61. I love Carnie!
She is a DOLL!
I hate that people have to comment on her weight...
Yes, I want her to be healthy but come on ...
she lost the weight , had a baby and has to face
food everyday of her life.
It is not like other additions...you just stay away from
what hurts you...but food is there everyday!
Cut her some slack and let her exercise in peace!

Posted at 4:33PM on Mar 11th 2008 by KK

62. When I first looked at the picture, I thought it was Chastity Bono. No, I guess that isn't a compliment to poor Carney. I have a oousin who had gastrc bypass and she lost ton of weight What it doesn't do, however, is change your self-worth. Too many people get the surgery and not the mental therapy afterwards. I'm thinking ths could be Carney' prob. It takes a special skill to get fat after having your stomach reduced to the size of a walnut, but clearly it's possible.

Posted at 4:37PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Brewstie-G

63. Geez Louise, she's as big as she was before the surgery isn't she?

Posted at 4:39PM on Mar 11th 2008 by DeeBee

64. The problem she needs to work on are the mental problems that keep her on the fatty Mc fat's roller coaster!

Posted at 4:48PM on Mar 11th 2008 by mfab

65. It's funny to see how cruel and vicious everyone (including the TMZ writers) are when it comes to Britney, calling her a fat pig when she has a tiny pudge on her stomach; and then look how everyone including TMZ is kissing Carnie's whale behind.

She is a giant disgusting obese pig, period.

Posted at 5:27PM on Mar 11th 2008 by wait what

66. Nice example you are setting for your daughter.
NOT!

Posted at 6:24PM on Mar 11th 2008 by knows-the-facts

67. As for people saying she looked nothing like that on a TV show you just saw...those shows were filmed several months ago!! It is deifnitely possible for people to pack on a lot of weight in a short period of time. I watched someone blow up @ least 50 pounds one summer.

Gastric bypass is not a "be all/end all" solution for weight loss: the dirty little secret is that many people figure out how to eat what they want despite the surgery, and wind up gaining the weight back. If they don't develop healthy habits like eating right and exercising regularly, the weight will come right back. She needs to deal with her issues, whatever they are.

Addiction transference is very common with gastric bypass as well: some people develop problems with alcohol and drugs...I know 3 people that have had the surgery and 2 of them developed problems with alcohol, and the 3rd is beginning to gain back weight.

Posted at 6:33PM on Mar 11th 2008 by over it

68. By the way, you can't have bypass reversed. You can have a lap band removed though..which I believe is what Sharon Osborne had.

Posted at 6:34PM on Mar 11th 2008 by see ya

69. She's another example of bariatric surgery failure. She is NOT trying. IF she were, she wouldn't eat until she gains the weight back. A lot of people had the surgery thinking they could eat what they wanted after. It doesn't work that way. You are supposed to have psychological counselling to help with the dependence on food. Surgery alone does not work.

Posted at 7:06PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Gotta Getta Life

70. She had gastric bypass, and she's STILL that fat?

I don't know how that's even possible. I would have to eat incredible amounts of food to get like that.

Posted at 7:33PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Fern

71. Carnie is beautiful in every way. I have no doubt that she'll get to a healthier weight. She is an incredible spirit and fighter.

I love her.

Posted at 7:58PM on Mar 11th 2008 by California Girlz

72. Look at Carnie people! Gastric bypass surger does not make you thin. You must exercise willpower. Carnie needs to see a counserlor/therapist/nutritionist and a psychiatrist.

Posted at 8:56PM on Mar 11th 2008 by toomanydoggies

73. Th-th-th-that's NOT all folks!!

Posted at 9:00PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Shawn

74. She had a baby..... we all know how hard that weight is to get off. I think she looks great!

Posted at 9:03PM on Mar 11th 2008 by Lucy

75. I really feel for her. People who do not struggle with their weight really don't understand. It is an addiction just like smoking, doing drugs, etc. Please be nice to people who are overweight as our self esteem is already at its lowest. It is really not as simple as putting the fork down. I especially feel for celebrities who struggle because of the intense media spotlight.

Posted at 9:16PM on Mar 11th 2008 by rita