Little (Brooke) White Lies

106. She sucks! has always too much to say! honey,you are there to sing not to talk! no one cares what you have to say!
seems to me like no matter what is going on she always has to say something-ALWAYS!!!! I can't stand her!
her voice is OK but nothing spacial and her face is just weird!!!!
I hope we will say bye bye to Brooke 2night!!!!!
CARLY-you go girl!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted at 5:34PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Jess

107. She didn't forget the lyrics the first time - she just started an octave too high and wouldn't have been able to hit the notes. David Archuleta screwed his up and he is still america's little f'n sweetheart - gag me please! David will get a contract regardless how Idol turns out - give her a chance!

Posted at 9:04AM on Apr 24th 2008 by Sarah Z

108. Actually, calling someone a liar in the press and on television is a pretty big accusation.
And since you (TMZ) are wrong on this one, it's actually slander.

I hope that someone advises her to take legal action against TMZ.

And the comparrison between Carly Smithson and Cass Elliot was just plain bizzare.

I hope that Brooke sues your fannies off.

Posted at 5:54PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by tsientsien

109. Losing the lyric and a false start (coming in too soon or too late) are quite different. She wasn't lying. And the performance itself was much better than the judges gave her credit for. Her interpretation was beautiful.

Posted at 6:16PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Kathy

110. I see I’m the only one who thinks this season is dull. I try and remember to tune in and then I find myself changing the station. I don’t find myself rooting for anyone. Brooke is a pretty girl and I liked her initially, but her voice just isn’t very good. If I have to hear her say “I love you too” back to the crowd one more time I’m going to be sick.

Posted at 5:51PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by emme

111. TMZ, are you dumb? She didn't forget the lyrics when she started with Every Breath You Take. She felt she didn't start off good so she started over. Big difference!

Posted at 6:01PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Balistyx

112. She didn't forget the words the first time she stopped and started. She didn't like the way it sounded. Oh TMZ, making drama where there is none....

Posted at 6:53PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Whatever

113. The didn't flub the line the first time. She started out very flat and so stopped.

Posted at 7:36PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by mark

114. You know I actually graduated with Brooke and performed with her on stage several times in high school and to tell the truth she is the MOST sincere person on that stage. She is genuinely sweet, kind and probably one of the BEST people I have ever known.

Posted at 7:17PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by BrookeIsTheBest in Mesa, AZ

115. #108, I believe that Brooke is sincere....................but I also do not feel she has a strong voice. She should already have been gone before now. Others who are now history were better performers than Brooke. Brooke is probably leaving tonight.......

Posted at 7:28PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Susan B

116. Well, I always feel bad each week when someone goes home, but I am voting for Carly Smithson...............Carly is awesome with a powerful voice. Brooke comes off as a sweet person, but.................

Posted at 7:32PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Denise

117. Does anyone know Brooke's REAL age? She's definitly NOT 24. How could she have fooled them like that? Did they let her slide in? They can just let her slide right out... NOW!!!

Posted at 7:39PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Mamasita

118. Actually she is 24. Mamasita, more like Mamaputa! O si te queda mejor la putamadre!

Posted at 8:23PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by BrookeIsTheBest in Mesa, AZ

119. TMZ! I am taking it that you don't watch all of the shows! The first time she started the song on the wrong key. If you really paid attention to the show you would have known this and would have made a complete ASS of yourselves AGAIN.
Brooke did a wonderful job with her song last night, she isn't going anywhere yet!

Posted at 8:22PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Mewithanopinionthatmatters

120. ummmmmmmmmmmmmmm No TMZ ----

I'm an avid reader and I usually appreciate your reporting but that was NOT a lie.

She messed up on key the first time --- definitely she did not lose the lyric. She started to sing "Every breathe you ta..." I'm sure she knew it was the word "take," that is the name of the frickin' song!! And that is how the song is supposed to start.

Posted at 10:08PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Lisa