One of These Women Was on "American Idol"

1. Carrie is as sweet as sugar.

Posted at 9:30AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Mali Bu

2. Carrie rocks! All the young girls out there should take lessons from her.

Posted at 9:35AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Mike B.

3. She is such a good person, inside and out. I would like to think that they are more people out their like her and less of the Paris and Lindsay's. Her (carrie) mom should also be giving a gold star.

Posted at 9:49AM on Jul 25th 2008 by ANGEL EYES

4. This young lady, Carrie Underwood, is a role model. She has talent, and a wonderfully, genuine personality. Her boobs, and other parts aren't splashed across the Internet, in tabloids, or in playboy.

She has a great future ahead of her, and she's smart enough to be herself through it.

Posted at 10:09AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Adrianna

5. I agree Carrie is a wonderful role model. I enjoy listening to her music with my daughters. But the comment about Taylor Hicks makes no sense...are you saying he should be homeless or are you suggesting he should be giving to the homeless? That comment really spoils an otherwise good story.

Posted at 10:36AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Hillary

6. Wow TMZ...another fake picture. It's all in the shadows. the homeless womans face is casting a shadow on the pole behind her, while the shadows on the ground are going the other way. So instead of pretending to be a good person carrie, actually help someone out....instead of faking it.

Posted at 10:42AM on Jul 25th 2008 by FAKE

7. Hey, FAKE, get a life. Carrie has better things to do than create fake photos of herself being nice. She was taking some family members to lunch. That's all.

Posted at 11:03AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Lana

8. TAYLOR HICKS IS APPEARING ON BROADWAY IN GREASE. Carrie Underwood is young and blond. Taylor Hicks appeals to a different fan base and cannot make the kind of deals or endorsements that Carrie Underwood can. Stop making negative comments against Taylor Hicks. He is doing JUST FINE.

Posted at 10:59AM on Jul 25th 2008 by liz smith

9. lmao i dont know who this girl is, but she's obviously a media whore (maybe just a whore). there's cameras around her so she gives money to the homeless. did she learn that from spencer and heidi?

Posted at 10:59AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Lindsey

10. haha that does look like nikki mckibbin!

Posted at 11:19AM on Jul 25th 2008 by thats right

11. very nice, i wish everyone would d this, is doesn't matter why they are homeless, we need to help them, some don't want any help, but those who do, we should help, GOD BLESS THOSE INNEED,

Posted at 11:32AM on Jul 25th 2008 by pattie

12. Um, Lindsey - do you live under a rock?!?! You don't know who Carrie Underwood is?!?! She's only won numerous awards - CMA's, Grammys, People's Choice - and the list goes on. And don't call her a whore - she one of the purest entertainers out there!! It does look a little staged, but with cameras following her all over the place and as someone mentioned, she was out to dinner with her family, she probably liked the homeless woman's sign. I give sometimes for originality.

"8. lmao i dont know who this girl is, but she's obviously a media whore (maybe just a whore). there's cameras around her so she gives money to the homeless. did she learn that from spencer and heidi?"

Posted at 11:42AM on Jul 25th 2008 by Jodi

13. YOUR AWESOME CARRIE! ALWAYS NICE TO HELP PEOPLE LESS FORTUNATE THAN WE ARE!

Posted at 11:46AM on Jul 25th 2008 by OBAMA HATER :)

14. Gotta love that Taylor Hicks. The 21st Century Liberace. Grayer and gayer every day.

Posted at 11:45AM on Jul 25th 2008 by chicken stripper

15. CARRY is one of the sweetest girls around, theres not a nasty bone in her body, who ever puts her down, needs help, or just plain haateful, i don't even like country music, but i know who she is, SHE ONE SWEET LADY.

Posted at 11:53AM on Jul 25th 2008 by pattie