32. I am saddened that David A didn't win. But I think David A. will have a wonderful future ahead of him--- just like another "second" winner-- Clay Aiken. And "another" who wasn't even a "second", the very, very talented Jennifer Hudson who won an Academy Award. You go, David A.!!!

Posted at 10:09AM on May 22nd 2008 by Jayne

33. Thank God a real man won and not some homosexual little sissy who is a disgrace to america and the male race as a whole. Ship Archelletta off to france where all the other homo's live!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

Posted at 10:14AM on May 22nd 2008 by archelletta is a homo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

34. Archuleta sounded the same every week. He sounds the same over and over. He did imagine Tues to be safe since it was a great hit weeks before.I have to give him credit, the kid will go a long way. . Cook took the chance of doing something he hadn't done on the show instead of the easy way out..

Posted at 10:11AM on May 22nd 2008 by d

35. Archuleta sounded the same every week. He sounds the same over and over. He did imagine Tues to be safe since it was a great hit weeks before.I have to give him credit, the kid will go a long way. . Cook took the chance of doing something he hadn't done on the show instead of the easy way out..

Posted at 10:11AM on May 22nd 2008 by d

36. TAYLOR HICKS has a lot of talent and carisma. It's too bad he's becoming the butt of Idol jokes and jabs. I'm sure Taylor is doing well and we'll see where the rest of these winners end up. Where's Kelley Clarkson now? TAYLOR RULES !

Posted at 10:11AM on May 22nd 2008 by BL

37. David A. will be the perfect Disney or ABC Family act to take the pressure off Miley Cyrus. His voice is fine he just shows no originality. David Cook should and did win. The voting likely was based on the entire competition and not just one night.

Posted at 1:31PM on May 22nd 2008 by Mark

38. I think the right David won, the other David did not have any diversity , He could only sing slow songs, there was nothing different or different about him, Great voice absolutely, different no. you seen what Cook did with the songs he had every one he made them different and sound like something he had wrote and directed.

Posted at 10:16AM on May 22nd 2008 by Mick

39. I told you he would win and I see you took my link down to the spoiler hmmmmmm..

Posted at 10:16AM on May 22nd 2008 by J_Man

40. How incredibly stupid are you folks. Archie is has baby voice, with no depth. He is just another back street boy or any other whiney kid. I am questing "The Real Judge"'s hearing. Nothing special? I believe you are talking about Archie. Cook has a fabulous voice. Archie certainly has a future with Disney. He will be fine with the other little boys!!!

Posted at 10:40AM on May 22nd 2008 by Anita

41. Both Davids have talent. I think that David Cook has greater sex appeal. The fact that he chose more uncommon songs for their final showdown may have appealed to more AI fans. DC should be better able to handle the fame, etc., that comes with this win than DA, who is, as someone else posted, is better suited at this point in time, for the Disney Channel (based on his age and life experience). Please don't diss Doughtery. He has done more than any AI "winner," except perhaps Kelly Clarkson. His songs are always on the radio. When was the last time you heard: Stoddard, Jordin, Clay Aiken, etc., on the air? It's interesting how those who didn't even come in second, that is, Doughtery and Jennifer Hudson, have gone onto more fame, etc., than "winners."

Posted at 10:40AM on May 22nd 2008 by nan1

42. First things first is this poll referring that Kelly Clarkson is the biggest thing to come out of the winner? Because Kelly has nothing on Carrie. Second for those that think its rigged dont you think that they want Archuleta to win all year long. I mean come on he judges praised him like there was no tomorrow. I will give it to him that he has a nice voice but really is the slow same crap better then a guy who can pretty much do anything?

Posted at 10:30AM on May 22nd 2008 by Joe Blow

43. I THINK DADDY HAD SOMETHING TO DO WITH DAVID A.'s FAILURE TO WIN. PEOPLE GOT TURNED OFF BY THAT.
IF DAVID A GETS AN OPEN CONTRACT, (INSTEAD OF IDOL CONTRACT), WATCH OUT! DADDY CAN TAKE DOWN HIS SON'S CAREER, BEFORE IT GETS STARTED. WASN'T DIANA D'GARMO'S MOM THE SAME WAY?

Posted at 10:26AM on May 22nd 2008 by i\\\'m someone\\\'s daddy

44. We love him!!!!!!

FREE DIET PROGRAM FOR WOMEN :-)

Posted at 10:32AM on May 22nd 2008 by Kanda

45. I AGREE, AI is a set up and the producers decide who wins. It's obvious Archuleta had the richer and purer voice. He lost because of his father's interference.

Posted at 10:28AM on May 22nd 2008 by AI is set up

Previous 15 Comments | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Most Recent | Next 15 Comments