Little (Brooke) White Lies

1. Oh come on give her a break

Posted at 9:11AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Donna

2. Can anyone gag me with a spoon? how many times are people going to fall for her sad puppy dog face every time? She's playing everybody. Wake up! She's a phony!

Posted at 9:16AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Tina

3. FIRST?????

Posted at 9:13AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by kc

4. Give me a break.She's playing everyone. Oh my gosh! people wake up and smell the crap.

Posted at 9:15AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Tina

5. Well I think it is time for Brook to call it a day. It must be horrible standing up there and at times singing songs that are not your favorite ones. I can see how your mind can just go "blank." These are not professional people. Give her a break. I still think she needs to go. I think she will be eliminated tonight.

Posted at 9:19AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by lori

6. She did not forget the words the first time! The timing was not right the first time she asked to start over.

Posted at 9:16AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by moblueeyes

7. The first time wasn't because she forgot the lyric, it's because she was off key...

Posted at 9:18AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by EB

8. Exactly, TMZ !! That's what I was thinking when I heard that lie come straight out of her mouth !! And to boot, no one immediately called her on it !! Ryan, as host, hould have been all over her for that one. Or maybe Paula should have defended her initial critique to say it was the SECOND time that she stopped and restarted her performance on the show. Brooke is becoming more and more unhinged every week. I sure hope this is the week that she goes. I just can't take it anymore !!!

Posted at 9:18AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by IdolFan

9. This chicks a Liar & has a big mouth, Brooke, CYA

Posted at 9:18AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Biff

10. You are wrong!!! She did not forget the lyrics the first time. It was either a timing issue or she began in the wrong key....either way she was note lying last night. in fact, i think she is one of the truly honest people left in the world. I guess this is why people want to attack her....

Posted at 9:21AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Amy

11. Actually, the first time she goofed up weeks ago wasn't due to forgetting the words, it was due to messing up on the piano. So it was in fact the first time the words got away from her. Here tmz goes again stretching the truth...I'd expect nothing less. Also, love her or hate her, she's the only one left on the show with any personality.

Posted at 9:22AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Travis

12. .


Off-Key, hesitated, whatever... it was a MISTAKE, and there are other much more talented people up on that stage that are also much more "Professional...". Sorry she had to miss her sisters' wedding, but now is Brooke's time to say "Adieu..." and I really, really like Brooke White!! She has a great style and a Carol King-type presence, but her time is over... now.

Posted at 9:22AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Kate

13. Brooke is the most annoying person on AI since Sanjaya. Who the hell told her it's cute for a 40 something grown woman to pout like a 5 year old? Kick her pasty, untoned, skinny, whiney ass to the curb.

Posted at 9:24AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by CAN'T STAND BROOKE THE DRAMA QUEEN

14. I think she said it "tongue in cheek" folks!!!!!

Posted at 9:25AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Vicki in Canada

15. Brooke didn't forget the words the first time she messed up.......... he voice was cracking and she sounded like crap so she stopped after a few notes. Either way, she is the only contestant who has screwed up twice now, the 17 year old forgot Several words in a song on live TV and I think he sucks and he is the one truely playing everyone! I like Brooke and I don't think it's fair that Idol, which I really enjoy watching makes them sing music they don't even like or know. They can show their range while singing their kind of music. I hope David Cook get voted off soon............ I think he's the best and I don't want him to have to be tied to Idol for any longer then he has to be. HE's awesome!

Posted at 9:50AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Krisann