"A.I." Song List -- It'll Be a Gay Ol' Night

16. PLEASE REPLACE PAULA!!!! She yammers on and on saying NOTHING. Hem. Haw. Hem. Haw.....hem.......uh.....haw.....
Can she ever speak a complete sentence? She's either dumb or on drugs. I've never seen anyone chop up a simple sentence into incomprehensible blatherings like Paula Abdul.

Posted at 8:44PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by ABOUT PAULA

17. So Brooke starts over again. Then she says, "It's the first time I've done that." No, Brooke, unlike anyone else on the show, you've started over twice. Loser.

Posted at 8:44PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by BROOKE SUCKS

18. Somewhere along the line Brooke White convinced herself it's cute for a 40 something woman to make pouty faces like a five year old. Somebody set her straight.

Posted at 8:44PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by BROOKE WHITE

19. No wonder the ratings for AI are so down, particularly amongst the desireable younger crowd. Who wants to watch these sorts of themes?

Posted at 8:54PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by brazen weep

20. Archuleta sucked... he totally ruined that song, bigtime. Carly and David Cook were my faves tonight.

I like that they did the Andrew Lloyd Webber thing instead of the typical stuff. Really goes a long way to show off who actually has talent.

Posted at 9:31PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by theGirl

21. BROOKE WHITE....u need to remove something..just saying...she is only 24 and married.

Posted at 9:46PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by 22 HRS UNTIL LEONA LEWIS SINGS.

22. ANYWAYS....I WANT DAVID COOK TO WIN...LOVE HIS PASSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 9:52PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by 22 HRS UNTIL LEONA LEWIS SINGS.

23. 14. oh good-something new, a ballad from David A--ugh!

Posted at 7:29PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by chelsea




I know right! I dont get why he is a judges favorite.. It will be the 2 Davids in the end anyway I believe... David Cook Not only looked like his sexy self but did really good with a different type of song..

Posted at 10:54PM on Apr 22nd 2008 by Star

24. Am I the only one that thinks Andrew Lloyd Webber looks like David Guest?

Posted at 12:25AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by whatado

25. David Cook's version of "Music of the night" was amazing. He can do broadway. lol

Posted at 1:59AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Julie

26. the fat lady is warming up for her solo too!..THE BEST QUOTE OF THE WEEK!

Posted at 2:52AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by PapaSmurf

27. Where is Constantine Maroulis now? Back stage talking to Andrew Lloyd Webber! You can see for yourself in LA on May 6th- come check out Constantine's acoustic show at the Knitting Factory. Hopefully he'll sing a couple of songs from ALWebber's Jesus Christ Super Star since he has performed them on stage before in the roles of both Judas and Jesus.

Posted at 4:11AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by jyes

28. Brook needs to move on she is out of there after tonight. Just my thoughts. She is a sweet girl and all but she needs to grow up and stop acting so cutsey.

Posted at 7:48AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by lori

29. David Cook was the best by far of any of them. He should WIN this hole thing. He is truely the most talented. Brooke has to go. Sorry, Brooke, stop and starting come on.

Posted at 8:43AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by amazing

30. Holy!!! and I thought Maria's night was boring... why do they choose these boring themes nobody cares about? they want pop stars!!! 2 of the things simon always complains about "mariah and broadway"... and they bring them as mentors... zzzzzzzz

Posted at 9:31AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by paupau