After last night's disastrous, forgetful performance, Brooke White said the words had never gotten away from her on "Idol" before ... oh really? Because it felt like Groundhog Day to us.
Nothing like fibbing for a little sympathy to get a few extra, much needed votes, right?
61. She did not forget the lyrics previously. SHe started the song in the wrong key. Two totally different things.
Posted at 2:49PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by becky
62. 4 this girl to go HOME-Syesha rocked the house-out!
Posted at 11:16AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Its time...
63. I love Brooke. She is the sweetest person ever. I think she has true talent but is just too nervous at this stage of the game. Singing a brand new song that nobody ever has sung on stage before, is very difficult. She was alot better in the beginning because the pressure was not so hard. She is just too delicate and shy to handle that pressure. She can sing, but she needs certain material to show off her talent. I am with her 100% no matter what happens. I wish her the best in her future career and I think people should just shut-up and leave her alone. She has really tried hard, but her best has not been good enough against the talent on the show. The two Davids will make it to the end.
I will miss Brooke though, I just think she is special.
Posted at 11:19AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Zee
64. She started on the wrong note in March,,,,,,last night was the lyrics.
Posted at 11:54AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by johnny
65. TMZ, you apparently don't watch the show. The last do-over was because she started in the wrong key, not because she lost the lyric. You're correct that she has had two "false starts," but to suggest that she was Lying is totally incorrect sensationalism on your part.
Posted at 11:19AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Annie
66. This whole post is ridiculous. Brooke did NOT LIE. She started off that first song wrong and corrected herself. The 2nd time, she actually went blank on the lyrics. TMZ, shame on you for trying to make this girl look bad.
And the worse thing is, you have many folks in here thinking she is a liar and she's not.
Posted at 11:22AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Brooke is not a liar
67. Do you guys even watch the show you comment on? Another story you got completely wrong.
Posted at 11:22AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Robinest
68. oh;come on anyone could've made that mistake i bet you have lair.i voted for two hrs.last night kept two phones going for her.
Posted at 11:38AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by shirley wheeler
69. it's a shame because i did like her, but after seeing her last night i started to see how fake everyone was saying she is.
Posted at 11:28AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Lovie
70. Time for Brooke to go.
Posted at 11:29AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by vj-dj
71. I think all of the contestants this year stink! I've never heard so many flubs and squacks come out of a group in my life! Can we rewind and start all over.. Like say In season one.. And just give it all up?
Posted at 11:30AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by erin
72. TMZ LIES!!! The first time, she did not forget the lyric, she started off in on the wrong key. Completely DIFFERENT from forgetting the lyrics. WHY MUST TMZ EXAGGERATE AND LIE?
Posted at 11:34AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Lorita
73. I have said it many times - I think Brooke should have been voted off long ago. She is a phony as was stated already. She is not the best singer - she always has something to say back to the judges - just doesn't know when to keep her mouth shut. I had said it in the past and still believe that she knows someone on the show because it appears she has been pushed from the beginning, she stays long after a better singer has been voted off and the most important incident is when her sister was getting married - she should have been voted off that week - she was even nervous about her performance after the judges citiqued it but the next day she came out so happy stating that she was going to miss the wedding "depending on the vote" and guess what she stayed - seems to me someone let her know it was ok that she would be around to torture the viewers one more week.
Posted at 11:38AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Trotsy471
74. she didnt "lose her lyrics" the first time you retards...go back and watch the tape. the judges even commented on it. WOW
Posted at 11:40AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by whit
75. If she gets voted off tonight maybe she can be on the show "don't forget the lyrics".
Posted at 11:45AM on Apr 23rd 2008 by dawg
ElinNordegren fight MichaelJackson MileyCyrus ErinAndrews crash KateGosselin accident DomesticViolence suv TigerWoods photos PeepingTom lawsuit video photo FireHydrant CelebrityPictures latoyajackson pictures LindsayLohan football shopping gallery voicemail paparazzi rihanna CarriePrejean AdamLambert BurglarBunch gossip propofol twilight KristenStewart Dr.ConradMurray xxx house LamarOdom BritneySpears MariaShriver JaimeeGrubbs divorce NationalEnquirer TaylorSwift lax CelebrityGossip muffingate FloridaHighwayPatrol tree BarackObama mistress ParkingTicket australia TilaTequila HulkHogan butt dui JonKatePlus8 LosAngeles JonGosselin octomom contest TaxLien vote RobertPattinson naked ArnoldSchwarzenegger celebrity NadyaSuleman prize FHP DebbieRowe sextape 911Call court
'Memba Them?! 
