The story takes the form of a series of letters from a senior demon, Screwtape, to his nephew, a junior tempter named Wormwood, so as to advise him on methods of securing the damnation of an earthly man, known only as "the Patient."

Screwtape (along with his trusted scribe Toadpipe) holds an administrative post in the bureaucracy ("Lowerarchy") of Hell, and acts more as a mentor than a supervisor to Wormwood, the inexperienced tempter; almost every letter ends with the signature, "Your affectionate uncle, Screwtape." In the body of the thirty-one letters which make up the book, Screwtape gives Wormwood detailed advice on various methods of undermining faith and promoting sin in his Patient, interspersed with observations on human nature and Christian doctrine.

Ben, maybe???

Posted at 1:06PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Sinead

79. Did you hear the last island to ship call?? That was Zoe Bell!! She will be in episodes this season!
I am so excited for her~She was Zena's Stunt double before working with Quinten T as Uma's Stunt double in the Kill Bill Movies~Then she starred in Death Proof,
She is also in a Documentary called Double Dare~Check her out!

Posted at 12:50PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Love Zoe Bell!!

80. The cow was the eye patch guy's (before Locke blew up his compound).

Posted at 12:54PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Harlan Liftbar

81. to Kelli re Charlotte Staples Lewis--perhaps he was ihspired by Clive Staples Lewis = C. S. Lewis, author of Chronicles of Narnia.. bb1

Posted at 12:54PM on Feb 8th 2008 by bb1

82. Maybe the "man" Ben was referring to - I have a man on the bozt- or something like that??? remember Ben lies a lot...it might be a woman....his friend from childhood that gave him the wooden doll or it's Michael, or it's someone we don't know...or heck it could be one of those freaking polar bears! Who knows!

Posted at 12:55PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Victoria

83. bozt = BOAT...sorry guys

Posted at 12:57PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Victoria

84. Hey, Kelli...

Charlotte Staples Lewis = C.S. Lewis. Like the auther, Clive Staples Lewis, a.k.a. the guy who wrote the Narnia books. More literary allusions. More background mythology to sort through. It would have been easier if she had named someone Philip Pullman, because at least then the damn polar bears would have some kind of meaning.

Posted at 2:03PM on Feb 8th 2008 by R.U. Kiddingme

85. I have a hunch the rescuers are darhma survivors whom were off the island at the time their darhma gang were all gased by ben and the others...they are back for revenge and to get back to work on the mystical island...however surprised by 815 survivors....because the plane in the ocean is another plane...ben knew they would be coming and sent a spy to the freighter...probably michael...remember he was a spy before for the others...walt, locke, jacob, and ben all connected somehow...my head hurts too...love hearing others theories

Posted at 1:06PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Lisa lees sister

86. great job! anyone else think that most of the survivors and dharma people will choose to stay on the island, or are they all killed? i also question that these are the rescuers. they will be lucky to get off the island alive, and now that charlie has flipped the swith, others may be able to find them. ben sure has alot of secrets and i'd say has his finger in alot of stuff outside of the island. i just wonder why hurley would not want to go back to the island, he seems much happier and healthier there. maybe he is more in touch with reality then jack and knows they can't go back. and the beach bum/pilot, and the whole plane in the ocean makes me wonder about cover-ups of a very large magnitude. i do believe there are ways to hide the island from the public. think einstien, and the navy, the philadelphia experiment where they made a ship disapear. the navy says it never happened but it would work for the sake of this show. just some things i ponder.

Posted at 1:05PM on Feb 8th 2008 by meemee

87. did anyone else see the really crappy editing that allowed the helicopter pilot's head wound have grass all over it one second and then be clean on the next shot?? i just thought that was funny. as intricate this show is it was kinda nice to see a tiny screw up. i agree that it certainly looked like christian sheppard in jacob's chair when hurley saw him.. though i dont know what that means.
Here's something we've questioned... The person in the coffin couldn't be one of the oceanic 6 because its been said that they are "famous" - or "celebrities". Wouldn't SOMEONE other than jack show up for a celebrity's funeral??
i'm undecided as to who is in it.. but i dont think its one of the "oceanic 6" that doesnt mean it wasnt someone off the island, or maybe there is some other connection between kate and jack once off the island that we dont yet know of.

just wondering. and terribly excited to find out

great recap, btw

my favorite lines from this episode "who are we to question taller ghost walt"
also... "oh! you're a survivor from flight 815?!?! Is that better??"

Posted at 1:17PM on Feb 8th 2008 by joru426

88. Sorry if this has been noted before....
Was that Sayid's girl with Charlotte at the dig site?

Posted at 1:32PM on Feb 8th 2008 by sunshine

89. Did anyone notice that the pilot called Juliet a native? If you remember Ben killed all of the Dharma people because the “natives” did not want them there. Ben went with them instead. I think they believe that she is not someone who was brought to the island by Ben but, was part of the group that helped Ben.

Posted at 1:11PM on Feb 8th 2008 by cKah

90. "I thought one of the most amazing and insightful lines of the entire series so far was when Dan Farraday made a comment about how weird it is there on the island in that the light doesn't seem to scatter properly. Is it some sort of Truman Show type thing going on?? Not just like that, but in that vein. Why would anyone make a comment like that? It's just such a random observation, unless he knows something about the island which would lead him to even say or notice such a thing."

I agree! That line was, to me, the most thought provoking of last night's episode. At first I thought it could be due to the magnetic force surrounding the island, but wasn't that shut off when they didn't punch in the numbers and the hatch exploded. But maybe not? I think he made the comment because he's a physicist and it's his job to observe and break down those sort of phenomena. To me, it reveals that Daniel hasn't been informed about the island's properties, or else he wouldn't have been surprised enough to mention it out loud. He seems pretty naive to me.

Posted at 1:24PM on Feb 8th 2008 by Maureen Q

Previous 15 Comments | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments