Tonight the "American Idol" karaoke all-stars will be trying their best to not massacre the songs that inspire them. TMZ moles have once again uncovered the tunes responsible for motivating the wannabes all the way to Hollywood and to your TV screens. Hold these accountable -- not us!
16. oh shut it
Posted at 8:42PM on Apr 8th 2008 by loserbeware99
17. Castro and Archuleta? Nice job. Michael Johns' choice? He's not Tyler. Syesha? After last week, you think she would have figured this out...don't pick someone that they'll immediately say, "You're not her." Duh. Carly Smithson? Ugh....what was she thinking? And that last one? Simon got it right....we're just going to snooooooooooze out of here .
Posted at 10:23PM on Apr 8th 2008 by Me
18. Honest Kristy bashers have to admit her performance tonight was at least in the top 4. Hope to see her again next week.
Posted at 10:47PM on Apr 8th 2008 by KristyFan
19. love david cook!!
Posted at 10:49PM on Apr 8th 2008 by alexis
20. Okay forget the contestants what the hell was up with Paulas outfit??? Don't these shows have stylist? That boustier top could NOT have been any tighter and it looked like her little tiny boobs were totally squooshing out the top! Totally disgusting!
Posted at 12:07AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Angela
21. I have to say, hands down this is the worst year.
Last year wasn't great, but I had at least 2 favorites that kept me watching, and the pre-show auditions were funnier. This year it was depressing. And I'm talking minus the sad "My dad just died the day I had to euthanise my cat" stories.
Its all just depressing. The auditions weren't as funny, a lot of the contestants were depessing and brought everyone down, the top contestants have the most attitude this year, and I'm not talking Self Confidence, I'm talking diva-tude... Randy is too down, Simon is too nice and Paula isn't as funny wacked out as she usually is.
When that one deer in the headlights blonde girl made it through yet again, I stopped watching. This is the first time since season 1, I have missed the show several weeks in a row now.
They need to do something to spice next year up, or the next season could be their last.
As for fantasia... I still don't understand the hubbub about her. I never really thought she was that good. I never hear her on the radio... and if she has been played, then I was giving another singer credit for her song... and that's not a good thing for an artist.
Posted at 12:24AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Mayu
22. I love David Cook, but Michael Johns rocked it tonight tho!
Posted at 12:10AM on Apr 9th 2008 by RP
23. I love David Cook, but Michael Johns rocked it tonight tho!
Posted at 12:14AM on Apr 9th 2008 by RP
24. I think if three of these contestants have had recording contracts in the past, they should be excluded from the contest. Give the "average joe" the chance to make something of themselves. What about the girl who was a single Mom and had a child with learning disabilities? SHE WAS GOOD! She should have made it, in place of these three who have HAD the chance!!!
Posted at 12:49AM on Apr 9th 2008 by SOCKS399
25. KK I agree with the James Taylor song. He IS the only one who can truly do it justice and she didn't...'nuff said!!
Posted at 12:49AM on Apr 9th 2008 by SOCKS399
26. I agree with Mayu...this season is not like the others..it's BORING!!!!! There is noone who stands out that anybody can root for...it's a very dull season. As far as the judges saying its the best yet...well, of course, thats what they get paid for!!
Posted at 1:57AM on Apr 9th 2008 by SOCKS399
27. very dull season there getting worse when they should be getting better david cook i like though and carly
Posted at 1:16AM on Apr 9th 2008 by red head /not dead
28. Did anyone else notice that when the clips of all the contestants were shown at the end of the show, the audience was doing their goofy little "clap along" with Jason's Somewhere Over the Rainbow, but during the live perfornance that we all saw, the audience didn't clap along? The producers obviously talked to the audience in between the preshow rehearsal and the live telecast.
Too bad they couldn't do anything to stop Sayesha from butchering another song.
Posted at 1:21AM on Apr 9th 2008 by cc
29. Tonight's best were David Archuleta, Jason Castro and Kristy Lee Cook. They all chose great songs and gave amazing performances!
Posted at 2:14AM on Apr 9th 2008 by Renee
30. You know, I don't know why the judges were so harsh on Carly...I thought she did pretty good. I "felt it" as Randy would say.
Though....it was nice to see David Cook brought down a peg. Bout darn time "Creed Boy".
Posted at 12:45PM on Apr 9th 2008 by Give The Irish Girl A Break
ElinNordegren fight MichaelJackson MileyCyrus ErinAndrews crash KateGosselin accident DomesticViolence suv TigerWoods photos PeepingTom lawsuit video photo FireHydrant CelebrityPictures latoyajackson pictures LindsayLohan football shopping gallery voicemail paparazzi rihanna CarriePrejean AdamLambert BurglarBunch gossip propofol twilight KristenStewart Dr.ConradMurray xxx house LamarOdom BritneySpears MariaShriver JaimeeGrubbs divorce NationalEnquirer TaylorSwift lax CelebrityGossip muffingate FloridaHighwayPatrol tree BarackObama mistress ParkingTicket australia TilaTequila HulkHogan butt dui JonKatePlus8 LosAngeles JonGosselin octomom contest TaxLien vote RobertPattinson naked ArnoldSchwarzenegger celebrity NadyaSuleman prize FHP DebbieRowe sextape 911Call court
'Memba Them?! 
