"Glitter 2" -- "Idols" Sing Mariah

David Cook blew everyone else away!! Jason boring as usual the guy needs to do something besides sit down every week to sing

Mariah Carey is such a has-been.. her time is up, time to let go!!

Mariah Carey has a wonderful talent. In her early days she was lovely and sweet. Somewhere along the way she became more concerned with her sexuality than her singing. She is always wearing those ridiculous skin tight low cut outfits, with her boobs hanging out. How does someone let their boobs get in the way of their talent? She has a lovely, surgically enhanced figure, but that should be secondary.

JESSE... YOUR AN IDIOT... DO YOU NOT KNOW THAT SHE JUST BROKE THE RECORD ELVIS HAD FOR #1 SINGLES??? SHE IS SO FAR FROM BEING A HAS BEEN

I still can't get over last week's elimination. Maybe a bunch of people decided to tie up lines by staying on the line of the person they wanted eliminated until the phone system beeped them off which would take a lot longer than just waiting for the vote validation. Maybe it was people who got mad at Fox for extending the program 2 minutes after the hour and thus fowling up their replay systems for recording the show following????

All the Idols did very well, too bad for TMZ, but I'm sure you'll find some minor stupid thing to bitch about.

BTW, TMZ...did you guys hire adult writers/editors yet? It still looks like your site was written by retarded junior high school kids.

just sayin'!

#50: I totally agree, Brooke White has got to go. Last night I was embarrassed for her, she was terrible. Initially there was something I liked about her personality, now she rubs me the wrong way.

Thank you Elle and Kat!! Brooke must go! I really dont understand why people are voting for her, just proves that most of the public i as tone-deaf as I thought they were. Just look at last nights performances and it is entirely too clear her vocal ability and range is so far below that of everyone else there. She has sung such simple melodies like last night, Here Comes the Sun, You're so Vain...does she sing them OK...of course...but thats it. Its kinda hard to screw up a song that only requires a minimal amount of vocal talent. This show isnt about you can carry a simple tune, its about finding the best of the best and if thats all it takes to win I should be auditioning next year. Not only that, I dont think I can stand to see her "poor me" act during critique one more week. There is nothing more immature than not being able to shut up and listen to the judges.

Brooke always acts like she's already won the damn thing. I'll be happy to see her go tonight.

Great Show!! It took me 45 minutes of busy signals before I could get my vote for David Cook through. I was surprised. I thought I wouldn't like hearing them sing Mariah songs. I do agree with Simon that the guys were better, but none of them were terrible.

I am recording American Idol tonight and I will watch Mariah Carey on American on my Digital Video Recorder (DVR) tomorrow morning. And Mariah Carey is the only reason!!!!

Thank heavens Kristy got voted off!!!! WOOT

THIS CHALLENGE IS GOING TO DETERMINE WHO HAS THE REAL TALENT TO SING!

As I live in England I have only just seen the show last night. Summary David A -personality of a wet mop, Jason - wet mops older brother, Brooke - wet mops sister, Syesha (made up name) - wet mop's cousin twice removed, Kirsty - looks like a wet mop but has absolutely no relationship with the others, Carly - slightly drier mop and don't you forget it and David C. Well he's more of a broom as he swept the compettion away. Anyway that's enough of the domestice appliances. How are you all in America. I like the fact that Leona seems to be doing so well over there. And yes we love Simon too.

The idols do a better job at Mariah's songs than she does. All her songs sound the same, blech! She is so over rated And whats with the hands? She looks retarded, like she's conducting an orchestra. I dont' get how she's sold so many records.
ROCK ON DAVID COOK! LOVE YOU!!!