Reader Comments
(Page 3 of 15) Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments31. If she has an amazing voice, why should her weight matter?
Posted at 1:12PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Michelle
32. Rumor has it around town (Birmingham, AL - home of Taylor Hicks, Bo Bice & Ruben Studdard) that she and Ruben are dating. I'd love to hear a gospel duet from those two. It would be amazing!!! I hope the rumor's true. Love can be found in the most amazing places -- even American Idol!
Posted at 11:48AM on Feb 25th 2008 by Thrillckr
33. I am not trying to be cruel but it would be nice if she lost some weight. For her own health. I have no idea who she is but it is simply unhealthy for anyone to be that heavy. She will be so much more comfortable on stage performing, too.
Posted at 1:38PM on Feb 18th 2008 by wickedsmart
34. Wait a minute! How is TMZ being mean? They didn't call her any names...so just because she's big and they post her picture that makes them wrong? So they should only post pics of skinny celebs? Those defending her here are sounding more biased about weight than anyone else!
Posted at 1:13PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Q
35. sometimes its better to be heard then seen
Posted at 1:14PM on Feb 18th 2008 by 2 bushels of balls
36. And DMD, we "tolerate" them as you say, because their wieight is only hurting them. Why do you care so much?
Posted at 1:14PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Michelle
37. Aretha Franklin is massive, but yet she is the Queen of Soul. Okay, Mandisa is obese. We all know this ,but she is very talented. TMZ just want you all to jump on the fat woman. Mama Cass was talented too.
Posted at 1:14PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Amara
38. Big girls are really smelly.
Posted at 1:14PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Respect yourself, geesh
39. omg i was at winter jam i saw her!!
Posted at 1:25PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Megan
40. Also, Kate Smith was the size of the Titanic, and she is legendary. We can't make them lose weight. No use pummeling them over it.
Posted at 1:17PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Surya
41. ITS TOO BAD THAT YOU ARE SO PERFECT THAT YOU CAN TRASH PEOPLE..SOMEDAY YOU WILL HAVE TO ANSWER FOR ALL THE HORRIBLE THINGS THAT YOU SAY ABOUT EVERYONE .... IT MAKES YOU THE ONE WHO IS THE LOSER BY FAR.
Posted at 1:20PM on Feb 18th 2008 by SUE
42. Can you imagine the force she can apply to a fart?
Posted at 1:31PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Stevo
43. #38 lmao
Posted at 1:18PM on Feb 18th 2008 by 2 bushels of balls
44. I'm not sure what you comment of "Res ipsa loquitur" (translation...."the thing speaks for itself") is supposed to mean with regards to your picture of Mandisa. Mandisa actually has a BRILLIANT voice and should go further than she will!! She should have won American Idol! None of the other contestants came close. Look...anyone who can belt out "I'm any woman", almost identical to Chaka Khan, can sing! She only lost because she wasn't a fan favorite.....in other words, she wasn't as cute as ____ or thin as _____. ((TMZ can surely fill in the blanks. You should be ashamed of yourselves!!))
Posted at 1:20PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Mag
45. Nell Carter was rotund, and she had a successful career too. There are plenty of fat singers out there who made it. It is better to lose weight, and be healthy and live longer though.
Posted at 1:20PM on Feb 18th 2008 by Deanie
