One of These Women Was on "American Idol"

16. FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE FAKE. I love how generous she is, she lives in a huge house and has millions of dollars and she gave this girl maybe 20 bucks....she cares. She should win the nobel peace prize. but then again this pic is FAKE so whatev.......hahahahahaha

Posted at 12:05PM on Jul 25th 2008 by Lana

17. she only did it for the camera.

Posted at 12:04PM on Jul 25th 2008 by kari

18. HEY LANA! STFU!!!!!!!!!!! CARRIE UNDERWOOD ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She is awesome!!

Posted at 12:21PM on Jul 25th 2008 by Billie

19. Don't really care about Carrie but the homeless woman in question is a professional. She has worked the streets of Westwood on and off for years.

Posted at 3:59PM on Jul 25th 2008 by JLV

20. Carrie Underwood is awesome! And look at her, out shopping just like a normal person... and this woman has sold like 10 million CDs. Those no talents like Lauren Conrad and Heidi Montag can't pick up the newspaper at the end of their driveway without a posse of hangers'-on. You keep it real, Carrie... and keep making great music!

Posted at 1:13PM on Jul 25th 2008 by MarkScottMusic.com

21. fake is a nitwit. its obviously not fake. there are like 10 other pictures of her , she was going out to lunch before and stopped to give the woman money.

Posted at 3:42PM on Jul 25th 2008 by fake is stupid and bitter

22. this pic is obviously not fake. she has better things to do unlike other celebs she actually has a career. besides... there are like 10 other pics of her that day. not like that.

Posted at 3:42PM on Jul 25th 2008 by lana is a dumbass

23. CARRIE IS SUCH A SWEETHEART AND A ROLEMODEL

Posted at 2:20AM on Jul 26th 2008 by ava

24. She is so sweet. and Lindsey, Lana and whoever else wants to bash Carrie and say mean things get a life, cause you sure need one if you have nothing better to do then come bash a lovly ladie who so manny little girls look up too and deserves everything she has!!!

Posted at 4:30PM on Jul 25th 2008 by Vickie

25. Anyone who thinks these pics are fake was clearly born without a brain....

Carrie's amazing, love her music & love her! She's one of the few genuine artists out there.

Posted at 3:59PM on Jul 25th 2008 by JJ

26. Go Carrie!! She is so sweet-- she is always quietly giving money to charity and donating tickets, clothes, etc- to all sorts of charities all over the world. Carrie is one of the last nice celebs left-- and is a good example to all of us. :)

CARRIE ROCKS!

Posted at 6:29PM on Jul 25th 2008 by CarrieRocks!

27. this is not fake!she was out to dinner with family and carrie wouldn't stage this!carrie is sweet enough to give her money away to people in need!

Posted at 5:18PM on Jul 27th 2008 by Kayla Ruth

28. This bag lady is crazy, she is always in Westwood screaming and crying for money.

Posted at 1:45AM on Jul 28th 2008 by Nathan

29. Lindsey-

You are a cold-hearted BITCH! Please, go do something with your life. Just another person heating the Earth. I swear!

Posted at 4:57AM on Jul 28th 2008 by Rob

30. Lana-

What's with the "hahahahahaha?" What you said wasn't even one bit funny!

Hey, if you're envious of those who have money, then get off your ass and better yourself. OR throw yourself in front of a train. On second thought, the latter would be the best solution.

Posted at 7:22AM on Jul 28th 2008 by Rob