1. Judging from those songs, I guess it will be Michael Johns night..

Posted at 5:56PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Castroville

2. Michael Johns is as sexy as hell...he's going to do a bang-up job tonight.

Posted at 6:00PM on Apr 8th 2008 by M

3. No NO No....Syesha you are making a big mistake. Nobody can sing Fantasia's songs but her - haven't you learned by now not to touch the legendary voices.

This is a big no no.

Say bye bye to Syesha

Posted at 6:02PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Deb

4. jason castro is going to be wonderful with his song!!

Posted at 6:03PM on Apr 8th 2008 by chipdog

5. Syesha just put the nail in the coffin with that song choice.

Posted at 6:28PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Dara

6. Fantasia...legendary?? Umm, that's a bit of a stretch, don't you think?

Posted at 6:48PM on Apr 8th 2008 by LOL!

7. Ewww, I hated Fantasia and still hate Fantasia..she never should have won and Syesha shouldn't sing her song either..blah..I think I will be really bored tonight watching/hearing these songs...and I hope Brooke doesn't ruin my favorite James Taylor song...she is just so blah!

Posted at 6:56PM on Apr 8th 2008 by KK

8. Any song by Martina McBride is too big a song for Kristy Lee Cook, this could easily be the end of her. Fantasia has a unique voice buy legendary is definitley NOT a way to describe it. She's talented but has a long way to go before she is legendary.

Posted at 6:56PM on Apr 8th 2008 by CanadianIdol

9. I hate American Idol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 6:57PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Erica N

10. 10. I hate American Idol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 6:57PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Erica N

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

You are posting to an American Idol story, you twit. Go away then.

Posted at 7:00PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Loser

11. this list is completely different than the list posted over the weekend... check the second link.
are your moles making this stuff up? because i doubt all of the contestants would change their song choice the day before or the day of the broadcast.
ps- kristy lee cook is this year's sanjaya malakar. i hope she does not rob any more worthy contestants of their spot and return next week. in the words of randy jackson, "come on america."

Posted at 7:22PM on Apr 8th 2008 by lauram

12. 12. this list is completely different than the list posted over the weekend... check the second link.
are your moles making this stuff up? because i doubt all of the contestants would change their song choice the day before or the day of the broadcast.
ps- kristy lee cook is this year's sanjaya malakar. i hope she does not rob any more worthy contestants of their spot and return next week. in the words of randy jackson, "come on america."

Posted at 7:22PM on Apr 8th 2008 by lauram

==========================================
That other list was a joke.
These are the real songs.

Posted at 7:33PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Jenny

13. Why would ANYONE want to copy Fantasia?

Post #7 (KK)....totally agree with your comment

Posted at 8:19PM on Apr 8th 2008 by MommaT

14. oh shut it

Posted at 8:42PM on Apr 8th 2008 by loserbeware99

15. Israel Kamakawiwo'ole did the exact version of over the rainbow, he is a Hawaiian singer. Check itout on itunes and notice the copy

Posted at 9:17PM on Apr 8th 2008 by arpee