"A.I." Song List -- It'll Be a Gay Ol' Night

31. Yea Syesha! I was happy that she started off with music from Starlight Express, since that's my favorite ALW musical. I thought she really did well with it. She, Carly and David C were the best. I think either Jason (most likely) or Brooke will be gone tonight. It's too bad Brooke did the 'start over' since she did well with the song.

Posted at 9:53AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by GrannyJ

32. I thought that David Cook was the best. You have to laugh - Simon compares the singers to Broadway singers when they do poorly, and then they have a Broadway night...

Speaking of which, I remember when Constantine was on. He was good, operative word being was. I just wonder after all of that "smoking" if his voice is still as strong as it used to be... He was just at a party promoting a book about stoners, wasn't he? Yeah, that's a shining example of a 6th place American Idol. Besides, he's too busy filming a pilot - remember?

Posted at 12:29PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Katie

33. Sorry, but in my opinion, none of them measured up to singing Broadway. Neither the David's nor Jason nor any of the girls was very good. David C tries to be all sexy but seems to fall short. Sorry, unpopular opinion but my opinion just the same. He's still such a little boy.

Posted at 3:31PM on Apr 24th 2008 by Angie

34. American Idol is rigged! Paula Abdul proved it tonight when they were supposed to be critiquing the first song of the two, and then she began critiquing him on his second song he hadn’t even sang yet.

Either she's wasted on drugs or she's having one too many drinks.

Posted at 11:37PM on Apr 29th 2008 by Noah

35. I am so sick of that kid Archuletta. He's lame, too predictable, and I just wish he would go the hell away. He may be cute, but that too will fade with age. I kind of suspect that the dad in the audience isn't even his dad. Mommy probably had an outside affair. He looks nothing at all like his dad. Go figure!

Posted at 11:44PM on Apr 29th 2008 by Noah

36. David Cook is the idol for this season. I just wish we were able to vote off some of the judges like Paula (the dimwit", Randy dfor calling everyone "DAWG" (learn a new word dude), and Simon (keep him) at least he's hones and what he said about David Archuletta is true. He picked the right song "AMERICA" to keep his sorry a-z-z in the competition, because he really sucked tonight.

Posted at 12:39AM on Apr 30th 2008 by Noah