Simon to Idols: Don't Let Me Down!

16. I'd like to make a Skunk-Head and HotHorseGirl sandwich......

Posted at 8:48PM on Mar 18th 2008 by BigTicket

17. Thats funny the comment made about they aren't musicians if they don't write their own songs.......
Show me a "singer" today that does. Better yet, show me a pop singer that doesn't lip synch. Best music
era ever was the hair/metal bands........American Idol is a great show,,,,, Stop Hating.

Posted at 9:00PM on Mar 18th 2008 by DK

18. Am I the only one around here who thinks that writing "First!" is just about the lamest thing anyone can do? I mean how pathetic can a person be to call that an accomplishment?

Posted at 9:39PM on Mar 18th 2008 by Jim

19. They screwed up by bringing all of those girls in to scream the whole time they are singing, you can't even here the singers half the time. Also, I have never seen a bunch of girls screaming for a woman singer.

It reminds me of the way they used to pay all of the girls to scream for the Partridge Family and the Brady Bunch kids...........Lame

Posted at 10:00PM on Mar 18th 2008 by Buckeye Girl

20. LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Posted at 10:52PM on Mar 18th 2008 by American Idol sucks

21. The Beatles ARE modern. The Beatles' music transcends time. Wake up, idiot!!

Posted at 10:55PM on Mar 18th 2008 by Davey Boy

22. DK you sound confused. First you give praise real rockers but then you say stop hating on idol . That's an oxymoron dude! Rockers rule and rappers and America idol wannabes suck! True rockers hate mediocrity dude! Idol is the essence of mediocrity today !

Posted at 11:01PM on Mar 18th 2008 by I love rock and roll-put another dime in the juke box baby!

23. This was very very bad. What were they thinking. American Idol should have never used these songs. Hasn't Paul had a bad enought week. Why do this to him.

Posted at 11:37PM on Mar 18th 2008 by sandra

24. why is dreadhead not in this pic?? hello?? is this a hint??

Posted at 12:10AM on Mar 19th 2008 by paulene roark

25. Also, the American Idol news sounds good as well, keep it coming TMZ.COM

Posted at 11:54PM on Mar 18th 2008 by Jonathan Bodack

26. I wasn't a big fan of Beatles Part 2 either... but not because I don't like the Beatles. Who can honestly say they don't like the Beatles... that wouldn't be human!?! I just think only a few of them can do it justice and make the original band members proud. Thank the sweet Lord that David Achuletta didn't choke, because I really like his humble personality and hope he goes far. Even if he gets on your nerves, I would hope you can admit he's an amazing singer and just a great talent. He tore that song up tonight! I also feel bad for a young kid like him. He probably hasn't had the luxury of being exposed to such an empire in music like the Beatles. But my sleeper in the competition has got to be David Cook. He's solid in whatever genre they throw at him.
Please tell me nobody voted for Skunk-a-licious tonight. After she did a great version of Janis, I'VE SEEN ENOUGH!

Posted at 11:58PM on Mar 18th 2008 by YankeesRule

27. PLEASE tell me why Jason Castro is not in this photo collage???? Does the mole know something we don't??? i am not ready to say goodbye to Jason yet.... first we have to get rid of brooke

Posted at 12:10AM on Mar 19th 2008 by paulene roark

28. Who can honestly say they don't like The Beatles? I can honestly say that, and that would be human. There is nothing in this world that every single person will like or agree upon. It is all just opinions.

Posted at 12:16AM on Mar 19th 2008 by whatever

29. #26 & 27.................................He was tokin' up and missed rehersal................

Posted at 12:17AM on Mar 19th 2008 by YankeesRule

30. I do not agree with Simon, that this season has the best singers. Last season had much better singers, one being Melinda Dolittle I sure wish Kristy would leave. That guy Hernandez is a better singer then Kristy..

Posted at 1:10AM on Mar 19th 2008 by Rose