Bar to Carly Smithson: Don't Come Back!

16. Some of you people really suck.

Posted at 1:01PM on Mar 6th 2008 by MissMiss

17. carly looks like she got her eyeteeth filed down or something, they look different..

Posted at 1:16PM on Mar 6th 2008 by trina

18. Do you guys just lie in bed at night and think up really mean stuff to write as headings ? What kind of Mamas were mean to you as kids (TMZ Interns) ? Did the nuns hit your fingers with rulers ? Were you the bullys in Jr. High? I saw some of you on TMZ TV and you look like you were bullied a bit yourselves ! Don't forget about Karma .....Try to say something nice to someone, anyone today. It will make you a better person. Get a nice, affectionate doggie to love you and make you kinder. I recommend a Golden/Bernese Mountain/ English Setter/Lab Mix. Or, get a mini Schnauzer/poodle mix. Both are smart , loyal, and will love you forever. No mean stuff.....I'll call the ASPCA !

Posted at 1:20PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Just Sayin...we care about you guys.

19. I hope she wins!! She has my votes

Posted at 1:35PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Shakota

20. I DO NOT like this woman as an entertainer on AI. She acts entitled, like she is better than everyone else. The men are so going to have the winner this year-they are far more talented.

Posted at 1:24PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Anon

21. TMZ - truth means zero ... is it even possible for you dolts to write a story, ANY STORY, and NOT trash someone?... oh, what am i saying?... i forgot who runs the show over there, it's dorf from peoples' court!

Posted at 1:33PM on Mar 6th 2008 by big poppy

22. I think that they need to make some more rules for this show, how bout to be on american idol you have to be born in america! they have european idol. anyway, also, she had a shot at fame before, too bad it didnt pan out, but this is about discovering and giving a chance to people who have never been "found". Gee whiz, and i fear shes getting a wee bit of a big noggin! I think she needs to be gettin o'er herself dontcha think?

Posted at 1:46PM on Mar 6th 2008 by daniellecolvin

23. I agree daniellecolvin, they should have more rules for AI. She already had her shot in Ireland and she just didn't have "it" to make it, and now she is being gready by taking the place of an unfound talent. I hope she feels guilty every second of her journey. And even if she does win, she is going to get stuck in a strick contract and she will not be able to do what she wants and she will not make the money she thinks she will. Karma's a b*tch.

MY VOTE GOES TO DAVID ARCHELETA!

Posted at 4:04PM on Mar 6th 2008 by dc

24. I can totally sympathize with ANYone tnhat has to suffer working as a "server" or with the public in ANY capacity - I hope she wins as well.. being a subserviant grunt not only doesn't cover the bills at all these days ... it sucks! Anyone who can break out of being a wage slave is awesome

Posted at 2:53PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Hansette

25. I've had a 'blessed' Guinness before. The shamrock shape is a result of blessing the foam, a la the Catholic self-blessing. Lots of Irish bars do it.

Posted at 3:10PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Memememe

26. hey TMZ - I'm surprised you guys didn't ferret out this juicy little morsel:

When asked as part of her profile for the AI web site pages which American Idol moment from the past 6 seasons she cherished most, did Carly cite great performances or favorite winners like everyone else? No--Carly said "When Sanjaya got voted off." Whaaa...?? Oh, Carly. Dear. That's not just politically incorrect it's downright mean-spirited.

The discovery of this bit of nastiness caused such a buzz backlash online today that it has SINCE BEEN REMOVED FROM THE IDOL WEB SITE. And to make it even more ridiculous--instead of deleting the entire question, the profile now just has "N/A" as the answer. Laaaaame.

Posted at 3:28PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Rascal

27. I loved Carly's version of "I drove all night" last night on AI. Nothing wrong with an Irish girl being on AI, I think she is married to an American fellow anyway. Hope she goes all the way to the top 2 on AI. Paula needs to stay sober before showtime! She looks ridiculous trying to talk while high/drunk.

Posted at 3:32PM on Mar 6th 2008 by tld123

28. I like carly she is from my "home town" S.D. Where is The Field?? Does anyone know? I think she has a great voice as well. Not crazy about the arms but to each his own. Now who out there knows what HTH means?

Posted at 3:30PM on Mar 6th 2008 by Lori

29. MCA invested $2.2 MILLION in producing and promoting Carly and look folks she already had her big break, she doesn't have the "it" factor, she sold LESS THAN 400 RECORDS, and Randy was one of the folks pushing her at the label. They're just trying to make back their money off her and her past shows she is not going to deliver -- her label gave her more than one chance, now she's got a shot for American Idol? This is a rip.

Posted at 4:57PM on Mar 6th 2008 by t.k.

30. She doesn't deserve it. She had her shot and no one liked it. Someone else deserves it.

Posted at 8:54PM on Mar 6th 2008 by KMC