31. ...nothing like beating up on someone who was just nervous for a sec and forgot her words, to get a few extra readers, right tmz! Don't you have anyone better than some hostile misogynist to write your news clips, tmz....

Posted at 10:14AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Chantal

32. She screwed up, so what? Doenat anyone else in this world screw up?

Posted at 10:18AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by john

33. I use to love Brooke but now I find her soooo annoying. She's always making stupid looking faces and she never looks at the judges or Ryan...what is to her left? Whatever it is, its apparently more interesting then everything else to her. She's annoying because she always has something to say like last week when Simon said that Kristy Lee Cook was the one who was leaving, or when anyone says something to her, she over talks everyone. Keep your mouth shut already. If you can't handle critique then you're really on the wrong show! As for her messing up...she did it twice, no matter the reason, it was still a mess. If you were at a concert and the band had to stop and start even 2 times, you'd be a little annoyed with it. Either you got it or you don't and she doesn't, It's live. Keep going. David Archulette did the rigt thing when he messed up, he kept going and caught up to the real lyrics.

I hope they get rid of Brooke soon because she makes me sick.

Posted at 10:23AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Bye bye sad face

34. She reminds me of someone I once dated...Manipulator

Posted at 10:26AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Ma

35. All she does is yap yap when the judges critique her performances. She talks over them, it's almost like watching The View !!!

Posted at 10:29AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Hillary

36. it isn't a lie. The first time she started again was to get the proper pitch with the piano, it had nothing to do with forgetting the lyrics.

Posted at 10:29AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by E

37. she didn't forget the lyrics, tmz idiots. she just needed to start over due to her pitch or something. i used to think that tmz was less jerkey then perezhilton. not anymore!!

Posted at 10:31AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by rita

38. People sure were not this hard on David A when he forgot the lyrics! Big deal, it happens I would rather see boring sitting all the time Jason go this week he is the same every week

Posted at 10:33AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Star

39. TMZ, why are you in the business of trying to destroy people? Answer the question losers? This "story" is a complete and utter exaggeration. She didn't forget her lyrics to the song in March, she repeated it because she was off in timing. Get it straight, if it were you, you'd get it straight. I am SO sick of your lies and shallow BS. Your "company" ought to be put out of business, you're in people's faces, you can't wait to tear someone down. Why don't you talk about yourselves, fat, lying desperate people you are - who didn't have a shot at getting real jobs.

Posted at 10:34AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Disappear for the good of the country

40. TMZ, get your fact straight. You can't show a clip of her saying she forgot the words the first time because it never happened. She restarted for other reasons, she did not say on last nights show that she never restarted a song before.
Brooke is a talented girl who obviously finds the pressure hard to take.

Posted at 10:38AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by stella

41. Its just haters trying to come up with something negative thats all.... There is much more to complain about with David A and Jason for sure!

Posted at 10:40AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Star

42. (Bye bye sad face).....Your speaking my language. Its good to see someone with a brain
in the comments section. Brooke White needs to go, See you later
Brooke...I'm counting down the hours till she is gone...

The show is to find the next great pop star, and guess what...YOU MESS UP (TWICE)...YOU DON'T DESERVE ANY SYMPATHY!!!

You know what your getting into with this show, its been 7 seasons. SHOW UP OR GO HOME....NO EXCUSES....

Posted at 10:41AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Rick Roll

43. Come on TMZ... You are not being honest. She started off key with the first incident. Big difference!

Posted at 10:44AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Christine

44. I'm not a religious person, but I am PRAYING that Jason Castro gets the boot. That boy can't sing, and the only reason he's still on there is because the young girls think he's cute. Give me a break people! When you watch the show, look away from the TV and listen, if you can picture hearing that voice on the radio, then the person deserves to stay. Jason should have been gone a few weeks ago.

Posted at 10:45AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by rfasoccermom

45. she needs to be medicated- she has some serious emotional issues

Posted at 10:49AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by BA33