Little (Brooke) White Lies

121. She didn't forget words first time! She wasn't in the right key, so she started over! Damn get it right!

Posted at 11:47PM on Apr 23rd 2008 by Melissa

122. Brooke has such an annoying personality, it's hard to even hear her music. She comes across as a very false person, babyish and amazingly self righteous. Please spare us all her drama. Paula is right, professionals don't start over. Let's move on to the real talent.

Posted at 11:24PM on Apr 24th 2008 by notimpressed

123. 15 minutes are up. NEXT !!!

Posted at 3:18AM on Apr 24th 2008 by The-Rex

124. Honestly, Brooke needs to go. She should have gone a long time ago. I can't believe that she is in the top five. Does America really think that she is the next big star. She and Jason deserved to be in the bottom two last night. Brooke has absolutely no stage presence.

Posted at 7:43PM on Apr 24th 2008 by Kristy

125. Brooke should have been off the show right from day one. Unfortunately, Simon always gives her some kind of kudos when he knows she stinks, and then America votes for her because she becomes some lap dog after she makes huge mistakes and makes those chooch faces to get the American vote. It is working, she is still there and so is Jason, although, not an AI, I like Jason, but my money is on David Cook. Also In past idol shows you were criticised for stopping and starting but apparently Brooke can do no wrong. If she is in the bottom two, I am going to vote for her all night long so she can win and become a flop like Taylor Hicks.

Posted at 6:39AM on Apr 30th 2008 by tweetybird31

126. This girl is a FAKE! She has a stupid "pitty me" look on her face the whole time, she is a cry baby who always plays the victim card. This girl is a complete wanna be who is so incredibly lucky her time is up like a month ago. She acts like she is 50 and dresses like she is back in the 60's. Why does she always bite her lip and look like she is going to cry? I'll tell you.... one word PSYCHO! Look in those pouty eyes, she is crazy and she will snap..... I look forward to her demise.

Posted at 8:07PM on Apr 25th 2008 by lisa2

127. First time she started over because she was in the wrong key. Second time was for the lyrics!! If you were a singer, you'd be able to understand that, and hear the different key after she started over for every breath you take.

Posted at 4:16AM on Apr 26th 2008 by jaymez428

128. SHE DIDNT FORGET THE WORDS THE FIRST TIME, SHE WAS OFF BEAT! SHE IS HUMAN!

Posted at 5:46PM on Apr 26th 2008 by tamara denver

129. Brooke White DID NOT forget the lyrics twice on AI. She told the truth. The first time, she did NOT forget the lyrics. She hit the wrong key on the piano. She new that after "every breath" came "you take". So she did NOT lie. She restarted twice but she said "I forgot the lyric. First time I have done that on this show" And she said the truth!

Posted at 8:49PM on Apr 27th 2008 by tootysams

130. Wow - I see a lot of talent-jealousy going on here. This girl (Brooke) is not only talented, she is the only person on this cast that i would trust to make decisions about anything that was important to me. We're talking honesty, integrity, maturity, straight-talking and a true role model for youth (an Idol). All the remaning Idols are fantastic people with great talent. I know a little about this 24-year old girl and I can objectively say her "flubbed-up" Andrew Lloyd Webber song is the only one that I have been humming all week. Hats off to all the Idols and a big hand for Brooke.

Posted at 6:30PM on Apr 29th 2008 by jacques

131. Stick it Jacques. That beyotch sucks so bad that she has lines around her mouth.

Posted at 6:54PM on Apr 29th 2008 by Dara

132. Is everyone here blind to the special friendship between Ryan and Brooke????

Posted at 11:04PM on May 2nd 2008 by Dee from Detroit