"Idol" Wannabes Inducted into Hall of Lame

16. COOK SHOULD HAVE BEEN GONE! HE'S ALREADY MADE 6 ALBUMS. HE DOESN'T DESERVE TO BE IN THE COMPETITION!

Posted at 7:24PM on May 6th 2008 by LA

17. Putting Fantasia in the same category as Taylor Hicks is disgraceful. They are on opposite ends of the talent spectrum

Posted at 12:51AM on May 20th 2008 by Rails

18. Come on people. This hole AI show is so rigged its not even funny. I don't see this show lasting much longer. I seen better talent on open MIC nights.

American Idol, can't you do better.

Posted at 8:21PM on May 6th 2008 by lady1

19. Umm, what happened to the comments posted an hour ago? I had two and now there gone. There were a lot more an hour ago! ???!!!!

Posted at 8:22PM on May 6th 2008 by ohreli

20. I think Randy is a racist. He keeps trying to tip it in the black chicks favor.

Posted at 8:25PM on May 6th 2008 by jFp

21. Jason sucks. His dreds can't sing or sell records. He is lazy. He can't even turn his head. He sleepwalks through all of this. He was even yawning when they first walked out on the stage. Is he high? He's a no talent loser and nobody will ever hear of him again after the teeny boppers are done texting in for his hair.

Posted at 8:29PM on May 6th 2008 by LOSER JASON IS LAZY

22. HEY!!! I just figured out who David Archuleta reminds me of!!!!!

Look up in wiki the Vorta named Weyoun. Wiki even has the picture of him posted.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weyoun

Posted at 8:34PM on May 6th 2008 by jFp

23. love david cook!

Posted at 8:46PM on May 6th 2008 by elisa

24. This show is so done. Nobody I know even watches more than the city-to-city auditions in the early weeks, because it just gets boring later. The lamest acts have been getting through since about Season 2 or 3.The songs are usually the most maudlin hits of all eras, and when they do use good songs it's cringe-worthy. Plus country singers keep getting through - that should be saved for Country Idol or whatever it's called - not to mention all this Christian music ("Jesus Take the Wheel"?! Ick! Doesn't the Bible have something to say about false idols?) The judges keep saying this is a singing contest, and the producers say it's not rigged, but ever since the heinous "Soul Patrol" season, it sure hasn't featured the most talented singers, and the voting system is so badly flawed that nobody really trusts the results anymore.

Posted at 8:51PM on May 6th 2008 by luvangel

25. FLAVOR FLAV RULES....HE IS THE AFRICAN-AMERICAN IDOL THAT WILL WIN....

THE REST ALL SUCK!!

Posted at 8:52PM on May 6th 2008 by NUMbnuts

26. David Archuleta, the next Josh Groban...just sayin'. All of their songs sound exactly the same. It's VERY clear that DA is Simon's fave...there is absolutely nothing original about any of his songs, and he gets rave reviews.

Posted at 9:45PM on May 6th 2008 by see ya

27. I think that David Archuleta is by far the best of the lot. He has a beautiful voice. It's hard to believe he's just 17!

Posted at 10:02PM on May 6th 2008 by Lena

28. Yippeeeee, finally they get to choose from an awesome set of songs. That should make the show wayyyyy better. Glad someone is thinking after the last two lame shows with horrible music.

Posted at 10:13PM on May 6th 2008 by lindy

29. David Archuleta is good IF you have no imagination and prefer the same old vanilla flavor week after gruelling week. He sounds the same in every song. He (his father) picks BOOOORING music. He has done absolutely nothing that could sell. Every church in America has somebody that sounds exactly like him. If you like mormon tabernacle choir boy sound... then he is for you. Think outside the box.

Posted at 10:34PM on May 6th 2008 by The same goes for Josh Groban.. he sounds like an idiot savant

30. Um, Duran Duran are NOT in the Rock 'n Roll Hall of Fame... so how was David Cook able to do "Hungry Like the Wolf"???

Posted at 11:34PM on May 6th 2008 by holden22