After last night's disastrous, forgetful performance, Brooke White said the words had never gotten away from her on "Idol" before ... oh really? Because it felt like Groundhog Day to us.
Nothing like fibbing for a little sympathy to get a few extra, much needed votes, right?
91. Trisha... what do you know about David Cook and an attiude... thats a little hypocritical to say others dont know when you dont either!
Posted at 1:09PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Star
92. For those that were correct, in that it was the first time she lost the lyrics, pat yourself on the back. The other time that the writer is refering to was clearly a beginning in the wrong key which she immediately corrected. When you are a professional writer, you should know what you are talking about before you say someone is a liar. Brooke is certainly not the best singer at this point, but I believe she is a very good singer, beautiful, and the kind of nice person I would trust children with. I've been in the music business for 35 years and learned a long time ago that it is not always the best singer that becomes famous. People relate to "nice". It won't surprise me if Brooke survives for another week.
Posted at 1:21PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by PLATO
93. She didn't forget the words on Every Breath - she was just "off". If the the person who posted this had any musical ability he/she would understand what that's like. The judges commended her for it. Even Simon said he would have done the same thing last night.
It's Seyesha's time to go home. She had ONE good night and that was because she's better suited for musical theatre - which is fine. But her time on AI is up.
Posted at 1:41PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Kelley
94. So, my brother works for Fox and frequents a place where all the Idol hopefuls and judges hang out. Apparently Brooke and Simon are an 'item' and were not trying to hide it the last time they were all hanging out!!! Look into it TMZ!!!
Posted at 1:36PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by InHollyweird
95. As a vocalist, I can tell you that she did not forget the words on the first song where she was playing piano. It is quite obvious that she mistakenly started singing in the wrong key.
Posted at 1:46PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Nicki
96. She is a no talent, talk back to the judges cry baby...can her ass................
Posted at 1:51PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by minnieux
97. She DIDN'T forget the words the first time, she was playing the piano and the timing was off. She is MUCH better than Jason Castro. Come on!! Jason's time should have been up before Michael Johns'. If anyone should go tonite, it should be Jason. And then Brooke NEXT week.
Posted at 1:59PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by debi
98. Here comes Star, defending David Cook again ....... big girl, time to get off the computer and wash your cooch.
Lay off Jason Castro - the subject is about Brooke!
Posted at 2:01PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Who cares
99. REMEMBER FOLKS - someone has to go home tonight - me thinks it will be her!
Posted at 2:03PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Demi
100. Please can't we just get her off the show. She makes me sick It is time for her to go . Evey week i hope she goes and she' still here like a bad dream
Posted at 10:11AM on Apr 24th 2008 by sick of brooke
101. She didn't forget the words last time - she started on the wrong note.
STILL - she should NOT have tried to justify or gloss over the mess up - a mistake is a mistake. Admit it, say whoops and MOVE ON.
Posted at 3:11PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Nicole
102. Hey "byebyesadface and "joni" and all the rest of you perfectionists who keep going on and on about how much she talks back to the judges, she DIDN'T SAY A WORD TO THE JUDGES LAST NIGHT, AND LOOKED RIGHT AT THEM, ESPECIALLY PAULA!!!!!!!!
You probably didn't even see the show last night, because you have no idea what went on, and are so biased or whatever that you just hate her just to hate her. Or because you like another contestant better.
She didn't say a word last night, and you know what? This isn't a karaoke competition (Rick Roll) where you're out if you mess up, or precious David Archuletta would have been out a long time ago.
It's a competition of amateurs, or at least that's what it's supposed to be, who are probably not used to this kind of pressure. Judge someone by their performance, not how they look, or their silly faces, or whatever. Her performance actually was pretty good.
Posted at 3:19PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by tsientsien
103. She did NOT forget the lyric the first itme. She SAID she started in the wrong key, and that's obvious if you watch the replay. Geez....
Posted at 4:03PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Veronica
104. Who cares.. apparently you do since you keep having some attitude with what I say Funny that I bother you.. anyway Jason does suck I agree with a lot of the people saying so, and David Cook will win it Kat McPhee forgot her lyrics and she ended up in the top 2 David A forgot his and for some stupid reason will be in the top 2 so it doesnt matter judges have favorites and thats how people seem to vote... Brook DIDNT talk at all when the judges were talking last night either
Posted at 4:28PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Star
105. TMZ I'm disappointed in you... she was not lying, two totally different situations. Still looks bad for her that she's goofed up on live tv twice, but let's not call her a liar!! No reason for that...
Posted at 4:20PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Alexandra
KhloeKardashian nude MichaelJackson lawsuit MileyCyrus Dr.ConradMurray police TigerWoods taxes crash photos twilight divorce photo JoeJackson accident MichaelBarrett CarriePrejean octomom NadyaSuleman suv oprah paparazzi arrested SexTape ElinNordegren xxx video court ParisHilton gossip JonGosselin australia propofol HulkHogan robertpattinson extortion fight dui AdamLambert hospital TaxLien Rihanna 911Call shopping pictures boot ChrisBrown football DjAm MissUniverse gay lax celebrity MariaShriver BritneySpears DougReinhardt house cops vivid ErinAndrews JonKatePlus8 CelebrityPictures JanetJackson TilaTequila NationalEnquirer NewMoon winner ChildSupport prison vote DebbieRowe paparazzo prize nfl
Hot Vegas 
